Plot Summary
Lakota's Quiet Refuge
Lakota, Wisconsin, is a rural crossroads where anonymity is cherished and the past lingers in the land. The town's history is one of hardship, resilience, and a stubborn refusal to be noticed by the outside world. Into this setting arrives Dr. Thomas Kennedy, a veterinarian fleeing the trauma and scandal of his wife's death. Seeking peace, he finds solace among the Amish and English farmers, trading his skills for eggs, produce, and the comfort of being left alone. But Lakota's quiet is fragile, and the arrival of extraordinary events will soon shatter its obscurity, drawing the world's gaze to this unlikely place.
Rachel's Tragic Legacy
Hannah Fisher, an Amish woman, reflects on her life: the pain of losing her first child, the joy of her daughter Rachel's birth, and the pride and anxiety of raising a beautiful girl in a community wary of vanity and temptation. Rachel's beauty and faith become both a blessing and a test, as Hannah's memories reveal the strictness of her upbringing and the complexities of Amish family life. The seeds of future tragedy are sown in these early years, as the community's values and Hannah's love for her daughter come into quiet conflict.
Exile and Shunning
When Rachel becomes pregnant out of wedlock and refuses to name the father, she is subjected to streng meidung—total shunning. Forced to leave her family, she finds refuge with the Widow Charlotte, an outsider who offers kindness when her own people will not. Rachel's exile is a wound that never heals for Hannah, who can only watch from across the river, singing lullabies into the night and stealing moments with her daughter and grandson, Jasper. The pain of separation and the rigidity of faith shape the lives of all involved, setting the stage for the next generation's struggles.
The Giant's Birth
Rachel's second pregnancy is marked by suffering and secrecy. When she goes into labor, it is Thomas Kennedy, the veterinarian, who is called to help. He delivers Gabriel, an impossibly large baby, moments before Rachel's death. The circumstances of Gabriel's birth become the stuff of local legend, and his survival is seen as both a miracle and an omen. Raised by his half-brother Jasper, Gabriel's origins are shrouded in mystery, and the community's whispers about his paternity and purpose only grow louder as he thrives.
Gabriel's Uncanny Growth
Gabriel grows at an astonishing rate, cared for by Jasper and watched over by Thomas. His size and strength are matched by a gentle nature and a unique bond with animals. As he moves through childhood, Gabriel's differences become more pronounced, drawing both awe and suspicion. He is a prodigy in the barn and on the ballfield, but his place in the community is always uncertain. The question of his father's identity and the meaning of his existence linger, even as he brings joy and wonder to those around him.
Baseball Prodigy
Gabriel's talents explode onto the local baseball scene, where his size and skill make him a legend before adolescence. Coaches and townsfolk marvel at his abilities, but his presence also stirs resentment and fear. As he advances through the leagues, breaking records and shattering expectations, Gabriel's fame begins to outgrow Lakota. The world beyond takes notice, and the pressures of attention, ambition, and belonging begin to weigh on him and those who love him.
Family, Faith, and Division
As Gabriel matures, the tensions between his Amish upbringing and the temptations of the English world intensify. His grandparents, Hannah and Josiah, struggle to guide him, torn between love and doctrine. Gabriel's work with Thomas and his friendships outside the community deepen his sense of difference. The family's unity is tested by grief, pride, and the inexorable pull of Gabriel's gifts. The boundaries between faith and freedom, tradition and change, are redrawn with every choice.
Football and Fame
High school football brings Gabriel new opportunities and new challenges. Under the guidance of Coach Beathard, he becomes a phenomenon, leading his team to unprecedented victories and drawing scouts, media, and crowds from across the country. The quiet of Lakota is shattered as the world descends, eager to witness the exploits of the Amish Giant. Gabriel's rise is meteoric, but it comes at a cost: the loss of privacy, the strain on family, and the growing sense that he is becoming a symbol rather than a person.
The World Descends
As Gabriel's legend grows, so does the intrusion of the outside world. Journalists, recruiters, and opportunists flood Lakota, transforming the town and its people. Gabriel is courted by colleges and brands, his every move scrutinized and commodified. The pressures of expectation and the lure of glory threaten to overwhelm him, while his family grapples with the consequences of his celebrity. The community's values are tested as never before, and Gabriel must navigate the treacherous terrain between destiny and desire.
Catastrophe on the Field
Gabriel's college football career at Wisconsin is cut short by a catastrophic injury—a brutal, career-ending leg amputation. The world watches in shock as the giant is brought low. The aftermath is a time of reckoning: for Gabriel, who must confront the loss of his identity and future; for his family, who must care for him in his vulnerability; and for the community, which must reconcile its pride with its compassion. The limits of strength, fame, and faith are laid bare in the face of suffering.
Aftermath and Reckoning
Gabriel returns home, struggling to adapt to life with a prosthesis and the end of his athletic dreams. The family and community rally to support him, but the challenges are immense. Old wounds resurface, secrets are revealed, and the meaning of forgiveness is tested. Gabriel's journey becomes one of self-discovery, as he seeks purpose beyond the field and the ring. The bonds of love, faith, and friendship are both strained and strengthened in the crucible of adversity.
Wrestling with Identity
Drawn into the world of professional wrestling, Gabriel reinvents himself as Anakim, the Amish Giant, captivating audiences around the globe. His fame reaches new heights, but so do the temptations and dangers of celebrity. The spectacle of his performances, the commodification of his identity, and the excesses of his new life threaten to consume him. Relationships are tested, and the search for meaning becomes ever more urgent as Gabriel's health begins to fail.
The Final Return
Stricken by an inoperable brain tumor, Gabriel returns to Lakota, blind and dying. The community closes ranks to care for him, with Hannah, Josiah, Thomas, and a host of friends and neighbors providing comfort and dignity in his final days. Old grievances are set aside, and the boundaries between Amish and English, family and stranger, dissolve in the face of mortality. Gabriel's son, Raphael, arrives with his mother, Bella, bringing a measure of hope and continuity even as the end approaches.
Death and Transcendence
Gabriel's death is marked by an extraordinary convergence of nature: birds, animals, and insects gather in a final, mysterious tribute. Surrounded by love, he slips away, his soul ascending in a vision that blurs the line between miracle and natural wonder. The community mourns, but also celebrates the life of a boy who was both a giant and a child, a symbol and a son. His funeral brings together all the threads of the story—faith, forgiveness, loss, and the enduring power of love.
Forgiveness and Farewell
In the aftermath of Gabriel's death, the characters reckon with their grief, their regrets, and their hopes for the future. Hannah returns to Josiah, seeking reconciliation and peace. Thomas prepares to leave Lakota, carrying with him the memories and lessons of his time among the Amish. The community, forever changed by Gabriel's presence, finds ways to honor his legacy and move forward. The story closes with a sense of hard-won wisdom: that life is complicated, forgiveness is essential, and love endures beyond even the greatest loss.
Characters
Hannah Fisher
Hannah is the emotional and moral center of the novel—a devout Amish woman whose life is shaped by loss, love, and the struggle to reconcile faith with the realities of the world. Her relationship with her daughter Rachel is marked by pride and sorrow, and her devotion to Gabriel is unwavering, even as it brings her into conflict with her community and husband. Hannah's psychological journey is one of humility, resilience, and eventual self-assertion. She is both nurturer and seeker, ultimately learning that forgiveness and love are more complex—and more necessary—than the certainties of doctrine.
Gabriel Fisher
Gabriel is the miraculous child at the heart of the story, born in tragedy and marked by extraordinary size and strength. Raised by his half-brother Jasper and watched over by Thomas, Gabriel is both a prodigy and an outsider, beloved for his kindness and uncanny bond with animals. As he grows, he becomes a local legend, a sports phenomenon, and eventually a global celebrity. Yet his journey is haunted by questions of identity, belonging, and purpose. Gabriel's arc is one of innocence, temptation, suffering, and, finally, transcendence—a life that touches and transforms everyone around him.
Thomas Kennedy
Thomas is a veterinarian who flees scandal and grief to find refuge in Lakota. His introverted nature and love for animals make him an outsider, yet he becomes deeply entwined with the Fisher family, especially Gabriel. Thomas's psychological landscape is shaped by loss, guilt, and a longing for connection. He serves as a bridge between Amish and English worlds, offering compassion and practical wisdom. His relationship with Hannah is one of deep, unspoken love and mutual respect, and his care for Gabriel is both redemptive and transformative.
Josiah Fisher
Josiah is Hannah's husband and Rachel's father, a man of few words and deep convictions. He embodies the strengths and limitations of Amish masculinity: hardworking, principled, and sometimes rigid. Josiah's love for his family is real but often expressed through duty rather than affection. He struggles with the changes Gabriel brings, the challenges to his authority, and the pain of loss. Ultimately, Josiah's capacity for forgiveness and humility allows for reconciliation and healing, even as he remains rooted in his faith.
Rachel Fisher
Rachel is Hannah and Josiah's daughter, whose beauty, faith, and tragic fate set the story in motion. Her exile and death are the crucible in which the family's loyalties and beliefs are tested. Rachel's refusal to name Gabriel's father and her endurance in the face of shunning reveal both strength and vulnerability. She is a symbol of the costs of rigid faith, but also of the enduring power of love and sacrifice.
Jasper Fisher
Jasper is Rachel's first son and Gabriel's half-brother, raised in exile and marked by the stigma of illegitimacy. He cares for Gabriel with selfless devotion, sacrificing his own prospects and happiness. Jasper's psychological burden is heavy—he is both protector and outcast, ultimately succumbing to despair. His suicide is a pivotal moment, underscoring the destructive power of shame and the need for compassion.
Billy Walton
Billy is the local tavern owner, a recovering alcoholic whose bar serves as a hub for gossip, camaraderie, and community. He is both comic relief and a source of hard-earned wisdom, narrating much of the town's history and Gabriel's rise. Billy's own struggles with addiction, regret, and redemption mirror the larger themes of the novel. His loyalty to Gabriel and the Fishers is unwavering, and his journey toward late-life love and self-acceptance is quietly moving.
Coach Trey Beathard
Trey is a Texan football coach who finds redemption in Lakota after losing everything to addiction and scandal. His recognition of Gabriel's talent and his guidance on the field are instrumental in Gabriel's rise to fame. Trey's own psychological arc is one of humility, recovery, and the search for meaning beyond victory. His letters to Gabriel and his presence at the end of the story highlight the importance of second chances and the dangers of ambition.
Absalom Yoder
Absalom is Hannah's father, a figure of authority, piety, and hidden darkness. His strictness and generosity mask a capacity for cruelty and, ultimately, sexual abuse. The revelation of his crimes is a shattering blow to the family and community, forcing a reckoning with the limits of forgiveness and the dangers of unchecked power. Absalom's legacy is one of both strength and devastation.
Bella Alvarez
Bella is Gabriel's college sweetheart and the mother of his son, Raphael. Her arrival at the end of Gabriel's life brings healing, continuity, and a measure of redemption. Bella's character is marked by resilience, compassion, and the ability to bridge worlds. Her presence ensures that Gabriel's legacy endures, not as a spectacle, but as a living, loving connection.
Plot Devices
Multiple Narrators and Shifting Perspectives
The novel employs a rotating cast of narrators—Hannah, Thomas, Billy, Trey, and others—each offering their own lens on events. This structure allows for a rich, polyphonic exploration of community, faith, and identity. The shifting perspectives create empathy and complexity, revealing the limitations of any single viewpoint and the ways in which stories are shaped by memory, bias, and longing.
Legend, Myth, and Exaggeration
Gabriel's life is surrounded by mythmaking, from the circumstances of his birth to the legends that grow around his feats. The novel plays with the tension between fact and folklore, showing how communities create meaning through storytelling, exaggeration, and the need for heroes. This device also interrogates the costs of being made into a symbol, and the ways in which individuals are both elevated and diminished by collective imagination.
Faith, Doubt, and Forgiveness
The narrative is structured around cycles of sin, punishment, and forgiveness—shunning, exile, confession, and reconciliation. The characters wrestle with the demands of faith, the pain of doubt, and the challenge of forgiving both others and themselves. The novel uses these plot devices to explore the limits of doctrine, the necessity of compassion, and the possibility of redemption even in the face of irreparable harm.
Nature as Witness and Miracle
The natural world is both setting and participant in the story, from the rivers and fields of Lakota to the miraculous gathering of animals at Gabriel's death. Nature serves as a silent witness to human suffering and joy, and, at key moments, as a source of wonder and transcendence. The blurring of the line between miracle and natural phenomenon is a recurring motif, inviting readers to question the boundaries of the possible.
Secrets, Revelations, and Generational Trauma
Hidden truths—about paternity, abuse, and the costs of silence—drive the narrative's emotional arc. The gradual revelation of Absalom's crimes, the true nature of Gabriel's parentage, and the unspoken wounds carried by each character create a sense of inevitability and catharsis. The novel uses these devices to explore the ways in which trauma is inherited, denied, and, ultimately, confronted.
Analysis
Life, and Death, and Giants is a sweeping, multi-generational novel that uses the extraordinary life of Gabriel Fisher—a literal giant born of tragedy and secrecy—to explore the tensions between community and individuality, faith and doubt, tradition and change. At its heart, the book is about the ways in which we are shaped by the stories we tell, the wounds we inherit, and the love we give and receive. The novel interrogates the costs of making someone into a symbol—how Gabriel's size, talent, and fame both elevate and isolate him, turning him into a spectacle even as he yearns for connection and meaning. Through its polyphonic structure and deep psychological insight, the book asks what it means to forgive, to belong, and to let go. It is a story about the limits of doctrine, the necessity of compassion, and the enduring power of love to heal even the deepest wounds. In a world obsessed with spectacle and difference, Life, and Death, and Giants offers a quiet, profound reminder that our greatest legacies are not in our feats, but in the lives we touch and the grace we extend to one another.
Last updated:
