Plot Summary
Baby Group Beginnings
Cora, a new mother in a small town, meets Sam at a baby group, bonding over their mutual disdain for another parent, "Broccoli Mom." Their alliance is sealed with a cinnamon toothpick and a shared sense of humor. Both are married, both are new to town, and both are quietly desperate for adult connection. The baby group, with its competitive, performative parenting, becomes the unlikely crucible for their friendship. Cora's home life is loving but routine, her husband Eliot supportive but distracted. The group's rituals—potty training debates, organic snacks, and awkward intimacy—set the stage for the emotional and psychological terrain that will define Cora and Sam's relationship. The seeds of longing and dissatisfaction are sown in these mundane, communal moments.
New Town, Old Longings
Cora's move from the city to a picturesque, middle-class town is meant to be a fresh start, but it leaves her feeling unmoored. The town's beauty—mountain views, waterfalls, art museums—contrasts with her sense of loneliness and the relentless demands of motherhood. Her husband, Eliot, is practical and loving, but their conversations circle around chores, repairs, and the logistics of family life. Cora's old friends are distant, her new acquaintances unsatisfying. She finds herself waiting for Sam in coffee shops, measuring other men against him, and feeling the ache of something missing. The town's charm cannot fill the void left by lost youth, ambition, and intimacy. Cora's longing for connection and meaning intensifies, setting her on a path toward emotional risk.
Toothpicks and Tensions
Sam's cinnamon toothpicks become a symbol of his idiosyncratic charm and the subtle flirtation between him and Cora. Their banter is laced with wit and a growing undercurrent of desire. Both are attentive parents, but their conversations at baby group and beyond reveal deeper frustrations with their marriages and the monotony of domestic life. Cora's husband, Eliot, is supportive but oblivious to her emotional needs, while Sam's wife, Jules, is competent and driven, yet distant. The tension between Cora and Sam is palpable, their attraction simmering beneath the surface of everyday interactions. The baby group's absurdities—orgasmic birth stories, elimination communication—highlight the absurdity and isolation of modern parenting, pushing Cora and Sam closer together.
The Broccoli Mom Wars
Broccoli Mom's rigid, performative parenting style becomes a lightning rod for conflict and camaraderie within the group. Her insistence on elimination communication and organic everything is both comic and menacing. Cora and Sam find themselves united against her, their shared skepticism deepening their bond. The group's dynamics expose the competitive, judgmental underbelly of middle-class parenting, where every choice is fraught with meaning. Cora's discomfort with Broccoli Mom's methods mirrors her discomfort with her own life's compromises. The group's rituals—potty training demonstrations, birth story competitions—become a microcosm of the pressures and absurdities of contemporary parenthood. Through these battles, Cora and Sam's alliance solidifies, and the possibility of something more begins to glimmer.
Parallel Lives, Secret Worlds
As Cora's friendship with Sam deepens, her reality bifurcates. She moves through her days as a wife, mother, and worker, but her imagination is increasingly consumed by fantasies of Sam. The narrative splits: in one timeline, she is faithful, in another, she is having an affair. These parallel lives run side by side—mundane chores and passionate rendezvous, family dinners and secret texts. The tension between longing and loyalty becomes the central drama of her life. Cora's emotional world is rich and tumultuous, even as her external life appears orderly. The affair, at first only imagined, becomes a refuge from the disappointments and constraints of adulthood. The boundaries between fantasy and reality blur, and the stakes rise.
The Affair Ignites
After months of flirtation and emotional intimacy, Cora and Sam finally cross the line. A spontaneous kiss in a bar leads to a series of secret meetings—coffees, beers, walks, and eventually, sex in a hotel room. The affair is both exhilarating and fraught with guilt. Cora is swept up in the physical and emotional intensity, but she is also acutely aware of the risks to her marriage, her children, and her sense of self. Sam is equally conflicted, torn between his affection for Cora and his loyalty to his wife and family. Their encounters are charged with both pleasure and anxiety, and the secrecy only heightens the thrill. The affair becomes the axis around which Cora's life revolves, even as she tries to maintain the facade of normalcy.
Family Dinners and Double Lives
As Cora and Sam's affair intensifies, their families become increasingly entangled. Dinners, playdates, and shared activities create a web of intimacy and deception. Cora and Sam's spouses, Eliot and Jules, are drawn into the orbit of their friendship, oblivious to the true nature of the connection. The tension between public harmony and private betrayal grows. Cora feels both possessive of Sam and guilty for the duplicity. The children's friendships, the couples' shared routines, and the small-town setting make secrecy both easier and more perilous. The affair is no longer just about Cora and Sam; it implicates everyone around them. The emotional stakes escalate as the boundaries between love, loyalty, and desire become increasingly porous.
Hotel Rooms and Heartbreak
Cora and Sam's affair finds its physical home in a nondescript hotel, a space of anonymity and escape. Their encounters are passionate, tender, and sometimes awkward, marked by both connection and disconnection. The hotel becomes a symbol of their double lives—a place where they can be themselves, or someone else entirely. But the intensity of the affair is unsustainable. Guilt, fear, and the practicalities of family life intrude. An unplanned pregnancy and subsequent abortion mark a turning point, introducing grief and resentment into their relationship. The hotel room, once a sanctuary, becomes a site of reckoning. The affair's initial wildness gives way to complications, and the possibility of lasting happiness seems increasingly remote.
Pandemic and Proximity
The arrival of the pandemic upends the rhythms of daily life, forcing Cora, Sam, and their families into new patterns of intimacy and isolation. Remote work, remote school, and the collapse of social boundaries bring everyone closer—and sometimes too close. The affair, once a secret escape, becomes harder to sustain amid constant togetherness and surveillance. The families form a "pod," sharing childcare and responsibilities, blurring the lines between friendship and something more. The pressures of the pandemic expose cracks in all the marriages, intensifying both longing and resentment. The world shrinks, and the possibilities for escape diminish. The pandemic becomes both a crucible and a mirror, revealing the strengths and weaknesses of every relationship.
PTA, Parenting, and Passion
Cora and Sam join the PTA, finding in its mundane rituals a new arena for their connection. Meetings, fundraisers, and school events become opportunities for flirtation and intimacy, even as they perform the roles of responsible parents and community members. The contrast between public duty and private desire sharpens. The PTA, with its endless discussions and petty politics, becomes a metaphor for the compromises and frustrations of adulthood. Cora's mother warns her against over-involvement, but Cora finds herself drawn to the sense of purpose and camaraderie, even as she chafes against its limitations. The affair persists, but its context shifts, shaped by the demands of family, work, and community.
Grief, Growth, and Guilt
The deaths of Eliot's parents plunge the family into grief, disrupting the fragile balance of Cora's double life. Eliot's depression deepens, and Cora is forced to confront her responsibilities as a wife and mother. The affair with Sam becomes both a solace and a source of guilt. The families take a joint vacation, hoping for healing and renewal, but old patterns and new tensions persist. Cora's sense of self is tested by loss, longing, and the demands of care. The affair, once a source of escape, now feels like a burden. The possibility of change—of forgiveness, of growth—emerges, but the path is uncertain. Grief becomes a catalyst for reflection and transformation.
The World Reopens
As the world emerges from the pandemic, the routines of work, school, and social life resume, but nothing is quite the same. Cora returns to the office, navigating new hierarchies and disappointments. The affair with Sam loses its urgency, but the emotional residue lingers. New neighbors arrive, old friends drift away, and the town's character shifts. The families attempt to reclaim a sense of normalcy, but the scars of the past years remain. Cora and Eliot's marriage is tested by old wounds and new opportunities. The possibility of reinvention—of starting over, of letting go—hovers in the air, but the past is not easily escaped.
Rumors, Revelations, and Regret
Rumors of infidelity begin to circulate in the community, fueled by gossip, observation, and the inevitable slip of secrets. The affair between Cora and Sam, once so carefully hidden, becomes an open secret. Jules discovers the truth, and the fallout is swift and painful. Friendships fracture, alliances shift, and the web of deception unravels. Cora is forced to confront the consequences of her actions—not just for herself, but for her family, her friends, and her sense of self. The pain of betrayal is matched by the pain of regret. The possibility of forgiveness is uncertain, and the cost of desire becomes clear.
Endings and Exits
With the truth exposed, Cora and Sam's affair comes to an end. Sam's family prepares to move away, and the possibility of a future together evaporates. Cora is left to pick up the pieces of her marriage, her friendships, and her identity. The end of the affair is both a relief and a loss—a closing of one chapter and the uncertain beginning of another. The routines of daily life resume, but everything is changed. The memory of passion lingers, but the demands of ordinary life reassert themselves. The possibility of happiness remains, but it is tempered by experience and humility.
The Aftermath of Desire
In the wake of the affair, Cora reflects on what she has gained and lost. Her marriage to Eliot endures, but it is marked by new honesty and vulnerability. Her friendship with Jules is irreparably altered, but a kind of understanding emerges. The children grow, the seasons change, and the town continues its slow evolution. Cora's longing for meaning and connection persists, but it is now shaped by acceptance and self-knowledge. The extraordinary intensity of the affair gives way to the ordinary work of living—parenting, working, loving, forgiving. The story's emotional arc resolves not in triumph or tragedy, but in the quiet persistence of hope.
The Shape of Forgiveness
Forgiveness, both given and received, becomes the central work of Cora's life. She and Eliot rebuild their marriage, not by forgetting the past, but by integrating it into their shared story. The pain of betrayal is acknowledged, but it does not define them. Cora finds new purpose in her work, her friendships, and her family. The possibility of happiness is no longer tied to passion or escape, but to presence and acceptance. The scars of the past remain, but they are softened by time and care. The story ends not with resolution, but with the ongoing process of healing and growth.
Moving On, Looking Back
As Sam and his family leave town, Cora is left to reflect on the decade that has passed. The affair, once the center of her world, recedes into memory. The routines of daily life—school pickups, work deadlines, family dinners—resume their place. The children grow older, friendships shift, and the town changes. Cora's longing for something more persists, but it is now tempered by gratitude for what she has. The past is not forgotten, but it no longer holds her captive. The story's final movement is one of acceptance, of moving forward while honoring what has been.
Ordinary Life, Extraordinary Longing
In the end, Cora's story is one of ordinary life—its joys, its disappointments, its quiet heroism. The extraordinary longing that drove her affair with Sam is not extinguished, but transformed. She learns to live with the ache, to find meaning in the everyday, to accept the limits and possibilities of love. The story closes with a sense of openness—a recognition that life is always unfinished, that longing is part of being alive, and that hope endures even in the most ordinary moments.
Analysis
The Ten Year Affair is a sharp, funny, and deeply humane exploration of marriage, desire, and the search for meaning in the midst of ordinary life. Erin Somers uses the device of parallel timelines to dramatize the ways in which fantasy and reality coexist, and how the choices we make—and the ones we only imagine—shape our identities. The novel is both a satire of contemporary parenting culture and a poignant meditation on the limits of fulfillment, the persistence of longing, and the possibility of forgiveness. Its characters are flawed, self-aware, and achingly real, navigating the messiness of love, friendship, and family with humor and vulnerability. The story resists easy resolutions, instead embracing the complexity and ambiguity of adult life. Its ultimate lesson is that happiness is not found in escape or perfection, but in the ongoing work of presence, acceptance, and connection. The ordinary, it suggests, is more than enough—if we are willing to see it.
Review Summary
The Ten Year Affair by Erin Somers receives polarized reviews with a 3.24 rating. Fans praise its dry humor, sharp writing, and clever dual-timeline structure following Cora's fantasy affair versus reality with Sam. Many appreciate the honest portrayal of marriage, parenthood, and modern relationships. Critics find the characters flat and unlikable, the premise stretched thin from its short story origins, and the narrative confusing. Common complaints include hollow character development, inappropriate parenting depictions, and a pointless plot. The book's literary style appeals to some but alienates readers seeking more traditional storytelling or likable protagonists.
People Also Read
Characters
Cora
Cora is the emotional and narrative center of the novel—a woman in her thirties, mother of two, wife to Eliot, and a professional content manager. Her psychological landscape is defined by longing: for connection, for meaning, for the lost intensity of youth and romance. Cora is intelligent, witty, and self-deprecating, but also prone to self-doubt and guilt. Her relationship with Sam awakens desires and vulnerabilities she thought she had outgrown. She is both a loving mother and a restless soul, torn between the comforts of domestic life and the lure of passion and escape. Over the course of the novel, Cora evolves from a woman seeking fulfillment outside herself to one who finds a measure of acceptance and forgiveness within her ordinary life.
Sam
Sam is Cora's counterpart in longing and dissatisfaction—a father, husband, and "chief storytelling officer" at a tech startup. He is defined by his quirks (notably his cinnamon toothpicks), his dry humor, and his ambivalence about ambition and adulthood. Sam is both attentive and avoidant, capable of deep connection but also prone to self-sabotage and passivity. His marriage to Jules is marked by affection and frustration, and his affair with Cora is both a refuge and a source of guilt. Sam's psychological complexity lies in his simultaneous desire for intimacy and fear of its consequences. He is both a catalyst for Cora's transformation and a mirror of her own uncertainties.
Eliot
Eliot is Cora's husband—a devoted father, a serious-minded editor, and a man of routines and rituals. He is supportive and practical, but often emotionally unavailable, retreating into work, weed, and the comforts of domestic order. Eliot's love for Cora is genuine, but he struggles to meet her emotional needs or to recognize the depth of her dissatisfaction. His own struggles with depression and grief add layers to his character, making him both sympathetic and frustrating. Eliot's journey is one of gradual awakening—to his wife's pain, to his own vulnerabilities, and to the possibility of forgiveness and renewal.
Jules
Jules is Sam's wife—a successful lawyer, mother, and the embodiment of competence and control. She is driven, organized, and often intimidating, but also deeply lonely and vulnerable. Jules's relationship with Sam is marked by both partnership and resentment, and her own infidelity complicates the moral landscape of the novel. Her friendship with Cora is fraught with competition, admiration, and betrayal. Jules's psychological depth emerges in her struggle to balance ambition, motherhood, and the desire for connection. She is both a foil and a mirror to Cora, representing the paths not taken and the costs of striving.
Opal
Opal is Cora and Eliot's eldest child—a bright, self-possessed girl whose intelligence and independence both delight and challenge her parents. She is sensitive to the undercurrents of adult life, often asking difficult questions and observing more than she lets on. Opal's development from toddler to adolescent parallels Cora's own journey, highlighting the complexities of motherhood and the passage of time. Her relationship with her parents is marked by both affection and rebellion, and her friendships reflect the shifting dynamics of childhood and adolescence.
Miles
Miles is Cora and Eliot's younger child—a high-energy, sometimes difficult boy whose needs and behaviors test his parents' patience and resilience. He represents both the joys and the burdens of parenthood, and his presence shapes the rhythms of family life. Miles's milestones—potty training, school, karate—serve as markers of time and change. His innocence and vulnerability are a constant reminder to Cora of what is at stake in her choices.
Broccoli Mom (Victoria)
Broccoli Mom, later revealed as Victoria, is the emblem of competitive, performative parenting. Her insistence on elimination communication, organic everything, and "natural" methods makes her both a comic figure and a source of anxiety for the other parents. She is self-righteous, inflexible, and often menacing in her certainty. Broccoli Mom's presence in the baby group catalyzes the alliance between Cora and Sam, and her reappearance during the pandemic underscores the persistence of judgment and rivalry in parenting communities.
Liz
Liz is one of the mothers in the baby group—a woman with white-lady dreads (later cut), patchwork pants, and a penchant for discussing taboo topics. She is open-minded, nonjudgmental, and a source of comic relief. Liz's willingness to talk about anything—from orgasmic birth to postpartum sex—makes her both an ally and a foil to Cora. She represents the possibility of female friendship and solidarity, even in the midst of competition and insecurity.
Celeste
Celeste is a new neighbor who brings energy and openness to the community. She is warm, welcoming, and eager to create connections—hosting parties, organizing gatherings, and encouraging friendships. Celeste's presence signals the changing character of the town and the possibility of renewal. She is both a friend and a reminder of the impermanence of relationships and the inevitability of change.
Richard
Richard is Celeste's husband—a larger-than-life figure whose flirtatiousness, wealth, and eccentricity make him both entertaining and unsettling. He is a catalyst for gossip, a source of comic relief, and a symbol of the town's shifting social landscape. Richard's actions—flashing Cora, spreading rumors—complicate the web of relationships and highlight the absurdity and unpredictability of adult life.
Plot Devices
Parallel Timelines and Counterfactuals
The novel's most distinctive device is its use of parallel timelines—one in which Cora remains faithful, another in which she has a long-running affair with Sam. These timelines are not strictly separated; they bleed into each other, reflecting the way fantasy and reality coexist in Cora's mind. The narrative frequently shifts between what is happening, what might have happened, and what Cora imagines could happen. This structure allows for a nuanced exploration of desire, regret, and the multiplicity of self. The counterfactuals are not just escapist fantasies; they are integral to Cora's psychological development and the novel's meditation on choice and consequence.
Domestic Detail and Mundane Ritual
The novel is rich in the textures of daily life—meals, chores, school pickups, PTA meetings, home repairs. These details ground the story in realism and provide a counterpoint to the intensity of the affair. The rituals of domesticity are both comforting and suffocating, highlighting the tension between stability and longing. The mundane becomes a site of both comedy and existential reflection, as characters navigate the gap between their inner lives and outward routines.
Satire of Middle-Class Parenting
The baby group, PTA, and school community serve as microcosms of contemporary parenting culture—competitive, judgmental, and often absurd. The novel satirizes the pressures and contradictions of modern parenthood, from elimination communication to organic snacks to the politics of school choice. These settings provide both comic relief and a lens for examining deeper anxieties about identity, belonging, and success.
Symbolism of Place and Object
The town, the mountain, the hotel, the mushroom in the bathroom—all serve as symbols of the characters' inner lives. The town is both idyllic and stifling, the mountain a constant presence and reminder of change. The hotel is a space of escape and reckoning, while the persistent mushroom becomes a metaphor for unresolved problems and the persistence of the past. Objects like the cinnamon toothpick, the gold necklace, and the cube for moving house acquire layered meanings, marking transitions and emotional turning points.
Irony, Humor, and Self-Awareness
The novel's tone is marked by irony, humor, and a keen sense of the absurd. Characters are often self-aware, using wit to deflect pain or to make sense of their predicaments. The humor is both a coping mechanism and a source of insight, allowing the narrative to address serious themes—infidelity, grief, regret—without succumbing to melodrama or despair.
