Plot Summary
Escape Through the Shadows
Paige Mahoney and a ragged group of voyant prisoners escape the brutal penal colony of Sheol I, racing through secret tunnels beneath London. Hunted and wounded, they navigate the city's underbelly, haunted by trauma and loss. The city is a labyrinth of danger, with Scion's forces tightening their grip and the threat of betrayal lurking in every shadow. Paige's leadership is tested as she tries to keep the survivors together, each step forward a gamble between hope and despair. The escape is not just physical but psychological, as each character must confront the scars left by captivity and the uncertainty of freedom. The city's pulse is relentless, and the fugitives' only chance is to disappear into its chaos, trusting in their wits and each other.
Hunted in London's Underworld
Now a fugitive, Paige is forced into hiding, moving between dingy doss-houses and the protection of her old gang, the Seven Seals. Scion's propaganda machine brands her a dangerous criminal, and the syndicate's own leaders are divided over her fate. Old alliances are strained as Paige's return upends the delicate balance of power. She is torn between loyalty to her former mentor, Jaxon Hall, and her growing conviction that the syndicate must unite against a greater threat. The city's streets are alive with suspicion, and every encounter is fraught with the risk of exposure. Paige's isolation deepens as she realizes that survival means more than just evading capture—it means redefining who she can trust and what she is willing to fight for.
Syndicate's Fractured Loyalties
The criminal underworld of London is a web of rival gangs, each led by a mime-lord or mime-queen with their own ambitions. Paige's attempt to rally the syndicate against Scion's new weapon, Senshield, is met with skepticism and outright hostility. The Underlord, Hector, rules through fear and violence, dismissing Paige's warnings and punishing dissent. Jaxon Hall, Paige's enigmatic mentor, offers protection but demands loyalty above all. As Paige navigates the treacherous politics of the Unnatural Assembly, she discovers that the syndicate's greatest weakness is its own division. Old grudges, personal ambitions, and the lure of power threaten to tear the underworld apart just as Scion's noose tightens around them all.
The Underlord's Bloody End
The fragile peace of the syndicate is shattered when Hector and his entire gang are found brutally murdered, their bodies arranged in a grotesque tableau. The killings are a message—one that sends shockwaves through the underworld. Suspicion falls on Paige, who discovered the scene, but the true culprit remains hidden. The massacre creates a power vacuum, and the scramble to claim the title of Underlord begins. Old alliances are tested, and new betrayals emerge as the syndicate's leaders maneuver for advantage. The violence is both a warning and an opportunity, forcing Paige to confront the reality that the greatest threats may come from within.
The Game of Masks
In the aftermath of the massacre, Paige is drawn deeper into the syndicate's deadly games. She uncovers a secret alliance between the Rag and Bone Man and the Abbess, leaders who manipulate events from the shadows. The "gray market" is revealed—a clandestine trade in voyants, sold to Scion by their own leaders. Paige's search for truth leads her through a maze of betrayals, as friends become enemies and enemies wear the faces of friends. The city is a stage, and everyone wears a mask. To survive, Paige must learn to play the game better than anyone else, even as the cost threatens to consume her.
The Gray Market's Secret
The horrifying truth of the gray market comes to light: the syndicate's leaders have been trafficking their own people to Scion in exchange for power and security. Ivy, a survivor and former mollisher, confesses her role in the scheme, wracked by guilt and grief. The revelation exposes the rot at the heart of the underworld and forces Paige to confront the limits of forgiveness and justice. The gray market is not just a crime—it is a wound that festers, threatening to destroy any hope of unity. Paige's resolve hardens as she vows to end the betrayal, even if it means turning against those she once called allies.
The Rephaim Among Us
The Rephaim, immortal beings from the Netherworld, are revealed to be the true puppet masters behind Scion. Their factions—the tyrannical Sargas and the rebellious Ranthen—wage a secret war for control. Paige's uneasy alliance with Warden, a Ranthen Rephaite, deepens as they train together and share forbidden intimacy. The boundaries between human and Rephaite blur, and Paige is forced to question the nature of power, loyalty, and love. The city becomes a battleground for forces beyond human comprehension, and Paige's role as a bridge between worlds becomes both her greatest strength and her most dangerous vulnerability.
The Scrimmage Approaches
With the Underlord dead, the syndicate calls a scrimmage—a brutal, gladiatorial contest to determine the next ruler. Paige and Jaxon Hall, once mentor and protégé, become rivals in the Rose Ring. The contest is a spectacle of violence and cunning, where alliances shift with every blow and only the ruthless survive. Paige's mastery of her dreamwalking gift is tested to its limits as she faces not just physical threats but the psychological warfare of her enemies. The scrimmage is more than a fight for power—it is a crucible that will determine the future of the underworld and the fate of all voyants.
The Rose Ring's Betrayal
The scrimmage reaches its climax as Paige and Jaxon face off in a final, brutal duel. Jaxon's true nature is revealed—he is not just a manipulator but a traitor with ties to the Rephaim. The battle is as much psychological as physical, with both combatants wielding their gifts and their knowledge of each other's weaknesses. Paige's victory is hard-won, but it comes at the cost of shattered trust and the loss of old friends. The Rose Ring is not just a place of ascension but of reckoning, where the past and future collide in blood and ash.
The Rise of Black Moth
Victorious, Paige is crowned Underqueen—Black Moth—amidst chaos and suspicion. The syndicate is fractured, and her authority is immediately challenged by those who see her as a traitor or a usurper. The Ranthen Rephaim reveal themselves, offering a fragile alliance against the Sargas and Scion. Paige's leadership is tested as she must balance justice, vengeance, and the need for unity. The cost of power is steep, and the wounds of betrayal run deep. Yet, for the first time, there is hope that the syndicate can become more than a den of thieves—it can be a force for revolution.
The Unmasking of Allies
The aftermath of the scrimmage brings a reckoning. Ivy's testimony exposes the full extent of the gray market, implicating the Abbess and the Rag and Bone Man in a conspiracy that reaches to the heart of the syndicate. The Abbess is unmasked and brought to justice, but the true mastermind remains at large. Paige's victory is bittersweet, as old friends depart and new enemies emerge. The lines between ally and adversary blur, and Paige must decide who she can trust as the war against Scion and the Rephaim intensifies.
The Anchor's Shadow Falls
Scion retaliates against the syndicate's uprising with public executions and a campaign of terror. The city is plunged into fear as voyants are hunted and killed. Paige is forced to make impossible choices, torn between saving her people and preserving her own life. The Rephaim's influence grows, and the true scale of the enemy's power becomes clear. The anchor—the symbol of Scion's oppression—casts a longer shadow than ever, threatening to crush all resistance. Yet, in the darkness, Paige finds new resolve, determined to fight on no matter the cost.
War on the Horizon
As the city reels from Scion's crackdown, Paige and her allies prepare for open war. The fragile alliance with the Ranthen is tested by old wounds and new betrayals. Jaxon Hall, revealed as the traitor who once doomed the first rebellion, defects to Scion, becoming Paige's most dangerous enemy. The lines between human and Rephaite, friend and foe, blur as the battle for London's soul begins. Paige stands at the center of the storm, Underqueen of a broken order, ready to lead her people into the unknown. The future is uncertain, but the fight for freedom has only just begun.
Characters
Paige Mahoney
Paige is the heart of the story—a dreamwalker whose journey from captive to Underqueen is marked by trauma, resilience, and moral complexity. Her relationships are fraught: she is both protégé and adversary to Jaxon Hall, lover and ally to Warden, and a symbol of hope and danger to the syndicate. Paige's psyche is shaped by guilt over those she could not save, a fierce loyalty to her friends, and a growing sense of responsibility for the fate of all voyants. Her development is a study in leadership under fire, as she learns to wield power without losing her humanity. Paige's struggle is not just against external enemies but against the scars of betrayal and the fear of becoming what she hates.
Jaxon Hall
Jaxon is both Paige's savior and her greatest threat. As the White Binder, he is a genius of the underworld, shaping the syndicate with his vision and ruthlessness. His relationship with Paige is deeply psychological—part father figure, part rival, part captor. Jaxon's need for control and his fear of irrelevance drive him to betray those closest to him, ultimately aligning with the Rephaim and Scion. His charm masks a profound emptiness, and his brilliance is matched only by his capacity for cruelty. Jaxon's arc is a tragic descent from flawed mentor to arch-villain, embodying the dangers of unchecked ambition and the seduction of power.
Arcturus Mesarthim (Warden)
Warden is a Ranthen Rephaite, torn between his immortal nature and his growing connection to humanity—especially Paige. His relationship with Paige is fraught with tension, desire, and mutual respect, complicated by the taboos of both their worlds. Warden's psyche is marked by centuries of guilt, loneliness, and the scars of betrayal. He is both a mentor and a student, learning from Paige even as he teaches her. Warden's development is a journey toward vulnerability, as he risks everything for a cause—and a person—he once would have dismissed as beneath him.
Nick Nygård
Nick is Paige's oldest friend and confidant, an oracle whose visions are both a gift and a curse. His relationship with Paige is one of deep trust and unspoken love, complicated by his own secrets and loyalties. Nick's calm exterior hides a well of pain, especially over the loss of his sister and the burdens of his gift. He is the voice of reason in Paige's life, urging caution and compassion even as the world falls apart. Nick's arc is one of quiet heroism, as he stands by Paige through every trial, sacrificing his own safety for the greater good.
Ivy Jacob
Ivy is a former mollisher whose involvement in the gray market haunts her. Her relationship with Paige is fraught with mistrust and shared trauma, as both struggle to reconcile survival with complicity. Ivy's psyche is a battleground of shame, grief, and the desperate hope for redemption. Her testimony is crucial in exposing the syndicate's corruption, but it comes at the cost of her own peace. Ivy's development is a painful journey toward self-forgiveness and the courage to speak truth to power.
Nadine Arnett
Nadine is a whisperer and Paige's chief competitor for Jaxon's favor. Her relationship with Paige is marked by jealousy, resentment, and a grudging respect. Nadine's psyche is shaped by insecurity and the need for validation, driving her to both support and undermine Paige. Her loyalty to Jaxon is tested by the shifting tides of power, and her arc is one of reluctant adaptation as the old order collapses.
Eliza Renton
Eliza is the gang's medium, channeling spirits through her art. Her relationship with Paige is one of friendship and occasional friction, as both struggle with the demands of loyalty and survival. Eliza's psyche is fragile, worn down by possession and the pressures of the syndicate. Yet, she finds strength in her art and her chosen family, ultimately siding with Paige in the struggle for a new order.
Danica Panić
Danica is the gang's technical genius, responsible for much of their survival. Her relationship with Paige is professional but respectful, grounded in mutual competence. Danica's psyche is analytical, focused on solutions rather than sentiment. She is a stabilizing force in the group, adapting quickly to new realities and providing the tools needed for revolution.
Zeke Arnett
Zeke is Nadine's brother and a member of the Seven Seals, caught between his love for his sister and his loyalty to Paige and Nick. His psyche is marked by trauma and the struggle to find his own path. Zeke's arc is one of painful choices, as he ultimately follows his sister into exile, symbolizing the cost of divided loyalties.
The Abbess
The Abbess is a powerful mime-queen whose alliance with the Rag and Bone Man and involvement in the gray market make her a central antagonist. Her relationship with Paige is adversarial, marked by manipulation and violence. The Abbess's psyche is a study in ambition corrupted by fear, as she clings to power through any means necessary. Her downfall is both a personal reckoning and a symbol of the syndicate's need for renewal.
Plot Devices
Dual Worlds and Hidden Hierarchies
The novel's structure is built on the interplay between the visible world of Scion London and the hidden underworld of voyants and Rephaim. The syndicate's complex hierarchy mirrors the oppressive regime of Scion, with both systems riddled by corruption, betrayal, and the constant threat of exposure. The use of secret tunnels, coded language, and clandestine meetings creates a sense of perpetual danger and intrigue. The Rephaim's infiltration of human society, and the existence of factions within their own ranks, adds layers of complexity and foreshadowing, as alliances shift and true motives are slowly revealed.
The Scrimmage as Crucible
The scrimmage is the novel's central plot device, serving as both a literal and symbolic battleground for the future of the syndicate. Its rules—brutal, archaic, and open to manipulation—reflect the larger struggle for power and legitimacy. The contest forces characters to confront their own limits, betrayals, and desires, while also exposing the rot at the heart of the underworld. The scrimmage's outcome is both a personal and political turning point, setting the stage for the war to come.
Masks, Betrayal, and Unreliable Alliances
The narrative is driven by secrets—hidden identities, double agents, and the constant threat of betrayal. Characters wear literal and figurative masks, concealing their true intentions even from themselves. Foreshadowing is woven through dreams, visions, and the manipulation of memory, creating a sense of inevitability and dread. The ultimate betrayal—Jaxon's defection to Scion and revelation as the original traitor—reframes the entire story, turning mentor into nemesis and forcing Paige to redefine her own identity and mission.
Dreamwalking and the Æther
Paige's gift as a dreamwalker is central to the plot, allowing her to possess, influence, and battle others on a psychic plane. The mechanics of dreamwalking—its risks, limitations, and the psychological toll it exacts—are explored in depth, making every use of the gift a moment of tension and potential catastrophe. The æther, as both a spiritual realm and a metaphor for the unconscious, is a source of power, trauma, and revelation, blurring the line between reality and nightmare.
Analysis
The Mime Order is a masterful exploration of power, betrayal, and the search for identity in a world where nothing is as it seems. At its core, the novel is about the cost of freedom—personal, political, and spiritual. Paige's journey from fugitive to Underqueen is both a literal and metaphorical ascent, marked by loss, sacrifice, and the constant threat of becoming what she fights against. The syndicate's corruption is not just a backdrop but a mirror for the dangers of complacency and the seduction of power. The novel's supernatural elements—dreamwalking, the Rephaim, the æther—are not mere fantasy but tools for examining trauma, memory, and the possibility of change. The story's emotional arc is one of hard-won hope: unity forged from division, love found in the unlikeliest of places, and the courage to face the darkness within and without. In a world built on lies and masks, The Mime Order insists that true revolution begins with the willingness to see, to speak, and to fight for something better.
Last updated:
Review Summary
The Mime Order receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its complex world-building, character development, and intense plot. Many find it an improvement over the first book, with less info-dumping and more action. The slow pacing in the first half and long length are common criticisms. Readers appreciate the political intrigue, the evolving relationships between characters, and the stunning cliffhanger ending. Overall, fans are eager for the next installment in the series.