Plot Summary
Midnight Screams and Memories
Levi is jolted awake by his daughter Brynn's midnight screams, only to find her unharmed and excited about her favorite rockstar, Sav Loveless, coming to their small town. The encounter triggers Levi's memories of Savannah, his first love and the woman he's never truly escaped. As he comforts Brynn, Levi's internal struggle is palpable—he's haunted by the past, unable to move on from the heartbreak Savannah left him with. The chapter sets the tone for a story where the past and present intertwine, and where the wounds of first love never fully heal. Levi's fierce protectiveness of Brynn is matched only by his dread at the thought of Savannah re-entering his life, threatening the fragile peace he's built.
Unlikely Friendship Forms
Fifteen-year-old Levi and Savannah, both misfits in their small town, form a friendship rooted in shared loneliness and mutual need. Savannah, brash and rebellious, latches onto Levi's quiet steadiness, while he's drawn to her wildness and vulnerability. Their connection is cemented through small acts of loyalty—sharing homework, defending each other from bullies, and offering comfort in the face of family dysfunction. Savannah's home life is a nightmare of abuse and neglect, while Levi's is stifling and judgmental. Their friendship becomes a lifeline, a secret world where they can be themselves, even as the rest of the town brands Savannah as trouble and Levi as a weenie.
Bruises and Broken Homes
Savannah's bruises are more than skin deep—they're evidence of the violence and chaos that define her existence. Levi sees the marks, feels the weight of her suffering, and is torn between wanting to save her and fearing the consequences of getting involved. Savannah's resilience is both inspiring and heartbreaking; she refuses to be a victim, even as she's battered by those who should protect her. Their nights together, huddled in Levi's bed, are moments of stolen safety. But the threat of discovery, and the ever-present danger in Savannah's home, loom over them. The chapter pulses with fear, longing, and the desperate hope that love might be enough to save them both.
Defending the Damned
When Savannah is suspended for defending Levi from a bully, the cost of loyalty becomes clear. Levi's attempts to get help for Savannah are met with indifference and cruelty from his religious parents, who see her as a corrupting influence. The town's hypocrisy is laid bare—those who should help turn a blind eye, and Levi is punished for his compassion. Savannah's situation worsens, culminating in a violent confrontation that forces her to run. The chapter is a gut-wrenching exploration of the limits of friendship, the failures of adults, and the way trauma can isolate even the strongest souls.
Forced Apart, Running Away
Savannah's decision to run away is both an act of self-preservation and a final, painful severing of her bond with Levi. Their goodbye is charged with longing and regret, culminating in a first kiss that is as much a promise as it is a farewell. Savannah's theft of Levi's bike—a symbol of their connection and her need for freedom—becomes a bittersweet joke between them. Levi is left behind, forced to endure his mother's wrath and the loss of the only person who truly understood him. The chapter closes the door on their childhood, setting them on separate paths marked by loss and longing.
First Kiss, Last Goodbye
The night Savannah leaves, she and Levi share a kiss that is both innocent and electric, a moment of tenderness amid chaos. Their connection is undeniable, but the world conspires to keep them apart. Levi's inability to protect Savannah, and her refusal to let him try, create a rift that feels insurmountable. The pain of goodbye is sharpened by the knowledge that their love, however real, may never be enough. The chapter is a meditation on the power of first love, the ache of separation, and the way some wounds never fully heal.
Stripped Down in Miami
Years later, Savannah has reinvented herself as Sav Loveless, frontwoman of a rising rock band and a dancer in Miami. Levi, now in college, stumbles into her club during spring break, and their reunion is explosive. The chemistry between them is as strong as ever, but so are the scars. Savannah's bravado masks deep pain, and Levi's straight-laced exterior hides a longing for the girl he lost. Their night together is a whirlwind of old jokes, new boundaries, and the realization that neither has truly moved on. The chapter pulses with sexual tension, nostalgia, and the sense that fate is not done with them yet.
Reunion and Reckoning
Levi and Savannah's reconnection is fraught with unresolved feelings and the baggage of their pasts. As they navigate the Miami nightlife, Savannah's band, and the temptations of drugs and fame, they are drawn together and pulled apart by the same forces that shaped their youth. A near-assault at a beach party brings Levi's protective instincts to the fore, and Savannah's vulnerability is laid bare. Their night together is tender but haunted, a reminder that love can be both a refuge and a risk. The chapter explores the complexities of forgiveness, the lure of self-destruction, and the hope that second chances might be possible.
Band of Misfits
Savannah's band becomes her new family, a ragtag group of outcasts united by music and survival. Levi is both an outsider and a lifeline, offering support even as he struggles to find his place in Savannah's world. The band's rise is meteoric, fueled by Savannah's talent and charisma, but the pressures of fame, addiction, and toxic relationships threaten to tear them apart. The chapter is a love letter to the power of music, the bonds of chosen family, and the way art can both heal and destroy.
Highs, Lows, and Betrayals
As The Hometown Heartless ascends to stardom, the cracks in Savannah's life widen. Addiction, betrayal, and the relentless demands of the industry push her to the brink. Levi's attempts to be there for her are complicated by his own responsibilities and the ghosts of their past. A pregnancy, a forced marriage, and the revelation of old secrets threaten to unravel everything. The chapter is a raw, unflinching look at the cost of survival, the pain of loving someone who is self-destructing, and the hope that redemption might still be possible.
Love, Loss, and Lies
The truth about Brynn's parentage, Julianna's illness, and the tangled web of lies that bind Levi, Savannah, and their families comes to light. The revelation is both devastating and liberating, forcing everyone to confront the consequences of their choices. Forgiveness is hard-won, and the path to healing is littered with setbacks. The chapter is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit, the power of truth, and the belief that love can survive even the deepest wounds.
The One That Got Away
Years pass, and Savannah and Levi's lives diverge and intersect in unexpected ways. Both achieve success—Savannah as a rockstar, Levi as a builder and father—but neither finds true peace. Their encounters are charged with what-ifs and might-have-beens, each meeting a reminder of what they've lost and what they still want. The chapter is a meditation on fate, the choices that define us, and the hope that some loves are meant to find their way home.
Fame's Double-Edged Sword
Savannah's fame brings both adulation and scrutiny, and the pressures of public life threaten to consume her. A leaked sex tape, relentless paparazzi, and the demands of her label force her to choose between her career and her heart. Levi, too, is tested by the expectations of others and the responsibilities of fatherhood. Their love is a sanctuary, but it is also a battleground, and the sacrifices required are steep. The chapter explores the tension between ambition and intimacy, the cost of vulnerability, and the courage it takes to claim happiness.
Ghosts of the Past
The return of old enemies and the resurfacing of buried trauma force Savannah and Levi to confront their pasts. Sharon, Savannah's mother, re-enters their lives, seeking redemption and a place in the family she once destroyed. The process of forgiveness is messy and incomplete, but it is also transformative. The chapter is a powerful exploration of generational pain, the possibility of change, and the belief that healing is possible, even after years of hurt.
Collisions and Consequences
A violent confrontation with Brynn's biological father, a house fire, and the threat of losing everything they've built push Savannah and Levi to their limits. The stakes are life and death, and the choices they make will define their future. The chapter is a heart-pounding, emotional climax that tests the strength of their love, the bonds of chosen family, and the resilience of the human spirit. In the aftermath, they are forced to rebuild—literally and figuratively—finding hope in the ashes.
Family, Found and Forgiven
In the wake of tragedy, Savannah, Levi, Brynn, and their extended family come together to create a new home and a new life. The process is slow and painful, but it is also filled with moments of joy, laughter, and connection. The band reunites, friendships are mended, and the wounds of the past begin to heal. The chapter is a celebration of found family, the power of forgiveness, and the belief that love can create a home, no matter where you are.
Fire, Flood, and Forgiveness
As Savannah and Levi navigate the challenges of blending their lives, they are forced to confront the ghosts that still haunt them. The process of forgiveness—of themselves, each other, and those who hurt them—is ongoing, but they are no longer alone. Together, they face the future with hope, determination, and the knowledge that they are stronger together than apart. The chapter is a testament to the power of resilience, the beauty of second chances, and the promise of forever.
Endgame: Between Never and Forever
Savannah and Levi, after years of heartbreak, loss, and longing, finally find their way to each other. Their love, forged in the fires of adversity, is both a refuge and a triumph. Surrounded by family, friends, and the music that brought them together, they embrace the future with open hearts. The story ends not with a perfect happily ever after, but with the promise of enduring love—a love that exists between never and forever.
Characters
Savannah "Sav" Loveless
Savannah is a force of nature—fierce, wounded, and endlessly resilient. Scarred by childhood abuse and neglect, she channels her pain into music, becoming the magnetic frontwoman of The Hometown Heartless. Her bravado masks deep vulnerability, and her journey is one of survival, self-destruction, and ultimately, healing. Savannah's relationships are complicated by her fear of abandonment and her struggle to trust, but her love for Levi is unwavering, even when she pushes him away. Her arc is one of self-forgiveness, learning to accept love, and finding family in unexpected places. She is both the storm and the calm, a woman who refuses to be defined by her past.
Levi Cooper
Levi is the anchor to Savannah's storm—a man shaped by duty, loss, and a longing for connection. Raised in a strict, judgmental household, he learns early to suppress his own needs in favor of others. His love for Savannah is both his greatest strength and his deepest wound. As a father to Brynn, he is fiercely protective, determined to break the cycle of pain that defined his own childhood. Levi's journey is one of learning to let go of guilt, to claim happiness for himself, and to trust that he is worthy of love. His quiet strength, loyalty, and capacity for forgiveness make him the heart of the story.
Brynnlee "Brynn" Cooper
Brynn is the brilliant, quirky daughter of Levi (and, by adoption, Savannah's stepdaughter). Wise beyond her years due to her mother's illness and death, she is both a source of comic relief and emotional depth. Brynn's intelligence and curiosity set her apart, but her longing for connection and stability is palpable. She becomes the glue that binds Savannah and Levi, and her journey is one of learning to trust, to love, and to believe that she is wanted. Brynn's resilience and wit make her a standout character, embodying the hope that the next generation can break free from the cycles of the past.
Sharon Shaw
Sharon is Savannah's estranged mother, a woman broken by addiction and regret. Her journey from villain to ally is fraught with pain, but her desire to make amends is genuine. Sharon's relationship with Brynn offers her a chance at redemption, and her willingness to confront her own failures is both moving and hard-won. She represents the possibility of change, the power of forgiveness, and the belief that it is never too late to try to be better.
Torren King
Torren is Savannah's bandmate and on-again, off-again lover, a man defined by loyalty and longing. His feelings for Savannah are complicated by addiction, codependency, and the pressures of fame. Torren's arc is one of learning to let go, to accept that love cannot be forced, and to find his own path. He is both a source of tension and a symbol of the family Savannah has built for herself.
Mabel Rossi
Mabel is Savannah's closest friend and the emotional center of the band. Her humor, loyalty, and no-nonsense attitude provide balance to Savannah's chaos. Mabel's own struggles with heartbreak and self-doubt mirror Savannah's, and their friendship is a testament to the power of chosen family. Mabel's journey is one of learning to trust again, to forgive, and to believe in her own worth.
Jonah
Jonah is the band's guitarist, a man haunted by addiction and the fear of being left behind. His silence and withdrawal mask deep pain, and his arc is one of slow, painful healing. Jonah's loyalty to the band is unwavering, but his struggle to stay sober and present is a constant battle. He represents the toll that trauma and fame can take, and the hope that recovery is possible.
Julianna Lark
Julianna is Brynn's biological mother and Levi's late wife, a woman whose choices reverberate throughout the story. Her illness, secrets, and death force Levi and Savannah to confront their own wounds and to redefine what family means. Julianna is both a source of pain and a symbol of the complexity of love, sacrifice, and forgiveness.
Terry
Terry is the embodiment of the violence and neglect that shaped Savannah's childhood. His reappearance threatens the fragile peace Savannah and Levi have built, forcing them to confront the darkness that still haunts them. Terry's actions are a catalyst for the story's climactic reckoning, and his defeat is both a literal and symbolic victory over the past.
Red
Red is Savannah's bodyguard and a surrogate father figure, providing stability and support in a world that is often chaotic and dangerous. His loyalty, humor, and quiet strength make him an essential part of Savannah's chosen family. Red's presence is a reminder that family is not just about blood, but about the people who show up when it matters most.
Plot Devices
Dual Timelines and Shifting Perspectives
The novel masterfully weaves together the "then" and "now," using flashbacks to illuminate the roots of Savannah and Levi's connection and the traumas that shaped them. This structure allows the reader to experience the full emotional arc of their relationship, from innocent beginnings to hard-won reconciliation. The shifting perspectives—primarily between Savannah and Levi—offer deep insight into their inner worlds, exposing fears, desires, and the ways they misunderstand each other. This device heightens tension, creates empathy, and underscores the theme that healing is a nonlinear journey.
Symbolism: Keys, Locks, and Music
Throughout the story, keys and locks symbolize the enduring connection between Savannah and Levi. The bike lock and its key, exchanged and kept for years, become tokens of first love, loss, and the hope of reunion. Music, too, is a central motif—both a source of salvation and a battleground for pain. Songs written, performed, and shared are acts of vulnerability and defiance, binding characters together and offering a path to healing. These symbols ground the narrative, providing continuity and emotional resonance.
Found Family and Cycles of Trauma
The novel explores the idea that family is not just inherited, but created. Savannah, Levi, and Brynn each grapple with the legacies of abuse, addiction, and abandonment, but they also find strength in the families they choose—bandmates, friends, and each other. The story does not shy away from the difficulty of breaking cycles of trauma, but it insists that change is possible. Forgiveness, both of self and others, is a hard-won victory, and the process of building trust is depicted with nuance and honesty.
Fame, Scandal, and the Public Eye
Savannah's rise to fame brings both opportunity and peril. The relentless scrutiny of the media, the threat of scandal, and the pressure to perform are ever-present obstacles. The novel uses these external forces to test the characters' relationships and to explore the tension between public persona and private self. The leaked sex tape, paparazzi, and label machinations are not just plot twists—they are metaphors for the ways trauma and shame can be exposed, exploited, and, ultimately, transcended.
Redemption and Second Chances
At its core, the story is about the possibility of redemption—for Savannah, for Sharon, for Levi, and for the band. The narrative structure, with its cycles of loss and reunion, reinforces the idea that second chances are both a gift and a responsibility. The characters are allowed to be flawed, to make mistakes, and to try again. The ending, while hopeful, is not a fairy tale—it is a promise that love, when chosen and fought for, can endure.
Analysis
Between Never and Forever is a raw, unflinching exploration of trauma, love, and the arduous journey toward healing. Brit Benson crafts a narrative that refuses easy answers, instead offering a tapestry of pain, resilience, and hope. The novel's power lies in its refusal to romanticize suffering—Savannah and Levi's love is hard-won, forged in the fires of abuse, addiction, and loss. The story insists that family is not just something we are born into, but something we build, often in defiance of the past. Through its dual timelines, shifting perspectives, and rich symbolism, the book interrogates the ways we are shaped by our wounds and the courage it takes to break free. The lessons are clear: forgiveness is possible, but it is a process; love is a risk, but it is worth taking; and healing is not about erasing the past, but about learning to live with it. In a world that often feels defined by never, the novel dares to imagine a forever—messy, imperfect, but fiercely, beautifully real.
Last updated:
