Key Takeaways
1. Intuition is a Process, Gut Feel is the Outcome
Intuition is the process that leads to a final moment of recognition that we call our gut feel.
Distinguishing terms. Many use "intuition" and "gut feel" interchangeably, but they are distinct. Intuition is the dynamic, often non-linear process of accessing and interpreting information, drawing on both external data and personal experience. Gut feel, on the other hand, is the sudden flash of clarity, the conclusive outcome of this intuiting process—a moment of strong conviction that often defies easy explanation.
Beyond data. While hard data, financials, and business models are crucial, the author's research on entrepreneurial investors revealed that their "gut feel" often drove decisions, even when data suggested otherwise. This gut feel wasn't random; it was the culmination of an elaborate intuiting process, where data was seamlessly integrated into emotional experiences and personal reflections. It's like enjoying iced tea, understanding sugar was dissolved, but savoring the whole refreshing beverage.
Data and experience. The interplay between personal experience and analytical information is vital. Just as "Moneyball" showed that data alone wasn't enough for baseball success until combined with managerial experience, and "centaur chess players" (human + AI) outperform either alone, true breakthroughs emerge when data augments human intelligence. Your gut feel is uniquely personal, built from your accumulated knowledge, observations, and lived truths, making it an internal signal straining to be heard.
2. Your Gut Feel is Your Inner Voice, Learn to Hear It
We can’t help but notice what is louder, brasher, more flamboyant. But we can also learn and train ourselves to listen to what whispers, not what screams.
Noise versus whisper. Our gut feel often whispers, easily drowned out by the "screaming" external noise of opinions from trusted people, social media, daily responsibilities, and societal expectations. To truly hear this inner voice, we must either amplify it or intentionally tune into its natural properties. This is akin to signal amplification (increasing power) and noise reduction (minimizing background sounds) in engineering.
Forcing clarity. One way to amplify your inner voice is by "forcing" a gut feel, much like flipping a coin not to make the decision, but to gauge your immediate sensation to the outcome. This method, exemplified by a military leader deciding on a cadet or a character in "Friends" discovering pregnancy, reveals your true feelings by confronting you with a definitive (even if hypothetical) result. It coalesces accumulated experience and data into a single, clarifying sensation.
Intentional filtering. Avoid making decisions based on a "Route 66" approach—a mix of all the noisy, irrelevant information. Instead, approach information gathering like filling a "paper cup" intentionally:
- Understand your goal or problem.
- Selectively "drip" in relevant information from various sources.
- Know exactly what's in your cup—your personal experience and external data.
This intentional filtering primes your inner voice, making its whispers more audible and reliable for the specific problem at hand.
3. Gut Feel Manifests in Three Distinct Ways: Eureka, Spidey Sense, and Jolt
Water presents as liquid, solid, or gas. Our gut feel manifests in three forms too.
Three forms of clarity. Just as water exists in three states, gut feel manifests in three distinct forms, each with unique triggers and sensations:
- Eureka moments: A "flash of clarity" or "aha!" moment, confirming something new that perfectly fits with what you already know. It's about connection and recognition, like Jack Dorsey naming Twitter.
- Spidey Sense: An "uh-oh" feeling of dissonance, where new information doesn't align with your understanding, causing discomfort or agitation. It signals that "something is off," as an AI strategist felt about a new hire.
- Jolt: A "whoa" moment of displacement, where something you thought was true is fundamentally challenged or dislodged, leading to a paradigm shift. A chef leaving a Michelin-starred restaurant for school cafeterias exemplifies this.
Priors and prompts. These sensations arise from the collision of your "priors" (your accumulated knowledge, beliefs, and experiences) and "prompts" (new information or situations).
- Eureka: A match between priors and prompts.
- Spidey Sense: A mismatch between priors and prompts.
- Jolt: Priors are displaced entirely by prompts.
Understanding this interaction helps you diagnose what your gut feel is trying to tell you, moving beyond a simple "good" or "bad" feeling.
Beyond the three. There's also a fourth quadrant where a mismatch between priors and prompts means you're still in the intuiting process and need more data. Recognizing this "need more information" signal is crucial, as acting prematurely in this state can lead to mistakes. The goal is to understand these distinctions to effectively interpret and act on your gut feel breakthroughs.
4. Trust Your Gut Feel for Complex and Chaotic Problems
For complex and chaotic problems, gut feel can always be trusted.
Gut feel doesn't lie. Your gut feel is always right when it genuinely stems from you—your authentic self, experiences, and values—rather than being swayed by external opinions or cognitive biases. It's most effective in specific contexts: complex and chaotic problems, where cause and effect are unclear or unknowable, and solutions are not apparent or predictable.
Problem types. The Cynefin framework categorizes problems into four domains:
- Simple: Familiar, single solution, clear cause-and-effect (e.g., prescribing antibiotics for strep throat). Gut feel is unnecessary.
- Complicated: Multiple factors, unfamiliar, but still predictable cause-and-effect (e.g., implementing new software). Solvable analytically; gut feel can be erroneous.
- Complex: Cause-and-effect only deduced in retrospect, solutions unpredictable (e.g., addressing team performance issues). Requires experimentation and adaptation; gut feel is best.
- Chaotic: Cause-and-effect unknowable, problem definition unclear, no universal solution (e.g., responding to a cybersecurity breach). Requires quick action and intuition.
Rick Cohen's example. Rick Cohen, CEO of C&S Wholesale Grocers, faced a complex problem of high employee turnover despite growth. His gut feel, "We are growing our way to decline," led him to a counterintuitive solution: self-managed teams. This bold stroke, driven by his deep understanding of his employees (priors) and the new customer (prompt), transformed the company. His success highlights that for complex, chaotic situations, gut feel, combined with experience and data, is invaluable.
5. Gut Feel Compels Action: Bold Strokes and Long Marches
A gut feeling is like a compass in the wilderness; it guides you through uncharted territory, but it’s your actions that turn it into a path.
Action is key. Gut feel isn't just about making the "right decision"; it's about the ability to take quick, decisive action and then adapt. This involves "bold strokes" – major, disruptive actions that signal change and command attention – followed by "long marches" – sustained efforts to embed new practices and ensure the decision's success. Cynthia Carroll, CEO of Anglo American, demonstrated this by immediately closing mines after a fatality (bold stroke) and then implementing comprehensive safety reforms (long march).
Making sense of paradox. Complex and chaotic situations are often rife with paradoxes (e.g., work-life balance, innovation vs. stability). Successful individuals make decisions quickly and firmly, understanding that not all decisions will be 100% right, but they can be course-corrected. The ability to act decisively in the face of ambiguity, transforming risk into opportunity, is crucial.
Focused abstraction. The mechanism linking gut feel to bold action is "focused abstraction"—a mental state where you filter out distractions to concentrate on essential patterns, while maintaining a broad perspective. This allows you to distill complex information into a new, actionable insight, like John Osher realizing his lollipop's mechanics could be applied to a toothbrush, or a city official understanding traffic wasn't about reduction, but pattern management. This state helps you "see" the solution and act.
6. Engage Your Intuition Actively Through Introspection
We can take our gut feel from the passive to the active. We can learn how to intentionally engage our intuiting process so it’s perceptible, to help solve our greatest problems.
Passive vs. active intuition. Most people experience gut feel passively, as a spontaneous nudge without deep understanding. Active intuition, however, involves deliberately investigating that message, accessing deeper insights, and consciously reflecting on your inner signals. This shift from passive to active is like "engaging your core" in exercise—it enhances performance, stability, and reduces the risk of misinterpretation.
The Stone Journey. Lee Mingwei's "The Stone Journey" art piece, which asks the owner to discard one of two indistinguishable stones (one natural, one bronze replica), illustrates this active engagement. The problem isn't simple; it forces introspection on values, ownership, and personal meaning. There's no objective "right" answer; the solution depends entirely on your gut feel, honed by understanding your priors and values.
Introspection's role. Introspection is the initial step in actively engaging your intuition, allowing you to connect with your "priors" – your traits, characteristics, physical sensations, emotions, and cognitive constructs. This self-awareness is crucial for:
- Recognizing your unique intuitive patterns.
- Understanding how your internal signals manifest.
- Proactively leveraging your gut feel to solve problems.
By understanding yourself, you can activate your intuition in response to prompts, rather than letting it remain dormant.
7. Understand Your Personified, Embodied, Emotional, and Cognitive Self
Gut feel is you because it stems from your individual interpretation of the external data that you are receiving and acquiring, and it is the culmination of everything that takes place during your intuiting process.
The four dimensions. To master intuition, you must understand its four personal dimensions:
- Personified: Your baseline traits and characteristics (e.g., divergent vs. convergent thinking, as measured by "forward flow"). Knowing if you're more like Ariana Grande (creative) or the Dalai Lama (consistent) helps you cultivate needed thinking styles.
- Embodied: Where you physically feel signals in your body. Erin Earley's "Truth Test" helps identify where you feel truth (e.g., chest) versus lies (varied locations), re-establishing trust in your internal compass. Warren Bennis felt his truth in his fingertips.
- Emotional: How you feel and how emotions relate to each other (e.g., using the emotional circumplex of valence and arousal). Recognizing typical emotional patterns helps you notice when an uncharacteristic emotion signals a breakthrough, like Saurabh's embarrassment.
- Cognitive: How you construct concepts through schemas (general frameworks), mental models (specific representations), and prototypes (idealized examples). Oskar's "Rule of 3" helped him refine his CEO prototype, aligning his career with his values.
Holistic self-awareness. These dimensions are intricately intertwined, creating a unique intuitive fingerprint for each individual. By acknowledging, cultivating, and maintaining awareness of these aspects, you sharpen your ability to interpret internal signals. This holistic self-understanding allows you to recognize your unique Eureka, Spidey Sense, and Jolt moments, making your intuition a reliable superpower.
8. Achieve Focused Abstraction by Cultivating Mental Flexibility
Life teaches you the wisdom that you can’t get from education alone. It’s the wisdom that always seems to come gradually, then suddenly.
Gradual to sudden. Significant changes and breakthroughs often occur "gradually, then suddenly," as Hemingway noted about bankruptcy. This also describes focused abstraction: experiences, observations, and data build up subtly until a critical threshold is reached, leading to a sudden, unexpected insight. John Osher's journey from Spin Pop to electric toothbrush illustrates this, where a seemingly "endgame" product provided the blueprint for a greater creation.
Flexibility in expertise. The best way to reach focused abstraction is to maintain mental flexibility, especially in areas of expertise. Specialists often suffer from "trained incapacity," being the last to see common-sense solutions. To counteract this, practice neuroplasticity through simple, everyday tasks:
- Brush your teeth with your non-dominant hand to notice subtle details and adapt.
- Take different routes to work to challenge automatic patterns.
- Engage in diverse conversations to gain fresh perspectives.
These exercises train your brain to form new neural connections, enhancing its ability to adapt and recognize sudden insights from gradual accumulation.
Broadening perspective. Travel and diverse conversations are powerful tools for cultivating focused abstraction. Henry Rollins urged young people to travel to "have your mind blown" and see their own country differently. Similarly, engaging with people from varied backgrounds, listening to their stories, and challenging your own communication styles broadens your mental models. A Pittsburgh limo driver, through countless conversations with diverse passengers, developed an uncanny gut feel, demonstrating how broad exposure enhances intuitive wisdom.
9. Heed Prompts and Master Listening for Actionable Insights
If you listen carefully, you’ll recognize prompts that compel you to action.
Recognizing prompts. A deeper understanding of your personified, embodied, emotional, and cognitive self provides the foundation for recognizing and acting on prompts – the crucial inputs that compel you to action. These prompts can be subtle, easily ignored, but when heeded, they can change the trajectory of your life, as they did for artist Amanda Phingbodhipakkiya.
Amanda's tapestry. Amanda, an artist with a neuroscience background, was painting a mural at the US Embassy in Thailand when the Ambassador mentioned wanting to "create a tapestry of connections." This single word, "tapestry," was a prompt that resonated deeply with her priors (her art's purpose, her experience fighting anti-Asian discrimination). It triggered a Eureka moment, leading to a "perfect pitch" for a textile installation that became her most meaningful project, weaving together Thai and US cultures.
Listening for insights. To effectively heed prompts, cultivate active listening skills in all conversations:
- Themes: Identify biases, goals, fears, loves, and losses of others.
- Repetition: Notice ideas or phrases subtly repeated, indicating what's most important to them.
- Keywords/Cues: Pay attention to salient words or non-verbal signals, like aposematism in nature.
- Coincidences: Note anything uncanny or related to your own grappling thoughts.
- Interruptions (with purpose): Gently probe with questions like "And then what happened?" to uncover nuances.
These practices help you discern actionable insights, transforming fleeting moments into bold strokes and long marches.
10. Learn from Experience and Mistakes to Sharpen Your Intuition
Make bold choices. Some may turn out to be mistakes. They all add up to the person you become.
Experience is not just repetition. It's crucial to learn from experience, but not to repeat "one year of experience twenty times." Ron Johnson's failure at JCPenney, despite his success at Apple and Target, exemplifies "situational arrogance"—an overreliance on past successes in a new, different context. His failure to adapt to JCPenney's unique customer base and culture highlights how expertise can blind you to new variables.
Value of mistakes. Mistakes and failures are invaluable for building and refining your schemas, mental models, and prototypes. They provide insights into personal growth and enhance self-awareness.
- Intrapersonal mistakes: Misjudgments about personal goals or limits (e.g., taking on too much, pursuing misaligned business ideas). An exercise involves brainstorming business ideas, then ruthlessly crossing out any that don't align with your core values and life parameters.
- Interpersonal mistakes: Misjudging others' intentions or being overly critical. Cam's experience with a transactional "friendship" taught him discernment and character judgment.
The 80/20 rule for mistakes. Embrace the idea that things will go wrong a certain percentage of the time (e.g., 20%). Instead of dwelling on setbacks, "throw it in that 20% bucket" and view it as an opportunity to master your intuition. Conduct "postmortems" on failures, analyzing the context, timeline, contributing factors, and assumptions. This builds resilience, tempers situational arrogance, and sparks creativity, allowing you to learn how to "fail well" and continuously sharpen your gut feel.
Last updated:
Similar Books
