Key Takeaways
1. The Problem of Evil Challenges God's Goodness and Power
If God is all-good and all-powerful, why is there evil? And so much of it?
The core dilemma. The existence of immense suffering and injustice in the world poses a profound challenge to Christian theism, which posits an omnibenevolent (all-good) and omnipotent (all-powerful) God. If God desires no evil and has the power to prevent it, then the widespread presence of horrendous evil seems to contradict His nature or even His existence. This isn't merely a philosophical puzzle but a deeply personal, faith-crushing existential problem for many.
Biblical lament. Scripture itself contains no shortage of lamentations and protests against evil, echoing the very questions asked today. Figures like Job, Isaiah, and the psalmists cry out against injustice, the prosperity of the wicked, and God's apparent silence or hiddenness in the face of suffering. Even Jesus on the cross questions God's forsaking, highlighting the acute nature of this problem within the biblical narrative.
Modern skepticism. This ancient problem continues to fuel modern skepticism and atheism. Critics argue that if God were truly good and powerful, He would intervene to prevent or mitigate evil, especially atrocities like the Holocaust. The perceived lack of divine intervention leads many to conclude that the God proclaimed by the Judeo-Christian tradition, actively and powerfully involved in the world, simply cannot exist.
2. Genuine Love Necessitates Creaturely Freedom, Allowing for Evil's Possibility
Free will, though it makes evil possible, is also the only thing that makes possible any love or goodness or joy worth having.
Love requires freedom. The theodicy of love posits that God grants creatures libertarian free will because it is an indispensable condition for genuine love. Love, by its very nature, must be freely given, freely received, and freely maintained. A world populated by automata, programmed to love, would lack the profound value of freely chosen affection and relationship.
The risk of freedom. In granting such freedom, God necessarily introduces the possibility of creatures choosing against His ideal desires, which is the definition of evil. This means evil is not a necessity for love itself, but the context required for genuine love inherently includes the possibility of evil. God desires that creatures enjoy a love relationship with Him and each other, and this supreme good justifies the risk of creaturely misuse of freedom.
Functional good. Free will is thus understood as a functional good, a means to the greater end of love, which is arguably the highest intrinsic good in the universe. This perspective refutes the notion that God needs evil for some greater good; rather, God desires love, and love requires freedom, which in turn makes evil a tragic, but not necessary, possibility.
3. God's Unfulfilled Desires Affirm Libertarian Free Will
If humans sometimes will otherwise than God desires, then human wills are free in some theologically indeterministic manner.
God's genuine desires. Scripture repeatedly portrays God as having desires that are not always fulfilled by human actions. Texts like Isaiah 66:4, Luke 7:30, and 2 Peter 3:9 explicitly state God's desire for all to be saved and to obey Him, yet clearly, not all do. This indicates that human choices are not causally determined by God.
Incompatibility with determinism. If God causally determined every event, including human wills, then by definition, none of His desires could ever go unfulfilled. Any "unfulfilled desire" would merely be a counterfactual one—what God would want if things were different, which He could have made different. This logical tension suggests that theological determinism is incompatible with the biblical depiction of God's genuine, yet sometimes unfulfilled, desires.
A robust providence. This model of providence, termed "sovereign love," distinguishes between God's ideal will (what would happen if all acted perfectly) and His remedial will (His plan accounting for creaturely freedom). It affirms God's exhaustive definite foreknowledge, allowing Him to plan history while respecting libertarian free will. God's ultimate purpose will triumph, not by overriding freedom, but by wisely navigating the choices of free agents.
4. A Cosmic Conflict Over God's Character Explains Evil's Scope
An enemy has done this!
The enemy's work. Jesus' parable of the wheat and tares (Matthew 13:28) explicitly attributes evil to an "enemy"—the devil—who sows bad seeds among the good. This highlights a pervasive biblical theme: evil is not solely a human phenomenon but is orchestrated by a malevolent, supernatural adversary. This cosmic conflict framework is crucial for understanding the scale and nature of evil in the world.
Satan's profile. The New Testament consistently depicts Satan as:
- The arch-adversary, accuser, and slanderer of God and His people (Revelation 12:10).
- The deceiver and tempter, the "father of lies" (John 8:44), who works to undermine faith.
- The usurping "ruler of this world" (John 12:31), wielding temporary, but significant, power.
This portrayal is consistent with the "satan" figure in Old Testament texts like Job 1-2 and Zechariah 3.
Beyond human agency. This framework expands the free will defense beyond human choices to include the free will of celestial beings. It suggests that the horrendous magnitude of evil, including what appears to be gratuitous suffering, is not merely the sum of human misdeeds but is actively instigated and amplified by demonic forces operating within a specific, albeit temporary, jurisdiction.
5. Covenantal Rules of Engagement Temporarily Limit Divine Intervention
Insofar as God covenants to act or refrain from acting in a certain way, he is morally bound to do so.
A dispute over character. The cosmic conflict is not a battle of raw power, as God is omnipotent. Instead, it is primarily an epistemic dispute over God's moral character and government, initiated by Satan's slanderous allegations (Genesis 3). Such a conflict cannot be resolved by force but requires a public demonstration of God's justice and love before the heavenly council.
Binding agreements. To facilitate this demonstration, God operates within "covenantal rules of engagement"—bilateral agreements that grant Satan and his minions temporary, limited jurisdiction over the earth. These rules, once agreed upon, morally restrict God's direct intervention, even though He retains the ontological power to act. God's unwavering faithfulness to His promises (Titus 1:2) means He cannot capriciously revoke these agreements.
Explaining divine inaction. This framework helps explain why God might not prevent specific horrendous evils, even when He could. Doing so might:
- Contravene the established rules of engagement.
- Undermine the creaturely free will necessary for love.
- Lead to a worse overall outcome in the cosmic demonstration.
This means God is doing everything He morally can to mitigate evil, even if He is not exercising His full ontological power in every instance.
6. The Cross Demonstrates God's Love and Defeats Evil's Accusations
God demonstrates His own love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us.
Ultimate demonstration. The cross of Christ is the definitive, public demonstration of God's righteousness and love, decisively refuting Satan's slanderous allegations. Romans 3:25-26 emphasizes that Christ's sacrifice publicly displayed God's justice, showing Him to be both just and the justifier of believers. This act of self-giving love, enduring unfathomable suffering, is the ultimate testimony to God's character.
Legal victory. The cross represents a legal victory in the cosmic courtroom drama. Revelation 12:10-11 describes Satan, the "accuser of our brethren," being "thrown down" because of the "blood of the Lamb." Christ's death and resurrection effectively disarmed the evil celestial powers (Colossians 2:15), removing Satan's legal standing as accuser and excommunicating him from the heavenly council.
Proleptic defeat. While Satan is legally defeated and his power broken at the cross, his final destruction is not yet executed. Christ's victory "binds" the "strong man" (Matthew 12:29), allowing for the plundering of his house, but the full eradication of his kingdom awaits the eschaton. The cross ensures that evil's ultimate end is certain, even as its temporary reign continues.
7. Natural Evil Stems from the Fall and Demonic Influence
The creation was subjected to futility, not willingly, but because of Him who subjected it, in hope that the creation itself also will be set free.
Corruption of nature. The theodicy of love posits that evil in nature is not inherent to God's original creation but is a by-product of the entrance of moral evil. Romans 8:20-22 explains that creation was "subjected to futility" and "groans" due to the fall, indicating that nature itself has been thrown out of equilibrium by creaturely disobedience.
Demonic agency. Many so-called "natural evils" are not merely random occurrences but are directly or indirectly influenced by demonic activity. Scripture frequently links illnesses and calamities to supernatural agents (Job 1:16, 18-19; Luke 13:16). Demonic forces, operating within their temporary jurisdiction, can perturb natural processes and amplify suffering as part of their campaign against God's kingdom.
Rules of nature. The laws and orderings of nature may have been modified or manipulated by Satan and his minions within the parameters of the rules of engagement. God may wish to prevent all such evils, but doing so might be against these covenantal rules, which temporarily restrict His intervention. Thus, the suffering in nature, like moral evil, is ultimately attributable to the enemy's work, not God's design.
8. Epistemic Humility is Crucial When Facing Unexplained Evils
Just because we do not see any good reason for God to permit this or that evil, it does not follow that God has no good reasons.
Limited human knowledge. When confronted with specific, horrendous evils, humans often struggle to find a justifying reason for God's permission. However, the book of Job powerfully reminds us of our limited knowledge and perspective. God's response to Job highlights that humans cannot fathom the complexities of the cosmic conflict or the myriad factors involved in divine providence.
Beyond "noseeum" arguments. The argument that "I cannot see a reason, therefore there is no reason" (a "noseeum" argument) is flawed when applied to an omniscient God. Our inability to conceive of a morally sufficient reason does not mean one doesn't exist. God's thoughts and ways are infinitely higher than ours (Isaiah 55:8-9), and we are not in a position to judge His actions comprehensively.
Trust, not full understanding. This call for epistemic humility does not mean abandoning the search for understanding, but rather approaching it with profound trust in God's character, especially as revealed at the cross. While we may not know the specific rationale for every evil, we can be confident that God permits only what is necessary to achieve the greatest good (the flourishing of love) without compromising His own nature or promises.
9. God Will Ultimately Eradicate All Evil Eschatologically
He will swallow up death for all time, And the Lord GOD will wipe away tears from all faces.
Final resolution. The ultimate answer to the problem of evil is eschatological. The cosmic conflict, settled epistemically at the cross, will be finally resolved through the execution of divine judgment. God's glory will be revealed, and all creation will recognize His justice and righteousness (Isaiah 40:5; Revelation 15:3-4).
Universal vindication. Every knee will bow, and every tongue will confess God's righteousness (Isaiah 45:23-24; Romans 14:10-11). This universal acknowledgment will not be coerced but will stem from the undeniable revelation of God's perfect character and His just dealings throughout history. The injustice of this present age will be overturned, and God's Servant will establish justice in the earth (Isaiah 42:1, 4).
Eternal security. Finally, God will utterly eradicate evil, suffering, and death forevermore. Revelation 21:4 promises a new heaven and new earth where "there will no longer be any death; there will no longer be any mourning, or crying, or pain; the first things have passed away." The universe will be eternally secure, inoculated against evil, and Christ's dominion will be all in all, ensuring an eternity of pure bliss.
10. Trust in God's Suffering Love Amidst Unanswered Questions
God’s love for his world is a rejoicing and suffering love.
God suffers most. While creatures endure immense suffering, God Himself suffers most of all, having voluntarily taken on and suffered all the evil of this world through Christ. The cross is the ultimate testament to God's willingness to bear the cost of love, demonstrating that He considers this world, despite its evil, to be worth the unfathomable sacrifice.
Confidence in His goodness. Because God "did not spare His own Son, but delivered Him over for us all" (Romans 8:32), believers can have unwavering confidence in His goodness and love, even when specific questions about evil remain unanswered. This trust is not blind but rooted in the historical, public demonstration of God's character.
Rage against evil. This theodicy does not trivialize evil or explain it away. Instead, it encourages righteous anger, hostility, and sadness directed not at God, but at the enemy of love and the evil that resides in human hearts. It calls believers to participate in God's ongoing campaign against darkness, trusting that the suffering God of the cross will ultimately destroy evil forevermore.
Last updated:
Similar Books
