Plot Summary
Ithaca's Unseen Queen
Ithaca is a battered, overlooked island, but its queen, Penelope, is anything but passive. For twenty years, she has held the kingdom together, balancing the demands of greedy suitors, the needs of her people, and the ever-present threat of violence. Her intelligence and subtlety are her weapons, wielded in a world that refuses to see her as anything but a placeholder for her absent husband. Penelope's power is quiet but absolute, her network of women and maids forming a hidden council that keeps the island running. She is haunted by loneliness and the burden of duty, but she never allows herself to falter. Her story is one of endurance, cunning, and the invisible labor of women who hold the world together while men chase glory.
The Return of Odysseus
After years of wandering, Odysseus finally returns to Ithaca, but not as a conquering hero. Instead, he comes disguised as a beggar, guided by Athena, who is as invested in the crafting of his legend as in his survival. The king is weary, scarred, and uncertain, his homecoming shadowed by the knowledge that his absence has changed everything. He must navigate a palace full of hostile suitors and a wife he no longer knows, relying on cunning rather than strength. Athena's presence is both a blessing and a curse, as she manipulates events to ensure the story of Odysseus endures, even if the truth is far more complicated and painful than any song.
Suitors and Schemes
The palace is filled with suitors, each vying for Penelope's hand and the throne of Ithaca. Antinous and Eurymachus are the most prominent, their arrogance and entitlement unchecked by any real authority. The suitors feast, plot, and insult the household, oblivious to the quiet resistance of Penelope and her maids. Kenamon, a foreign suitor, stands apart, his presence a reminder of the wider world and the shifting alliances beyond Ithaca. The suitors' presence is both a threat and a catalyst, forcing Penelope to weave ever more intricate schemes to protect her son, her people, and herself from the violence simmering beneath the surface.
Telemachus Comes Home
Telemachus, Penelope's son, returns from his own journey seeking news of his father. He is no longer a boy, but not yet a man, hardened by disappointment and the weight of expectation. His homecoming is fraught with tension; he avoids his mother, ashamed of his perceived failures, and is wary of the suitors who once plotted his death. The reunion between mother and son is cold, marked by misunderstandings and unspoken grief. Telemachus's return upsets the fragile balance in the palace, setting in motion the final confrontation that will decide the fate of Ithaca.
Mother and Son Estranged
The gulf between Penelope and Telemachus widens as they struggle to communicate. Penelope's attempts at tenderness are rebuffed, her son's pride and shame making him unreachable. Both are haunted by regrets—Penelope for the years lost to duty, Telemachus for his inability to live up to his father's legend. Their estrangement is a microcosm of the larger fractures in Ithacan society, where old bonds have been eroded by absence, trauma, and the relentless demands of survival. The emotional distance between mother and son foreshadows the violence and loss to come.
The Women's Midnight Council
Beneath the surface of the palace, Penelope's council of women—maids, widows, priestesses, and warriors—meets in secret. They share intelligence, plot defenses, and prepare for the inevitable bloodshed. Priene, a foreign warrior, and Anaitis, priestess of Artemis, are among her closest allies. The women's council is a parallel power structure, invisible to the men who believe themselves in control. Their solidarity and resourcefulness are the true backbone of Ithaca's survival, and their plans will shape the outcome of the coming conflict as much as any man's sword.
The Beggar in the Hall
Disguised as a beggar, Odysseus enters his own hall, observing the suitors and the reactions of his wife and servants. He is struck by the changes in his home and the resilience of those left behind. The suitors mock and abuse him, while Penelope, ever cautious, treats him with measured hospitality. The beggar's presence is a catalyst, exposing the true nature of those in the palace and setting the stage for the reckoning to come. Odysseus's disguise allows him to see the reality of his kingdom—and the cost of his absence.
The Bow and the Blood
Penelope announces a contest: whoever can string Odysseus's bow and shoot an arrow through twelve axes will win her hand. The suitors fail, their bravado exposed as incompetence. Telemachus tries and fails as well, his humiliation complete. At last, the beggar—Odysseus—takes up the bow, revealing his identity in a moment of deadly clarity. The contest is a turning point, the prelude to a massacre that will cleanse the palace but also unleash new horrors. The bow becomes a symbol of both justice and the violence required to reclaim power.
The Slaughter of the Suitors
With the help of Telemachus and a handful of loyal servants, Odysseus unleashes a brutal slaughter upon the suitors. The violence is swift and merciless, justified by the sacred laws of hospitality but tainted by the excesses of vengeance. The women of the palace, who have played their own part in the downfall of the suitors, watch in horror and relief. The massacre restores Odysseus's authority but at a terrible cost, staining the halls with blood and setting the stage for further tragedy. The gods watch, their own interests entwined with the fate of mortals.
The Price of Vengeance
The aftermath of the slaughter is grim. The bodies of the suitors are left unburied, a provocation to their powerful families. Odysseus's return is not universally welcomed; the fathers of the dead sons—Eupheithes and Polybus—begin to muster forces for revenge. The cycle of violence threatens to spiral out of control, and the fragile peace Penelope maintained is shattered. Odysseus's need to assert mastery over his house blinds him to the consequences of his actions, and the kingdom teeters on the brink of civil war.
The Maids' Last Stand
In the most harrowing moment of Odysseus's return, the palace maids—accused of disloyalty and complicity with the suitors—are hanged. Euracleia, the old nursemaid, points them out, and Telemachus carries out the executions. Penelope is powerless to stop the atrocity, and the women's screams haunt the palace. The killing of the maids is both a ritual purification and a profound injustice, erasing the contributions and sacrifices of the women who kept Ithaca alive. The gods, especially Athena, are silent, complicit in the violence that upholds the old order.
The Aftermath and Exile
The palace is a place of mourning and fear. Penelope and her surviving allies retreat to the temple of Artemis, seeking sanctuary and plotting their next move. The women grieve for their lost sisters, their anger and sorrow fueling a new resolve. Penelope's power is diminished but not destroyed; she begins to look beyond Ithaca, sending messages to Mycenae and other allies. The men prepare for war, but it is the women who hold the memory of what has been lost—and what must be rebuilt.
Siege at Laertes' Farm
With the palace unsafe, Odysseus, Penelope, Telemachus, and their loyal followers retreat to Laertes' fortified farm. The fathers of the slain suitors, now leading a coalition of vengeful men, lay siege to the farm. The defenders are outnumbered and exhausted, their supplies dwindling. The tension between Odysseus and Penelope simmers, their old wounds and new grievances exposed by the pressure of survival. The farm becomes a crucible, testing the limits of loyalty, love, and endurance as the final battle looms.
The Women of the Forest
In a dramatic reversal, Penelope summons her secret army of women—hunters, widows, and maids trained in the arts of war. Led by Priene and Anaitis, they slip through the forest to reinforce the defenders at Laertes' farm. Their arrival shocks both friend and foe, challenging the assumptions of men who believed only they could fight. The women's courage and skill turn the tide, but not without cost. Priene falls in battle, her sacrifice a testament to the power and tragedy of women's resistance. The old world is dying, but something new struggles to be born.
The Last Stand of Ithaca
The siege reaches its climax as the attackers launch a full assault. The defenders, men and women alike, fight with everything they have. The gate is breached, and the fighting becomes hand-to-hand, brutal and chaotic. Odysseus and Penelope are forced to make impossible choices—who to save, who to sacrifice, what to surrender. In the end, Odysseus negotiates a surrender with Gaios, the mercenary captain, trading his own life and the safety of the women for a chance at peace. The cost is immense, and the survivors are left to reckon with what they have done.
The Arrival of Mycenae
Just as all seems lost, Elektra, daughter of Agamemnon, arrives with a Mycenaean army. Her presence is both salvation and humiliation, as Ithaca's fate is now in the hands of outsiders. Elektra's authority is absolute, her judgment swift. She demands the release of Odysseus and the punishment of the rebel fathers, but Penelope pleads for mercy. The intervention of Mycenae restores order, but at the price of Ithaca's independence. The old alliances are reforged, and the future of the island is secured—at least for now.
Mercy and the End of War
With the power to execute his enemies, Odysseus instead chooses exile for Polybus and mercy for the defeated. The cycle of blood is broken, not by divine intervention, but by the hard-won wisdom of suffering. Penelope's influence is felt in this decision, her plea for a different kind of justice echoing in the hall. The survivors gather for a feast, honoring the dead and the living, and the women who fought are quietly acknowledged, if not celebrated. The gods watch, their own power waning as the world changes.
The Feast and the Future
In the aftermath, Ithaca is changed forever. Odysseus and Penelope share a tentative reconciliation, their marriage scarred but enduring. The women who fought return to their lives, forever altered by what they have seen and done. Telemachus is left to find his own path, no longer a boy but not yet a man. The gods, especially Athena, reflect on the limits of their power and the stories that will outlast them. The future is uncertain, but for the first time, there is the possibility of something new—a world where women's voices are not only heard, but remembered.
Analysis
Claire North's The Last Song of Penelope is a radical reimagining of myth, centering the invisible labor, suffering, and agency of women in a world obsessed with male heroism. Through the dual narration of Athena and the lived experiences of Penelope and her allies, the novel exposes the violence and erasure at the heart of epic tradition. The story interrogates the costs of survival—personal, communal, and narrative—and asks what is left when the songs of men have faded. North's adaptation is both a critique and a celebration: it mourns the women lost to history, the maids hanged for loyalty, the warriors forgotten by poets, but it also insists on the possibility of something new. Mercy, solidarity, and the refusal to be defined by violence emerge as the true sources of hope. In a world where gods and kings are fading, it is the women—organizing, mourning, fighting, and remembering—who point the way forward. The novel's lesson is clear: stories matter, but whose stories are told, and at what cost, is the real battle.
Review Summary
The Last Song of Penelope receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, averaging 4.29/5 stars. Readers praise Claire North's feminist retelling, Athena's compelling narration, and the nuanced portrayals of Penelope and Odysseus. Many consider it a standout conclusion to the trilogy, lauding its humor, emotional depth, and gorgeous prose. Critics note slow pacing and battle sequences as weaknesses, while some feel the retelling strays too far from Homer's original. Most agree Penelope is brilliantly reimagined as a powerful, intelligent queen rather than a passive, grieving wife.
Characters
Penelope
Penelope is the heart of Ithaca, a woman whose intelligence and resilience sustain her kingdom through decades of uncertainty. She is defined by absence—her husband's, her son's, her own denied desires—but she refuses to be erased. Her relationships are complex: she loves Telemachus but cannot reach him; she respects Odysseus but is wounded by his choices; she is both leader and sister to her council of women. Penelope's psychological depth lies in her ability to endure, adapt, and scheme in a world that denies her agency. Her development is a journey from invisible labor to open resistance, from patient suffering to the assertion of her own story. She is both the victim and the architect of Ithaca's fate, her sorrow and strength inseparable.
Odysseus
Odysseus is a man remade by suffering, his legendary cunning now shadowed by trauma and regret. His return to Ithaca is not a triumph but a reckoning—with his wife, his son, and himself. He is both manipulator and manipulated, his actions shaped by Athena's designs and his own need for mastery. Odysseus's relationships are fraught: he cannot recognize the changes in Penelope, and his attempts to reclaim his house unleash new violence. Psychologically, he is torn between the roles of hero, husband, and king, never fully at home in any. His development is a slow, painful awakening to the costs of his legend and the necessity of mercy.
Telemachus
Telemachus is caught between childhood and manhood, crushed by the weight of his father's myth and his mother's expectations. His journey is one of disappointment and alienation; he returns home changed, but not in the ways he hoped. His relationship with Penelope is strained, marked by mutual misunderstanding and unspoken grief. With Odysseus, he seeks approval but finds only further confusion. Psychologically, Telemachus is defined by shame, pride, and a desperate need to prove himself. His development is incomplete, a reflection of a generation left adrift by the failures of their parents.
Athena
Athena is both narrator and participant, shaping events to ensure the survival of Odysseus's story—and her own relevance. She is torn between the roles of protector, strategist, and observer, her divinity both empowering and isolating. Athena's relationship to mortals is complex: she admires Penelope's cunning, pities Odysseus's suffering, and is frustrated by the limitations of her own power. Psychologically, she is marked by loneliness, ambition, and a yearning for meaning in a world that is moving beyond the gods. Her development is a meditation on the nature of stories, power, and the costs of survival.
Priene
Priene is a warrior from the east, a survivor of Troy, and the captain of Penelope's secret army. She is fierce, loyal, and uncompromising, her identity forged in battle and loss. Her relationship with Penelope is one of mutual respect and shared purpose; with the other women, she is both leader and protector. Psychologically, Priene is driven by duty and the need to find meaning after the destruction of her own people. Her development culminates in sacrifice, her death a symbol of the possibility—and the cost—of a new kind of heroism.
Kenamon
Kenamon is an Egyptian warrior and suitor, marked by exile and longing. He forms a quiet bond with Penelope, offering her a glimpse of a different life. His relationship with Telemachus is almost paternal, and with Penelope, it is tinged with unfulfilled desire and mutual respect. Psychologically, Kenamon is defined by displacement, loneliness, and the search for belonging. His departure is both a personal tragedy and a commentary on the limits of love and loyalty in a world ruled by violence and tradition.
Autonoe
Autonoe is one of Penelope's closest maids, a woman of sharp wit and deep loyalty. She is both participant and witness to the palace's secrets, her role shifting from servant to strategist as the crisis deepens. Her relationship with Penelope is intimate, marked by shared grief and unspoken understanding. Psychologically, Autonoe is shaped by trauma and the constant threat of violence, her resilience a testament to the hidden strength of women. Her survival is both a victory and a reminder of all that has been lost.
Anaitis
Anaitis is the priestess who provides sanctuary and guidance to Penelope and her allies. She is calm, practical, and deeply connected to the natural world. Her relationship with the other women is one of quiet authority, her faith a source of comfort and strength. Psychologically, Anaitis is marked by acceptance and a refusal to be cowed by the violence of men. Her presence is a reminder of the enduring power of female community and the possibility of a different kind of order.
Gaios
Gaios is the professional soldier hired by the fathers of the suitors. He is competent, dispassionate, and ultimately more interested in survival than glory. His relationship with Odysseus is one of mutual respect, and his decisions are guided by a code of honor that is flexible but not absent. Psychologically, Gaios is defined by realism and the scars of long experience. His willingness to negotiate and show mercy marks him as a new kind of man in a changing world.
Elektra
Elektra is the daughter of Agamemnon, a woman of intelligence, authority, and political acumen. Her arrival with the Mycenaean army is both rescue and assertion of dominance. Her relationship with Penelope is sisterly, marked by shared suffering and mutual recognition. Psychologically, Elektra is shaped by the trauma of her family's history and the demands of leadership. Her intervention restores order but also signals the end of Ithaca's independence, her presence a reminder of the larger forces shaping the fate of individuals.
Plot Devices
Dual Narration and Divine Perspective
The story is told through a blend of mortal and divine perspectives, with Athena as both narrator and character. This device allows for a re-examination of myth, exposing the constructed nature of heroism and the hidden labor of women. Athena's commentary is self-aware, ironic, and often critical of the very legends she helps create. The divine perspective also enables foreshadowing and dramatic irony, as the gods manipulate events while acknowledging their own limitations and eventual obsolescence.
Disguise and Revelation
Odysseus's return in disguise is both a practical strategy and a metaphor for the uncertainty of homecoming. The motif of disguise extends to Penelope and her council, whose true power is hidden beneath the surface. Revelation comes at moments of crisis—the contest of the bow, the slaughter of the suitors, the arrival of Mycenae—forcing characters to confront the reality behind the stories they tell themselves and each other.
Parallel Power Structures
The secret council of women, led by Penelope, Priene, and Anaitis, operates in parallel to the official councils of men. This device highlights the invisible labor and agency of women, challenging the traditional epic focus on male heroism. The women's strategies, alliances, and sacrifices are as decisive as any battle, and their story runs beneath and ultimately disrupts the dominant narrative.
Cycles of Violence and Mercy
The plot is driven by cycles of violence—Odysseus's vengeance on the suitors, the fathers' retaliation, the execution of the maids. Each act of violence threatens to unleash further bloodshed, but the story ultimately turns on moments of mercy: Penelope's plea for exile over execution, Odysseus's decision to spare his enemies, Gaios's willingness to negotiate. These choices are hard-won and ambiguous, suggesting that true heroism lies not in slaughter but in the refusal to perpetuate suffering.
Storytelling as Survival
The characters are acutely aware that their actions will be remembered—or forgotten—through the stories told about them. Athena's obsession with narrative immortality, Penelope's manipulation of her own legend, and Odysseus's struggle to live up to his myth all reflect the power of storytelling to shape reality. The plot is structured around key moments—contests, councils, battles—that are both lived experience and future legend, blurring the line between truth and tale.
The Songs of Penelope Series
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
