Plot Summary
Broken in the Hospital
Leo, under the alias Jake, lies broken in a hospital bed, physically shattered after a car accident and emotionally devastated by the loss of his brother Seth. Haunted by guilt and self-loathing, he rebuffs Dr. Fox, the hospital psychologist, who persistently tries to reach him. Leo's past is a tangle of trauma, abandonment, and self-destruction, and he feels unworthy of love or redemption. The only glimmer of hope is the memory of Evie, the girl he once loved and left behind. Dr. Fox's gentle persistence begins to crack Leo's defenses, planting the first seeds of trust and the possibility of healing, even as Leo remains convinced he is beyond saving.
Watching from Afar
After years apart, Leo returns to Cincinnati and secretly watches Evie, the girl he left behind. He is both relieved and tormented to see her thriving, independent, and kind, working hard and living simply. His longing for her is overwhelming, but fear of rejection and the weight of his own failures keep him at a distance. Leo's pride in Evie's resilience is mixed with guilt for abandoning her. He struggles with how to approach her, torn between the desire to reconnect and the fear that his presence will only bring her pain. The past and present collide as he realizes he is still deeply in love with her.
Ghosts and Goodbyes
Leo attends the funeral of Willow, a troubled friend from foster care, and sees Evie for the first time in years. Evie's eulogy—a fairy tale about the "Glass Princess"—evokes the pain and beauty of their shared childhood. The story is a metaphor for the fragility and strength of those who survive trauma. Leo is overwhelmed by memories and the realization that his love for Evie has never faded. The encounter is bittersweet, filled with regret for lost time and the ache of unspoken words. Leo's gesture to honor Willow's memory is a small act of redemption, but his longing for Evie only deepens.
The Pedestal and the Past
Dr. Fox challenges Leo's idealization of Evie and his belief that he is unworthy of her love. Through their sessions, Leo begins to confront the walls he has built around his heart and the self-hatred that drives his destructive choices. He reflects on Evie's courage to remain open and loving despite her hardships, and questions why he cannot do the same. The conversation forces Leo to examine the roots of his pain and the possibility of change. Dr. Fox insists that Leo must find self-worth independent of Evie's acceptance, urging him to become whole for himself and for her.
Stalker Revealed, Lies Unfold
Leo's secret following of Evie is exposed when she confronts him. Caught off guard, he panics and lies, claiming to be a friend of "Leo" sent to check on her. The lie is both a shield and a prison, allowing him to stay close but deepening his guilt. Evie's reaction is guarded, her pain at Leo's supposed death masked by indifference. The chemistry between them is undeniable, but the foundation is shaky. Leo is trapped by his own dishonesty, desperate to protect Evie from the truth of his past and his failures, even as he yearns for genuine connection.
Reconnecting, Regrets, and Gwen
Leo and Evie begin to reconnect, sharing moments of laughter and vulnerability. Leo is torn between the joy of being near her and the burden of his ongoing deception. Gwen, a figure from Leo's past, reappears, embodying the shallow, destructive choices he once made. Her presence is a reminder of the person he used to be and the life he is trying to leave behind. Leo's attempts to distance himself from Gwen and his old habits are complicated by guilt, shame, and the fear that he will never be worthy of Evie's love or forgiveness.
Seth's Memory and Guilt
Leo visits the grave of his brother Seth, overwhelmed by guilt for not protecting him and for abandoning him in pursuit of a better life. The memory of Seth is both a source of pain and a catalyst for change. Leo's grief is raw, his apology heartfelt, as he confronts the reality that he cannot undo the past. The act of remembrance is a step toward healing, but the weight of responsibility lingers. Leo's love for Seth and Evie becomes a driving force in his struggle to become a better man, even as he doubts his ability to do so.
First Date, First Kiss
Leo and Evie share their first real date, filled with nervous anticipation and the tentative rekindling of old feelings. The chemistry between them is electric, and their connection deepens as they open up about their lives and dreams. Leo is both exhilarated and terrified, knowing that his lies threaten the fragile trust they are rebuilding. The first kiss is a moment of pure joy, a glimpse of the happiness that might be possible if they can overcome the shadows of the past. For the first time, Leo allows himself to hope for a future with Evie.
Haunted by the Past
Leo's adoptive mother, Lauren, reappears, bringing with her the trauma of their abusive, manipulative relationship. Her presence is a trigger for Leo's deepest wounds, reigniting feelings of shame, anger, and helplessness. The encounter with Lauren threatens to unravel the progress Leo has made, as he is forced to confront the reality of his abuse and the impact it has had on his life. Dr. Fox encourages Leo to face his pain and to recognize that he is not to blame for Lauren's actions. The struggle to break free from her influence is ongoing and fraught with difficulty.
Dinner, Deceptions, and Desire
Leo and Evie's relationship intensifies, both emotionally and physically. They share laughter, stories, and dreams, finding comfort and healing in each other's presence. Yet, the foundation of their connection is still built on Leo's deception. The desire between them is powerful, but so is the fear of what will happen when the truth comes out. Leo is torn between the need to confess and the terror of losing Evie forever. The tension between honesty and self-preservation grows, as does the depth of their love.
Gwen's Interference, Evie's Pain
Gwen's manipulations and the public exposure of Leo's connection to her sow seeds of doubt and jealousy in Evie's mind. Misunderstandings and half-truths create distance and pain, threatening to undo the fragile trust that has been built. Leo's past choices and the consequences of his lies come to a head, forcing both him and Evie to confront the reality of their relationship. The pain of betrayal is acute, and the risk of losing each other becomes very real. Both must decide whether love is strong enough to survive the wounds of the past.
Confessions and Consequences
The weight of Leo's deception becomes unbearable, and the truth finally comes out—first through external revelation, then through Leo's own confession. Evie is devastated by the betrayal, her trust shattered. Leo is consumed by guilt and fear, but also by a sense of relief at no longer hiding. The aftermath is raw and painful, as both struggle to process the consequences of the lies and the depth of their feelings for each other. The possibility of forgiveness and reconciliation hangs in the balance, dependent on honesty, vulnerability, and the willingness to fight for love.
The Truth Comes Out
Leo bares his soul to Evie, sharing the full story of his past, his abuse, his guilt, and his longing for redemption. Evie listens, her own pain and anger mingling with empathy and understanding. The process is excruciating, but necessary for healing. Both are forced to confront the darkest parts of themselves and each other. The act of confession is an act of love, a leap of faith that opens the door to forgiveness and the possibility of a new beginning. The journey toward wholeness is not easy, but it is real.
Letters, Loss, and Hope
In the aftermath of the truth, Leo and Evie are separated, each grappling with their own pain and the question of whether love can survive betrayal. Leo writes letters, pouring out his heart and his hope for forgiveness. He reflects on his journey, the lessons learned, and the growth achieved. The support of friends and mentors, especially Dr. Fox, reinforces the message that healing is possible and that love is worth fighting for. The decision to fight for Evie is both an act of courage and an act of faith.
Fighting for Forgiveness
As Leo works to rebuild his life and prove his worth, justice is served in the form of Lauren's arrest and the closure of old wounds. Dr. Fox's intervention and the support of friends provide the foundation for Leo's continued healing. The process of forgiveness—of self and of each other—is ongoing, but the possibility of a future together becomes real. Leo's willingness to fight for Evie, and Evie's willingness to believe in him again, are testaments to the power of love and the resilience of the human spirit.
Full Circle, New Beginnings
Leo and Evie come full circle, returning to the place where their love began. The proposal on the rooftop is a symbol of healing, hope, and the promise of a new life together. Their shared dream of creating a safe haven for foster children becomes a reality, transforming their pain into purpose. The epilogue reveals a life built on love, forgiveness, and the courage to fight for happiness. The journey is not without scars, but the wounds have become the foundation for a future filled with joy, meaning, and the enduring power of love.
Characters
Leo (Jake Madsen)
Leo is the deeply scarred protagonist, shaped by a childhood of abuse, neglect, and the trauma of foster care. His identity is fractured—he becomes Jake Madsen after adoption, trying to escape his past. Leo is fiercely loyal, protective, and self-sacrificing, but also plagued by guilt, self-hatred, and a belief that he is unworthy of love. His relationship with Evie is the anchor of his life, representing both his greatest hope and his deepest regret. Through therapy and self-reflection, Leo confronts his demons, striving to become whole and to earn forgiveness. His journey is one of vulnerability, courage, and the transformative power of love.
Evie (Evelyn Cruise)
Evie is Leo's childhood love, a survivor of the foster care system who retains her kindness, hope, and capacity for love despite immense hardship. She is imaginative, empathetic, and fiercely independent, using storytelling as a means of survival and healing. Evie's strength lies in her ability to remain open and compassionate, even when wounded. Her relationship with Leo is both a source of joy and pain, as she grapples with betrayal and the challenge of forgiveness. Evie's journey is one of self-discovery, empowerment, and the reclamation of her own worth and dreams.
Dr. Fox
Dr. Fox is the hospital psychologist who becomes a crucial figure in Leo's recovery. He is patient, insightful, and unafraid to challenge Leo's defenses. Dr. Fox's approach is both compassionate and direct, guiding Leo to confront his pain, accept responsibility, and seek healing. His own background in long stories and computer expertise hints at a deeper understanding of trauma and justice. Dr. Fox's intervention in Lauren's crimes is an act of protection and advocacy, embodying the role of the father figure Leo never had. He represents the possibility of hope, change, and the importance of fighting for those who cannot fight for themselves.
Lauren
Lauren is Leo's adoptive mother and abuser, whose actions leave deep psychological scars. She is self-absorbed, delusional, and obsessed with control, using manipulation and seduction to maintain power over Leo. Lauren's inability to recognize the harm she causes is both infuriating and tragic. Her eventual arrest and exposure are necessary for Leo's healing, but the damage she inflicts lingers. Lauren embodies the destructive force of unchecked trauma and the importance of justice and accountability.
Gwen
Gwen is a figure from Leo's adoptive life, representing the shallow, destructive choices he made in an attempt to numb his pain. She is persistent, entitled, and manipulative, serving as both a temptation and a threat to Leo's new beginning with Evie. Gwen's interference creates conflict and misunderstanding, but ultimately highlights the contrast between the life Leo is leaving behind and the one he hopes to build.
Seth
Seth is Leo's younger brother, whose death is a catalyst for Leo's downward spiral and ongoing guilt. Seth's memory is both a source of pain and a reminder of the love and responsibility that drive Leo's actions. The act of visiting Seth's grave and seeking forgiveness is a turning point in Leo's journey, symbolizing the need to confront the past in order to move forward.
Willow
Willow is a fellow survivor of foster care, whose struggles with addiction and self-destruction mirror the dangers faced by those who are not able to overcome their trauma. Her death is a moment of reckoning for Leo and Evie, underscoring the importance of hope, connection, and the fight for survival. Willow's story is a reminder of the stakes involved and the cost of giving up.
Preston
Preston is Leo's adoptive father's business partner and a supportive presence in Leo's professional and personal life. He offers guidance, stability, and a sense of belonging, helping Leo navigate the challenges of leadership and legacy. Preston's loyalty and belief in Leo are crucial in moments of crisis, reinforcing the message that family can be chosen and that support is essential for healing.
Christine
Christine is Leo's receptionist and a surrogate mother figure, offering kindness, humor, and practical advice. Her presence is a balm to Leo's wounded spirit, and her support during times of crisis is invaluable. Christine's role as a mentor and friend highlights the importance of community and the healing power of everyday acts of care.
Landon
Landon is Evie's close friend, providing support, laughter, and a sense of family. His acceptance and encouragement are vital to Evie's journey, and his eventual role in The Willow House represents the possibility of building new, chosen families. Landon's presence is a reminder that healing is a collective effort and that love can be found in unexpected places.
Plot Devices
Dual Narratives and Unreliable Identity
The novel employs a dual narrative structure, alternating between Leo's internal struggles and his external actions. The use of an unreliable identity—Leo as Jake—creates dramatic irony, as the reader is aware of the truth before Evie is. This device heightens tension and emotional stakes, as the impending revelation looms over every interaction. The gradual unveiling of the past through therapy sessions, memories, and confessions allows for deep psychological exploration and the slow build of trust and vulnerability.
Foreshadowing and Symbolism
The story is rich with foreshadowing and symbolism, from the "Glass Princess" fairy tale to the counterclockwise whorled shell and the rooftop where love began. These motifs represent fragility, resilience, and the possibility of new beginnings. The act of storytelling—both literal and metaphorical—is a means of survival and healing, connecting past and present. The use of letters, tattoos, and physical spaces (the hospital, the grave, the rooftop) grounds the emotional journey in tangible symbols of pain and redemption.
Trauma, Healing, and Redemption Arc
The central plot device is the arc from trauma to healing, with each character's journey reflecting the challenges of overcoming abuse, loss, and self-doubt. Therapy, confession, and acts of love are the mechanisms of change, while setbacks and relapses underscore the difficulty of true transformation. The narrative structure mirrors the process of recovery—nonlinear, painful, and ultimately hopeful. The resolution is earned through vulnerability, accountability, and the willingness to fight for forgiveness and a better future.
Analysis
Leo by Mia Sheridan is a powerful exploration of trauma, love, and the arduous path to healing. At its core, the novel is about the ways in which our past shapes us, but does not have to define us. Through the intertwined journeys of Leo and Evie, Sheridan examines the enduring scars of abuse, the complexity of forgiveness, and the redemptive power of vulnerability. The story does not shy away from the darkness—addiction, betrayal, and self-hatred are confronted head-on—but it insists that hope is possible, even for the most wounded. The use of dual identities, confessional therapy, and symbolic motifs (like the rooftop and the counterclockwise shell) reinforce the themes of transformation and second chances. Ultimately, the novel argues that love is not a cure-all, but a catalyst for growth; it is through honesty, accountability, and the courage to fight for oneself and others that true healing occurs. Leo and Evie's journey is a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the belief that, no matter how broken we feel, we are all worth fighting for.
Last updated:
