Plot Summary
Shipwrecks and Secrets Collide
On a misty morning on Winthrop Island, Audrey Fisher is summoned to identify a body found at the edge of a cliff. The dead man, Harlan Walker, is tied to her mother, Meredith, in ways Audrey doesn't fully understand. The police probe for answers, but the real mystery is buried in the island's past—a shipwreck, a lost painting, and the tangled relationships of the Fisher family. As Audrey navigates the aftermath, she's forced to confront not only the secrets of her mother's life but also the unresolved wounds of her own.
Mothers, Daughters, and Damage
Audrey and her mother, Meredith, drive from California to Winthrop Island, seeking refuge from scandal and addiction. Meredith, a faded Hollywood star, is in withdrawal and hiding from the public eye. Their relationship is fraught with resentment, humor, and old pain. Audrey, reeling from her husband's betrayal and her dog's death, is tasked with keeping Meredith sober and out of trouble. The island, with its ghosts and memories, becomes a crucible for both women as they try to rebuild—or finally break—their bond.
The Wreck of the Atlantic
Interwoven with the present is the harrowing account of Providence Dare, a servant fleeing scandal in 1846. Boarding the steamship Atlantic under an assumed name, she's swept into a deadly storm. The ship's wreck off Winthrop Island becomes both literal and metaphorical: a disaster that shapes the island's history and the fate of its inhabitants. Providence's narrative, full of fear, guilt, and longing, mirrors the struggles of Audrey and Meredith, binding past and present in a cycle of survival and loss.
Ghosts of Winthrop Island
As Audrey settles into the decaying grandeur of Greyfriars, Meredith's childhood home, she reconnects with her estranged father, Mike, the local barkeep. Their reunion is awkward, tender, and laced with regret. The island's history—its shipwrecks, its summer colonies, its tangled families—haunts every conversation. Meredith's own past, full of wild summers, forbidden loves, and a fateful night on a sailboat, resurfaces, threatening to upend the fragile peace Audrey is trying to build.
The Art of Survival
Meredith's battle with sobriety is both comic and tragic. She purges the house of alcohol, swims laps to quiet her cravings, and spars with Audrey over every detail of their exile. Audrey, meanwhile, finds purpose in cleaning up the Mohegan Inn's kitchen and reconnecting with Mike. The discovery of a trunk full of lost paintings—erotic nudes by the fictional Henry Irving—offers a tantalizing chance at redemption and fortune, but also stirs up old rivalries and new dangers.
Old Flames, New Wounds
Audrey's encounters with Sedge Peabody, a charming local with hidden depths, ignite a slow-burning romance. Their connection is complicated by Audrey's trust issues and the scars left by her failed marriage. Meanwhile, Meredith and Mike fall back into old habits, their chemistry undimmed by time or disappointment. The island becomes a stage for second chances and old mistakes, as everyone grapples with what—and whom—they truly want.
The Past Washes Ashore
The paintings found in the Mo's cellar are authenticated as lost works of Irving, painted during a mysterious period after his wife's death. Their value is immense, but their provenance is contested. As legal battles loom, the story of Providence Dare—her affair with Irving, her flight from scandal, her survival of the shipwreck—emerges as the key to everything. The past, long buried, demands to be reckoned with.
Inheritance and Identity
Audrey, Meredith, and Mike must decide what to do with the paintings—and with each other. Questions of inheritance, both material and emotional, come to the fore. Audrey's paternity, Meredith's choices, and the legacy of Providence Dare all intertwine. The island's history is not just a backdrop but a living force, shaping the destinies of its inhabitants.
Lovers, Liars, and Legacies
Audrey's estranged husband, David, reappears, desperate and dangerous. He kidnaps Audrey and the most valuable painting, setting off a chase that ends in violence and heartbreak. Sedge risks everything to save her, and in the aftermath, Audrey must confront the truth about love, loyalty, and the lies we tell to survive. The legacy of Providence Dare—her courage, her mistakes, her capacity for love—becomes a guide for the living.
The Truth Beneath the Waves
The true story of the Atlantic's wreck, and of Providence's role in Irving's death, is finally revealed. Through a long-lost manuscript, the tangled threads of guilt, innocence, and survival are unraveled. The island's present-day dramas—legal battles, family feuds, romantic entanglements—are all haunted by the choices of those who came before. The truth, once unearthed, offers both closure and new beginnings.
The Price of Love
Audrey and Sedge, battered by trauma and misunderstanding, must decide if they can trust each other enough to build a future. Meredith and Mike, after decades of push and pull, face the possibility of real commitment. The cost of love—its risks, its losses, its demands—is laid bare. Only by embracing vulnerability can any of them hope to find peace.
Confessions and Consequences
As the dust settles, the characters reckon with their actions. Meredith confesses the truth about that long-ago night on the sailboat, offering closure to a grieving father. Audrey faces her own guilt and fear, learning that forgiveness—of others and of herself—is the only way forward. The island, with its shipwrecks and secrets, becomes a place of healing as well as pain.
The Bell Tolls Again
The Atlantic's bell, once a symbol of tragedy, becomes a reminder of survival and resilience. The islanders gather to honor the lost and celebrate the living. The paintings, once hidden, are now a source of pride and connection. The cycles of love and loss, of leaving and returning, continue—but with new understanding and hope.
Forgiveness and Fresh Starts
Audrey and Meredith, at last, find a measure of peace with each other. Mike and Meredith contemplate a future together, while Audrey and Sedge tentatively rebuild their trust. The inheritance left by Harlan Walker offers new possibilities, but the real gift is the freedom to choose—where to live, whom to love, and how to forgive.
Home Is Where You Choose
The characters realize that home is not just a place, but a choice. Audrey considers staying on Winthrop Island, running the Mo, and building a life with Sedge. Meredith, ever restless, contemplates a new chapter but knows she can always return. The island, with its storms and shipwrecks, becomes a symbol of both danger and sanctuary.
The Gist of Mercy
The final revelations—about Providence Dare, about the paintings, about the tangled web of love and loss—bring a sense of mercy to all involved. The characters learn that to be human is to err, to hurt, and to heal. Mercy, not justice, is what allows them to move forward.
Under the Stars, Together
As summer wanes, the islanders gather under the stars. Audrey and Sedge, Meredith and Mike, and the rest of the cast find themselves changed by all they've endured. The past is not forgotten, but it no longer dictates the future. Under the stars, they choose each other—imperfect, wounded, and full of hope.
Characters
Audrey Fisher
Audrey is the emotional heart of the novel—a woman battered by betrayal, loss, and the weight of her mother's legacy. Her relationship with Meredith is fraught with resentment and longing, shaped by years of neglect and codependence. Audrey's journey is one of self-discovery: learning to trust, to forgive, and to claim her own identity. Her romance with Sedge Peabody is both a source of healing and a test of her ability to risk love again. Audrey's connection to the past—through the lost paintings and the story of Providence Dare—mirrors her struggle to reconcile where she comes from with who she wants to be. Her arc is one of moving from survival to genuine belonging.
Meredith Fisher
Meredith is a force of nature: beautiful, talented, and deeply flawed. Her addiction, impulsivity, and emotional volatility have left scars on everyone around her, especially Audrey. Yet beneath her bravado lies a profound vulnerability—a woman haunted by her own childhood, her failed relationships, and a traumatic night that changed everything. Meredith's journey is about facing the truth, making amends, and learning that love is not just about passion or drama, but about showing up. Her dynamic with Mike is both comic and poignant, a testament to the enduring power of first love and the possibility of second chances.
Mike Kennedy
Mike is the island's everyman: bartender, father, and keeper of local lore. His relationship with Meredith is a study in loyalty and heartbreak—he loves her despite everything, and his devotion to Audrey is unwavering, even if belated. Mike's arc is about stepping up: claiming his role as a father, fighting for his family's legacy, and daring to hope for happiness with Meredith. He is both comic relief and emotional ballast, grounding the novel's more dramatic elements in everyday decency and resilience.
Sedge Peabody
Sedge is the antidote to Audrey's past wounds: patient, kind, and unafraid to be vulnerable. His own history—privilege mixed with disappointment, a failed marriage, a hidden business success—gives him depth and empathy. Sedge's pursuit of Audrey is marked by respect and understanding; he knows she needs time and space, but he's willing to risk everything for her. His near-fatal act of heroism crystallizes the novel's themes of sacrifice and the courage to love. Sedge is the rare romantic lead who is both strong and soft, a partner rather than a savior.
Providence Dare
Providence is the 19th-century counterpart to Audrey and Meredith—a woman fleeing scandal, seeking safety, and forced to make impossible choices. Her affair with Henry Irving, her survival of the Atlantic's wreck, and her ultimate sacrifice for love and justice echo through the generations. Providence's manuscript becomes the key to resolving the present-day legal and emotional crises. Her story is one of agency, guilt, and the search for redemption—a reminder that the past is never truly past.
Harlan Walker
Harlan is the novel's most tragic figure: a man broken by the loss of his son, searching for answers and meaning. His connection to Meredith and Audrey is both literal and symbolic—he is the bridge between past and present, between guilt and forgiveness. Harlan's final act—leaving behind the manuscript that exonerates Audrey and reveals the truth—transforms him from a figure of suspicion to one of mercy. His death is both an ending and a gift, allowing the living to move forward.
David (Audrey's husband)
David is the shadow that haunts Audrey's present—a husband who abandons her, steals from her, and returns only to endanger her further. His charisma masks a deep selfishness and instability. David's actions force Audrey to confront her own patterns of trust and self-worth. He is both a cautionary tale and a catalyst, pushing Audrey toward the realization that she deserves better.
Mallory Adams
Mallory is the novel's intellectual anchor—a woman who helps authenticate the lost paintings and navigate the legal and historical complexities. Her partnership with Monk Adams is a model of mutual respect and support. Mallory's research and advocacy are crucial to resolving the central mystery and securing Audrey's future. She represents the power of knowledge, friendship, and quiet competence.
Monk Adams
Monk is both a celebrity and a local, bridging the worlds of art, music, and community. His generosity, humor, and loyalty make him a beloved figure. Monk's role in the story is to facilitate connections—between Audrey and Sedge, between the past and the present, between the island's various tribes. He is a reminder that home is as much about people as it is about place.
John Starkweather
Starkweather is Providence Dare's pursuer and, ultimately, her protector. His dogged pursuit of the truth is complicated by his growing feelings for Providence. Their relationship, forged in crisis, is a meditation on justice, mercy, and the possibility of redemption. Starkweather's fate—sacrificing himself to save Providence—echoes through the generations, shaping the destinies of all who come after.
Plot Devices
Dual Timelines and Interwoven Narratives
The novel's structure alternates between the present-day story of Audrey, Meredith, and their family, and the 19th-century account of Providence Dare and the wreck of the Atlantic. This device allows the author to explore themes of survival, guilt, and redemption across generations. The historical narrative is not just a backdrop but a living force, shaping the characters' choices and the island's fate. The interweaving of timelines creates suspense, deepens emotional resonance, and underscores the cyclical nature of trauma and healing.
Found Manuscript and Lost Art
The discovery of Providence Dare's manuscript and the lost paintings of Henry Irving serve as both plot catalysts and symbols. They are the literal inheritance that drives the legal and emotional conflicts, but also metaphors for the secrets, wounds, and gifts passed down through families. The authentication and provenance of the art become a battleground for questions of identity, belonging, and justice. The manuscript, in particular, is a classic device: a voice from the past that reveals hidden truths and offers a path to resolution.
Foreshadowing and Echoes
Throughout the novel, images and events repeat across time: shipwrecks, storms, lost children, the tolling of bells. These echoes create a sense of fate and inevitability, but also of hope—the idea that what was broken can be mended, that what was lost can be found. The use of foreshadowing heightens suspense and emotional impact, as the reader senses that the past is always about to break into the present.
Multiple Points of View
By giving voice to a range of characters—Audrey, Meredith, Mike, Sedge, Providence, Harlan—the novel allows the reader to inhabit different experiences and motivations. This multiplicity of perspectives complicates easy judgments and highlights the ways in which everyone is both victim and perpetrator, wounded and wounding. The shifting POVs also allow for dramatic irony, as the reader knows more than any one character, and for moments of revelation and catharsis.
Analysis
Under the Stars is a sweeping, emotionally charged novel that uses the device of a historical shipwreck to explore the wreckage and resilience of modern families. At its core, the book is about survival—literal and metaphorical. The characters are all, in their own ways, shipwrecked: by addiction, betrayal, loss, and the weight of inherited trauma. The dual timelines allow the author to draw powerful parallels between past and present, showing how the choices of one generation ripple forward to shape the next. The novel is also a meditation on forgiveness—of others and of oneself—and on the courage it takes to love, to stay, and to start over. The lost paintings and the found manuscript are not just MacGuffins but potent symbols of the ways in which art, memory, and story can redeem what is broken. Ultimately, the book argues that home is not a place but a choice, that mercy is more important than justice, and that the only way to heal is to face the truth, forgive the past, and risk loving again. Under the Stars is both a gripping family saga and a profound reflection on what it means to be human.
Last updated:
