Plot Summary
Devil's Hour in Goetia
In the mining town of Goetia, on the high holy day of Aventum Angelorum, a black wind stirs old resentments and supernatural unease. Celeste Semyaza, a half-Elect, half-Fallen card dealer at the Eden saloon, keeps a wary eye on her sister Mariel, the town's beloved Fallen songbird. The night's revelry is interrupted by violence at Celeste's table, revealing the ever-present tension between the privileged Elect and the marginalized Fallen. Celeste's fierce protectiveness of Mariel is clear, as is her own precarious place between two worlds. The night's ill omens foreshadow the chaos to come, as the sisters' bond is tested by forces both human and divine.
Sisters and Sins
After the brawl, Celeste seeks solace in the alley with Hypatia, the Eden's formidable owner. Their banter reveals Celeste's deep sense of responsibility for Mariel, rooted in their shared, troubled past. Hypatia warns Celeste not to let her protectiveness become a prison for them both. The conversation hints at old heartbreaks—especially Celeste's with the demon Abraxas—and the loneliness that comes from living between worlds. When news arrives that Mariel has been arrested by the Virtues, the Elect's enforcers, Celeste's worst fears are realized. The sisters' fates are now entwined with the town's darkest powers.
Virtues Descend, Mariel Taken
The Virtues, masked and merciless, parade Mariel through the streets, accused of murdering one of their own. The crowd's outrage is palpable, but the Virtues' authority is absolute. Celeste's attempts to intervene are futile; she is forced to watch as her sister is taken away, bloodied and broken. The spectacle exposes the deep divisions in Goetia—between Elect and Fallen, law and justice, power and powerlessness. Celeste's desperation grows, and she resolves to do whatever it takes to save Mariel, even if it means confronting her own past and the town's most dangerous secrets.
Bargains with Demons
With Mariel imprisoned, Celeste turns to Abraxas, the enigmatic demon lord and her former lover. Their reunion is fraught with longing and regret, as old wounds are reopened. Abraxas offers Celeste a protective charm and crucial information about the Virtues' secret court, the Circle, where Mariel will be judged. The price of his help is ambiguous, tangled in the unresolved passion and pain between them. Celeste's willingness to bargain with a demon underscores her desperation and the blurred lines between good and evil in Goetia.
The Circle's Shadow
Celeste infiltrates the courthouse, navigating a labyrinth of prejudice and bureaucracy. She learns that Mariel's trial will be held in the Virtues' Circle, a clandestine court where spiritual "fitness" matters more than evidence. The head of the Order of Chamuel, Mr. Ibrahim, offers Celeste the role of advocatus diaboli—Mariel's defender. The position is both an opportunity and a trap, as the Circle's justice is designed to condemn the Fallen. Celeste's resolve hardens; she will use every tool at her disposal, even if it means embracing the parts of herself she has long denied.
The Eden's Bloody Secret
Celeste and Hypatia investigate the scene of the murder at the Eden. Blood stains and laudanum bottles suggest Mariel's story is incomplete. Hypatia reveals Mariel's secret affair with an Elect doctor, Daniel, deepening Celeste's sense of betrayal and confusion. The evidence points to a tangled web of love, jealousy, and power. Celeste's faith in her sister is shaken, but her determination to save her only grows. The search for the real killer becomes a quest to understand the truth of Mariel's heart—and Celeste's own.
The Doctor's Double Life
Celeste's investigation leads her to Dr. Daniel Alameda's widow, who reveals Daniel's infidelities and his connection to the Virtues. The encounter is hostile and painful, exposing the cost of Daniel's double life. Celeste realizes Mariel was not Daniel's only lover, and that many women in Goetia have been hurt by men like him. The lines between victim and perpetrator blur, and Celeste is forced to confront the limits of her own understanding. The search for justice becomes a reckoning with the town's—and her own—complicity in cycles of harm.
Poisoned Promises
Celeste's pursuit of answers brings her to Tabor, Daniel's business partner and a Virtue. Tabor, driven mad by divinity mining, poisons Celeste, revealing the ruthless lengths the powerful will go to protect their interests. As she succumbs, Abraxas intervenes, saving her with his blood at the cost of awakening dangerous desires. The rescue is both salvation and damnation, binding Celeste and Abraxas in a new, fraught intimacy. The experience leaves Celeste changed, her sense of self and morality further destabilized.
Truths in the Dark
In the aftermath, Celeste and Abraxas grapple with the consequences of their renewed connection. Their night together is passionate but haunted by guilt and the knowledge that love cannot erase the past. Celeste devises a plan to save Mariel by framing Lilitha, a jealous saloon girl, for Daniel's murder. The moral cost is high, and Abraxas warns her of the darkness she courts. Celeste's willingness to sacrifice another for her sister's sake marks a turning point, as she embraces the ambiguity of her own soul.
The Trial's Reckoning
The trial is a spectacle of power and prejudice. Celeste, wearing Abraxas's protective charm, prepares to manipulate the gloria—a device that compels truth. But Mariel, refusing to let her sister bear the burden, seizes the gloria and confesses to Daniel's murder. Her admission is both an act of agency and a plea for mercy. The court is stunned, and Mariel's pregnancy complicates the verdict. The trial exposes the limits of justice in a world built on inequality and the redemptive power of self-sacrifice.
Sacrifice and Salvation
Mariel's confession spares Lilitha and forces the court to confront the humanity of the Fallen. Daniel's widow, Mrs. Alameda, offers to take in Mariel and her unborn child, promising a chance at rehabilitation. The judge commutes Mariel's sentence, postponing final judgment until after the birth. Celeste is left reeling, her efforts to save her sister both vindicated and rendered moot by Mariel's own courage. The sisters' bond is forever altered, marked by love, loss, and the cost of survival.
Rain, Ruin, and Release
With Mariel in Mrs. Alameda's care and the trial concluded, Celeste is left homeless and adrift. The rain-soaked streets of Goetia mirror her grief and exhaustion. She returns to her childhood home, now abandoned, and confronts the ghosts of her past. The town's divisions remain, but Celeste's journey has changed her. She is no longer defined by her role as Mariel's protector or by her longing for Abraxas. The future is uncertain, but she is free to choose her own path.
The Devil's Farewell
Abraxas visits Celeste one last time, their final encounter marked by regret and acceptance. Both acknowledge the ways they have clung to the past and to each other, unable to move forward. Abraxas departs, seeking his own redemption, and Celeste is left to reckon with the consequences of her choices. Their parting is bittersweet, a recognition that love alone cannot heal all wounds or bridge all divides.
Guilt, Grace, and Goetia
Celeste reflects on the harm she has caused—to Lilitha, to Hypatia and Zeke, to herself. She vows to make amends, even as she recognizes that some wounds may never fully heal. The town of Goetia, with its mingled beauty and brutality, becomes a symbol of the world's complexity. Celeste's journey is one of self-knowledge, as she learns to accept her own flaws and the impossibility of perfect redemption.
The Weight of Redemption
The story's end finds Celeste alone but not defeated. She has lost much—her home, her sister, her lover—but gained a deeper understanding of herself and the world. The rain that falls on Goetia is both cleansing and mournful, a reminder that healing is possible but never complete. Celeste's willingness to face the consequences of her actions, to seek forgiveness and forge a new path, is her truest act of courage.
Sisters Unbound
Mariel's decision to accept responsibility for her actions frees both sisters from the roles that have defined them. Celeste is no longer merely a protector, and Mariel is no longer a victim. Their parting is painful but necessary, a step toward autonomy and growth. The sisters' love endures, transformed by honesty and the willingness to let each other go.
Ashes Washed by Rain
As dawn breaks over Goetia, Celeste sits on the porch of her old home, wrapped in Abraxas's blanket. The rain continues to fall, washing away the ash and the past. She is alone, but the weight of guilt and regret is tempered by the possibility of renewal. The story ends not with triumph or despair, but with the quiet hope that even in a world of devils and angels, redemption is possible for those who seek it.
Characters
Celeste Semyaza
Celeste is the story's protagonist, a half-Elect, half-Fallen woman who straddles the line between privilege and marginalization. Fiercely protective of her sister Mariel, Celeste is driven by guilt over their shared past and a deep sense of responsibility. Her pragmatic, sometimes ruthless nature is balanced by a longing for connection and belonging. Celeste's relationship with Abraxas, the demon lord, reveals her capacity for passion and self-doubt. Over the course of the story, she is forced to confront the limits of her own morality, the cost of loyalty, and the necessity of letting go. Her journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns to accept her own flaws and the complexity of love, justice, and redemption.
Mariel Semyaza
Mariel is Celeste's younger sister, a beautiful and talented singer marked by her Fallen heritage. Idolized by the town for her voice, she is also vulnerable to exploitation and betrayal. Mariel's secret affair with Daniel, an Elect doctor, and her subsequent pregnancy set the story's tragedy in motion. Her confession at the trial is an act of agency and sacrifice, freeing both herself and Celeste from the roles that have confined them. Mariel's character embodies the tension between victimhood and culpability, innocence and defiance. Her development is a testament to the power of self-acceptance and the courage to face the consequences of one's actions.
Abraxas
Abraxas is a charismatic, immortal demon who once led Lucifer's armies and now lingers in Goetia, haunted by loss and longing. His relationship with Celeste is passionate, fraught with unresolved desire and mutual wounds. Abraxas is both a source of power and temptation, offering Celeste the means to save her sister at a moral cost. His own journey is one of self-exile and eventual acceptance that love cannot be forced or bargained for. Abraxas's presence in the story blurs the boundaries between good and evil, highlighting the complexity of desire, loyalty, and redemption.
Hypatia
Hypatia is the formidable owner of the Eden and a maternal figure to Celeste and Mariel. Practical, tough, and deeply loyal, she provides both sanctuary and hard truths. Her relationship with Celeste is marked by affection and frustration, as she urges Celeste to live for herself rather than for others. Hypatia's own romantic entanglements and her willingness to bend the rules for those she loves reveal her as a survivor who understands the cost of living on society's margins.
Zeke
Zeke is the Eden's bartender and a gifted inventor, whose creations are powered by scraps of divinity. As a Fallen man, he occupies a precarious position in Goetia but remains optimistic and supportive. Zeke's friendship with Celeste is marked by kindness and quiet strength. His imaginarium is a symbol of hope and ingenuity in a world defined by hierarchy and oppression. Zeke's willingness to help, even at personal risk, underscores the importance of community and solidarity.
Mr. Ibrahim
Ibrahim is the head of the Order of Chamuel and the architect of the Circle's secret justice. Outwardly courteous and reasonable, he is a master manipulator who uses the system to maintain power. Ibrahim's offer to make Celeste Mariel's defender is both a test and a trap, designed to uphold the appearance of fairness while ensuring the Fallen's subjugation. His interactions with Celeste reveal the hypocrisy and self-interest at the heart of Goetia's ruling class.
Daniel Alameda
Daniel is the charming, faithless doctor whose affair with Mariel—and many other women—sets the tragedy in motion. As a member of the Virtues, he embodies the town's double standards: revered in public, predatory in private. Daniel's death exposes the vulnerability of the Fallen and the dangers of crossing social boundaries. His legacy is one of harm and heartbreak, forcing those left behind to reckon with the consequences of his actions.
Lilitha
Lilitha is a healer-turned-saloon girl, ambitious and jealous of Mariel's success. Her rivalry with Mariel and her own secrets make her a convenient target for Celeste's desperate plan. Lilitha's fate—being enthralled and sacrificed to save Mariel—highlights the story's moral ambiguity and the collateral damage of survival. Her character is a reminder of the many unseen victims in a world built on exploitation.
Mrs. Alameda
Daniel's widow is initially hostile, her grief and anger directed at the women her husband betrayed. Yet, in the trial's climax, she offers to take in Mariel and her unborn child, choosing compassion over vengeance. Mrs. Alameda's transformation is a testament to the possibility of grace and the power of shared suffering to foster empathy.
Tabor
Tabor is Daniel's business partner and a Virtue driven mad by exposure to divinity. His paranoia and cruelty make him a dangerous adversary. Tabor's attempt to poison Celeste and his subsequent death at Abraxas's hands expose the rot at the heart of Goetia's power structure. He is both a symbol and a victim of the town's relentless pursuit of progress at any cost.
Plot Devices
Duality and Passing
The story's central device is Celeste's dual heritage—half-Elect, half-Fallen—which allows her to move between worlds but never fully belong to either. This duality is mirrored in the town's structure, the sisters' relationship, and the blurred lines between good and evil. The motif of "passing" recurs, as characters hide or reveal their true selves to survive. The narrative structure alternates between moments of intimacy and public spectacle, emphasizing the tension between private truth and public performance.
The Circle and the Gloria
The Virtues' Circle is a clandestine court where the accused's spiritual worth is judged rather than the facts of the case. The gloria, a mechanical device that compels truth, serves as both a literal and symbolic test of character. These devices expose the hypocrisy of the Elect's justice and the impossibility of true fairness in a system designed to condemn the marginalized. Foreshadowing and misdirection are used to heighten suspense, as the true nature of the crime and the characters' motivations are gradually revealed.
Bargains and Sacrifice
The motif of bargaining—whether with Abraxas, the Virtues, or one's own conscience—runs throughout the story. Characters are forced to weigh the cost of survival against the price of their souls. Sacrifice, both willing and coerced, is a recurring theme: Celeste's willingness to frame Lilitha, Mariel's confession, Abraxas's departure. These choices drive the emotional arc and underscore the story's exploration of agency, guilt, and redemption.
Analysis
Rebecca Roanhorse's Tread of Angels is a genre-bending novella that fuses Western, noir, and fantasy to interrogate the boundaries of justice, identity, and redemption. At its heart, the story is about the costs of survival in a world built on hierarchy and exclusion. Through Celeste's journey, Roanhorse explores the pain of living between worlds—never fully accepted, always negotiating one's place. The narrative's supernatural elements—Virtues, demons, divinity mining—serve as metaphors for real-world systems of power and prejudice. The trial at the Circle exposes the hollowness of "justice" when it is wielded by the powerful to maintain their own dominance. Yet, the novella resists nihilism: acts of grace, confession, and self-sacrifice offer the possibility of change, even if imperfect. The ending, with its rain-soaked ambiguity, suggests that redemption is not a destination but a process—one that requires honesty, courage, and the willingness to let go. In a world of devils and angels, Roanhorse reminds us, it is our choices—and our capacity for empathy—that define us.
Last updated:
