Key Takeaways
1. Elizebeth Smith Friedman: A Pioneer in Cryptanalysis
Like the open code in Dickinson’s letters, Elizebeth could appear ordinary on the surface.
Unassuming Genius. Elizebeth Smith Friedman, often overshadowed by her husband William, was a brilliant cryptanalyst who played a pivotal role in shaping modern codebreaking. Her ability to decipher complex codes and ciphers was instrumental in combating organized crime during Prohibition and uncovering Nazi spy networks during World War II. Despite her extraordinary contributions, she often remained in the shadows, her work unacknowledged due to security concerns and gender biases of the time.
Breaking Barriers. Elizebeth's journey was marked by ambition and grit, overcoming societal expectations and professional obstacles to excel in a male-dominated field. Her story highlights the importance of recognizing and celebrating the contributions of women in STEM fields, particularly in areas where their work has been historically overlooked. Her work was essential to national security, and her skills were highly sought after by various government agencies.
Lasting Impact. Elizebeth's legacy extends beyond her specific achievements, inspiring future generations of codebreakers and intelligence professionals. Her story serves as a reminder that true genius can often be found in unexpected places, and that perseverance and determination can overcome even the most daunting challenges. Her work laid the foundation for modern cryptanalysis techniques.
2. Early Life and Education: Seeds of a Codebreaker
What you see, early on, is that young Elizebeth Smith was determined to be different.
Defying Expectations. Born in 1892, Elizebeth Smith grew up in a large family in rural Indiana, where she developed a keen interest in languages and a rebellious spirit against societal norms. Despite facing disapproval from her father, who believed higher education was a waste of time for girls, she pursued her academic ambitions with unwavering determination. Her early life experiences shaped her into an independent and resourceful individual, qualities that would prove invaluable in her future career.
Academic Pursuits. Elizebeth's passion for words and languages led her to excel in her studies, particularly in German and Latin. She attended the College of Wooster and later Hillsdale College, where she honed her analytical skills and developed a love for literature and poetry. These academic pursuits laid the foundation for her future career in cryptanalysis, which required a deep understanding of language patterns and logical reasoning.
Early Influences. Elizebeth's mother, Sopha, played a crucial role in encouraging her daughter to pursue her dreams and challenge societal expectations. Sopha's own experiences as a teacher and her belief in the importance of education instilled in Elizebeth a strong sense of self-worth and a desire to make a meaningful contribution to the world. This support system was essential in helping Elizebeth overcome the obstacles she faced in her early life.
3. Riverbank: An Unconventional Beginning
There Elizebeth found herself in a strange new world.
A Millionaire's Estate. In 1916, Elizebeth's life took an unexpected turn when she was offered a job at Riverbank, a unique research estate owned by millionaire George Fabyan. Fabyan, a man of eccentric tastes and unconventional ideas, had assembled a team of experts to explore various scientific and intellectual pursuits, including the study of Bacon's cipher. This opportunity provided Elizebeth with a chance to escape the limitations of traditional female roles and embark on a path of intellectual discovery.
Bacon's Cipher. At Riverbank, Elizebeth joined a team led by Elizabeth Wells Gallup, who believed that Shakespeare's plays contained secret messages encoded using Bacon's cipher. While Elizebeth initially embraced the project, she soon began to question the validity of Gallup's theories. This experience taught her the importance of critical thinking and the need to challenge established beliefs, even when they were held by respected authorities.
Meeting William. Riverbank was also where Elizebeth met William Friedman, a young scientist who shared her intellectual curiosity and her skepticism about Gallup's project. Their shared doubts and their mutual love for language and puzzles sparked a deep connection that would transform their lives and the future of American codebreaking. Riverbank provided the unique environment for their partnership to blossom.
4. World War I: A Nation's Call to Codebreaking
Code breaking even helped drag the United States into the war.
The War of Codebreakers. As World War I raged in Europe, the United States found itself increasingly drawn into the conflict. The advent of radio communication made codebreaking a critical skill, as both sides sought to intercept and decipher enemy messages. Recognizing the need for skilled cryptanalysts, the U.S. government turned to Riverbank, where Elizebeth and William were poised to make their mark.
Riverbank's Contribution. Elizebeth and William quickly established themselves as the nation's leading codebreaking team, deciphering messages for various government agencies, including the War Department, the Navy, and the Justice Department. Their ability to crack even the most complex codes within hours made them invaluable assets in the war effort. They trained military personnel in codebreaking techniques, sharing their knowledge and expertise to bolster the nation's intelligence capabilities.
Early Successes. The Friedmans' work at Riverbank played a crucial role in uncovering German plots and disrupting enemy operations. Their success in deciphering intercepted messages helped to strengthen the case against German agents and contributed to the overall Allied war effort. Their work was essential to national security, and their skills were highly sought after by various government agencies.
5. Love and Partnership: The Friedman Codebreaking Duo
Working together, they were solving problems that no one else could.
A Perfect Match. Elizebeth and William's professional partnership blossomed into a deep and enduring love. Their shared passion for codebreaking, their complementary skills, and their mutual respect created a bond that transcended the workplace. They became an inseparable team, both in their personal lives and in their professional endeavors.
Complementary Skills. While both Elizebeth and William possessed exceptional codebreaking abilities, they each brought unique strengths to the table. William excelled at analysis and technical problem-solving, while Elizebeth possessed remarkable intuition and a knack for spotting patterns. Their combined talents made them an unstoppable force in the world of cryptanalysis.
Overcoming Obstacles. Their relationship faced challenges, including societal prejudices against interfaith marriages and the disapproval of some family members. However, their love for each other and their commitment to their shared goals allowed them to overcome these obstacles and build a life together based on mutual respect and unwavering support. Their partnership was a testament to the power of love and collaboration.
6. The Rum War: Cracking Down on Criminals
The thrill of your life.
Prohibition Era Crime. After World War I, Elizebeth found herself facing a new challenge: the rise of organized crime during Prohibition. As illegal liquor smuggling became a lucrative business, criminal gangs began using sophisticated codes and ciphers to protect their operations. Recognizing the threat, the Coast Guard turned to Elizebeth for help.
Fighting the Mob. Elizebeth's codebreaking skills proved invaluable in combating the rumrunners. She deciphered thousands of secret messages, providing the Coast Guard with critical intelligence about smuggling routes, ship locations, and gang activities. Her work led to the arrest of numerous criminals and the seizure of vast quantities of illegal liquor, significantly disrupting the operations of organized crime syndicates.
A Pioneer in Law Enforcement. Elizebeth's work during the Rum War established her as a pioneer in the field of law enforcement intelligence. Her ability to analyze complex data, identify patterns, and extract actionable information from seemingly random messages transformed the way law enforcement agencies approached criminal investigations. Her work was essential to national security, and her skills were highly sought after by various government agencies.
7. World War II: Unmasking Nazi Espionage
The woman all spies in U.S. fear.
A Growing Threat. As World War II loomed, Elizebeth's focus shifted from domestic crime to international espionage. With Nazi Germany posing a growing threat to global security, the United States needed to identify and neutralize enemy spies operating within its borders and in South America. Elizebeth's expertise in codebreaking made her the ideal person to lead this effort.
Tracking Nazi Spies. Elizebeth and her team worked tirelessly to decipher messages from Nazi spy networks, uncovering their plans to gather intelligence, sabotage American interests, and influence political events in South America. Her work helped to expose the extent of Nazi influence in the region and allowed the United States to take steps to counter their activities.
Cracking Enigma. One of Elizebeth's most significant achievements during World War II was her success in cracking the Enigma code used by Nazi spies. This breakthrough provided the United States with invaluable insights into German espionage operations and allowed them to disrupt enemy activities before they could cause significant damage. Her work was essential to national security, and her skills were highly sought after by various government agencies.
8. Post-War Legacy: Recognition and Remembrance
You never get sick of too much knowledge.
Unsung Hero. Despite her extraordinary contributions to national security, Elizebeth Smith Friedman remained largely unknown to the public for many years. Her work was shrouded in secrecy, and her achievements were often overshadowed by those of her husband. However, in recent years, her story has begun to emerge, and she is finally receiving the recognition she deserves.
Breaking the Silence. In the decades following World War II, Elizebeth continued to work in the field of cryptanalysis, but she was bound by oaths of secrecy that prevented her from discussing her wartime experiences. It was not until after her death that her story began to be told, thanks to the efforts of historians, biographers, and family members who sought to uncover the truth about her remarkable life.
A Lasting Impact. Elizebeth Smith Friedman's legacy as a pioneer in cryptanalysis and a champion of women in STEM fields continues to inspire generations. Her story serves as a reminder that true genius can often be found in unexpected places, and that perseverance and determination can overcome even the most daunting challenges. Her work laid the foundation for modern cryptanalysis techniques.
Last updated:
FAQ
What is The Woman All Spies Fear by Amy Butler Greenfield about?
- Biography of a codebreaker: The book is a biography of Elizebeth Smith Friedman, an American woman who pioneered codebreaking from World War I through World War II and beyond.
- Hidden contributions revealed: It uncovers her secret work in cryptology and counterintelligence, often overshadowed by government secrecy and male colleagues.
- Historical context: The narrative situates her work within major events like Prohibition, both World Wars, and the early Cold War, showing her impact on espionage and national security.
- Personal and professional struggles: The book also explores her partnership with her husband, William Friedman, and the challenges they faced due to secrecy, lack of recognition, and personal hardships.
Why should I read The Woman All Spies Fear by Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Uncovering a hidden heroine: The book brings to light the remarkable but largely unrecognized achievements of Elizebeth Friedman, inspiring readers interested in history, cryptology, or women’s contributions to intelligence.
- Insight into cryptology and espionage: It provides accessible explanations of complex codebreaking techniques and their crucial role in World War II intelligence.
- Humanizing history: The narrative delves into the personal lives, mental health struggles, and ethical dilemmas faced by the Friedmans, offering a nuanced portrait of intelligence work’s human cost.
- Relevance to today: The book highlights ongoing tensions between secrecy and democracy, resonating with contemporary debates about surveillance and government transparency.
Who was Elizebeth Smith Friedman and why is she significant in The Woman All Spies Fear by Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Pioneering female cryptologist: Elizebeth was one of America’s first professional female code breakers, starting her career during World War I and continuing through World War II.
- Breaking major spy networks: She played a crucial role in dismantling Nazi espionage in South America and fighting organized crime during Prohibition.
- Designing secure systems: Beyond breaking codes, she designed secure communication systems, including one-time pad ciphers for the OSS.
- Legacy and recognition: Despite her achievements, she was often denied credit due to secrecy and institutional biases, but her legacy is now honored with awards and inclusion in the NSA Cryptologic Hall of Honor.
How did Elizebeth Smith Friedman start her codebreaking career according to Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Riverbank Library beginnings: Elizebeth’s career began at the Riverbank estate in Illinois, where she was hired to work on a project decoding supposed secret messages in Shakespeare’s works.
- Meeting William Friedman: At Riverbank, she met William Friedman, and together they doubted the Shakespeare cipher theory, forming a powerful codebreaking team.
- Self-taught cryptanalyst: They trained themselves and others, developing new methods and breaking complex ciphers, which laid the foundation for their future work.
- Transition to government work: Frustrated with Riverbank, they secretly accepted government jobs in Washington, DC, marking the start of their official careers in military cryptanalysis.
What are the key codebreaking concepts explained in The Woman All Spies Fear by Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Code vs. cipher: The book clarifies that a code replaces entire words or phrases, while a cipher works at the letter level, substituting or rearranging letters.
- Bacon’s cipher and binary: It explains Bacon’s biliteral cipher, which uses two elements to encode messages, linking historical cryptography to modern computing.
- Keyword and transposition ciphers: The book describes keyword ciphers (using a keyword to scramble the alphabet) and transposition ciphers (rearranging letters), illustrating the complexity of encryption methods Elizebeth faced.
- Cryptanalyst’s toolkit: Elizebeth’s favorite term was “cryptanalyst,” emphasizing the analytical and intuitive skills needed to break these encryptions.
How did Elizebeth Smith Friedman contribute to fighting organized crime during Prohibition as described in The Woman All Spies Fear?
- Codebreaking for law enforcement: Elizebeth was recruited by the Coast Guard to break the complex codes and ciphers used by rumrunners and gangsters during the Rum War.
- Mapping criminal networks: She decrypted thousands of intercepted messages, exposing smuggling operations and key players, which was crucial in court cases and convictions.
- Facing danger and recognition: Despite her success, she faced threats from gangsters and was often underestimated, with credit sometimes given to others.
- Impact on crime: Her work helped reduce illegal liquor imports by an estimated 60%, making her vital in law enforcement’s fight against organized crime.
What challenges did Elizebeth Smith Friedman face as a woman in the male-dominated field of cryptography, according to Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Gender bias and pay disparity: Elizebeth often earned less than her male colleagues and was sometimes hired as an assistant rather than an equal.
- Lack of public recognition: Her contributions were frequently overshadowed by her husband’s or attributed to others, with official records often mentioning her only as “Mrs. William F. Friedman.”
- Balancing family and career: She juggled motherhood, health issues, and a demanding career, often working from home with the help of housekeepers and nurses.
- Persistence and leadership: Despite these challenges, she persisted and eventually led her own codebreaking unit, paving the way for future women in intelligence.
How did Elizebeth and William Friedman’s partnership influence American codebreaking as detailed in The Woman All Spies Fear?
- Complementary skills: William excelled in analytical, methodical codebreaking, while Elizebeth had exceptional intuition and pattern recognition, making their teamwork “almost invincible.”
- Joint innovations: They developed new techniques, training programs, and working practices that became standard in American cryptanalysis.
- Shared struggles and successes: They supported each other through personal and professional hardships, including health issues and family life.
- Historic collaboration: Their partnership was both a love story and a groundbreaking collaboration in intelligence history.
How did Elizebeth Smith Friedman and her team break the Japanese Purple cipher machine, according to Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Complexity of Purple: The Japanese Purple cipher machine used stepping switches and had daily-changing settings, making it extremely difficult to crack.
- Team effort and breakthrough: After a year of struggle, Genevieve Grotjan, a young mathematician on the team, discovered a key pattern that enabled them to build a working replica of Purple without ever seeing the machine.
- Impact of breaking Purple: The decrypted messages, code-named Magic, provided critical intelligence on Japanese and Axis plans, aiding Allied operations including D-Day.
- Psychological toll: The intense pressure of the Purple project contributed to William’s mental breakdown, highlighting the human cost behind cryptologic triumphs.
What role did Elizebeth Smith Friedman play in breaking Nazi spy networks in South America during World War II, as described in The Woman All Spies Fear?
- Intercepting and decrypting messages: Elizebeth’s unit intercepted and decrypted messages from Nazi spy rings operating in South America, including those linked to the notorious spy Sargo.
- Use of code names and cribs: The spies used code names that repeated frequently, serving as “cribs” or known plaintexts that helped Elizebeth’s team break their ciphers.
- Counterintelligence efforts: By reading these messages, her team uncovered plans for fascist uprisings, sabotage, and espionage, enabling Allied forces to disrupt Nazi operations.
- Challenges with the FBI: The FBI’s premature arrests in Brazil compromised the spy networks and frustrated Elizebeth’s efforts by alerting the Nazis.
How did Elizebeth Smith Friedman and her team approach breaking the Nazi Enigma machine ciphers, according to Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Enigma’s complexity: The Enigma machine used rotors and a plugboard, creating about 159 quintillion possible settings, making brute-force attacks impossible.
- Collaboration with British code breakers: Elizebeth worked with British experts who had developed bombes, but her team also used pencil, paper, and statistical methods to break messages.
- Solving in depth method: By collecting multiple messages sent with the same Enigma settings, her team lined them up to detect patterns and exploited operator mistakes.
- Success and secrecy: Her team broke into the Abwehr Enigma used by Nazi spies in South America, providing vital intelligence while maintaining strict secrecy.
What is the legacy of Elizebeth Smith Friedman as presented in The Woman All Spies Fear by Amy Butler Greenfield?
- Trailblazer for women in intelligence: Elizebeth opened doors for thousands of women who became code breakers during World War II and beyond.
- Recognition and honors: She was posthumously inducted into the NSA Cryptologic Hall of Honor, had a federal intelligence award named after her, and is now celebrated as a role model for courage and intellect.
- Preservation of history: Through meticulous cataloging and coded notes, she ensured the truth about her and William’s work could eventually be uncovered by historians.
- A complex, honest story: Elizebeth wanted her story told with honesty, including her struggles and the challenges of secrecy, making her legacy both inspiring and human.
Review Summary
The Woman All Spies Fear receives high praise for its engaging portrayal of Elizebeth Smith Friedman, a pioneering codebreaker. Readers appreciate the book's accessible style, historical depth, and insights into Friedman's personal life and professional challenges. Many are surprised to learn about her significant contributions, which were often overshadowed or uncredited. The book is lauded for its educational value, inspiring narrative, and ability to shed light on an overlooked historical figure. Some readers note its appeal to both young adults and adults interested in history, espionage, and women in STEM.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
