Plot Summary
Cottage, Charity, and Confession
They met as teenagers at a commercial shoot, where mutual attraction led to the first of many secret hookups. Over a decade later, both are twenty-nine — Shane1 captains the Montreal Voyageurs, Ilya2 leads the Ottawa Centaurs — and each summer they disappear to Shane's lake house to live the life they can't have the rest of the year.
This July they confess their relationship to their shared agent, Farah,18 who takes the news in stride. Then they launch their second charity camp honoring Ilya's mother, Irina, who died by suicide when he was twelve. The coaching staff includes Shane's1 teammate Hayden Pike,3 one of few who knows their secret, and retired player Ryan Price,10 who caught them kissing the year before.
Four Men at a Pizza Bar
Shane1 nervously invites Ryan10 and his boyfriend Fabian11 — an openly queer musician radiating effortless sensuality — to dinner at a gay bar in Montreal. It's their first double date, the first time they've sat across from another queer couple as a couple themselves. Fabian11 asks pointed, gentle questions: why the secrecy? How long have they been together?
The answers — over ten years, because the hockey world isn't ready — sound thinner spoken aloud than they do inside Shane's1 head. Later, they attend Fabian's11 concert. The room thrums with desire and music, and Shane,1 against every rule they've set, places his hand on the small of Ilya's2 back. Ilya's2 whole body relaxes into the touch. Shane1 keeps his hand there for the rest of the show.
Ottawa Loses, Ilya Fades
The NHL season begins and geography reasserts its cruelty. Shane's1 Montreal dominates; Ilya's2 Ottawa keeps losing. But the losses aren't the worst of it. Ilya2 withdraws from his teammates, declining invitations to bars and outings. He feels bone-deep exhaustion that hockey alone can't explain. He dreams repeatedly of his dead mother — always the same dream, her in a hammock, Shane1 never arriving in time.
One night after a loss, unable to sleep and desperate for connection, Ilya2 texts Shane1 after one in the morning asking if he's awake. Shane1 finds the message the next morning and assumes Ilya2 was just being horny. He misses the distress signal entirely, and the gulf between them widens without either man realizing it.
The Stolen Goal
Shane1 has been practicing in secret for months. During a nationally televised game against Boston, he executes Ilya's2 signature deke — a fake backhand, lightning forehand — and winks directly at the camera.
Ilya,2 watching from Shane's parents'12 couch in Ottawa, erupts off the cushions in outrage and admiration. He calls Shane1 afterward, furious and aroused, and they fall into a competitive, filthy phone-sex session that involves Shane1 wearing his glasses on command and Ilya2 coming so hard he manages a second orgasm.
It's funny and achingly intimate, the way they convert distance into electricity. But when the call ends, Ilya2 is alone again, and the apartment feels enormous. Ten days until they see each other. The number sounds like a prison sentence.
The Gladiator Cries Alone
For Halloween, Ilya2 hosts a lavish party for his teammates — decorations, costumes, a packed dance floor. He's dressed as a gladiator, all breastplate and bare arms. But midway through, he slips upstairs to his bedroom, overwhelmed by loneliness.
Everyone downstairs is dancing with a partner. Ilya2 is the only one alone. After midnight, when the guests have left, Shane1 appears at his door, having driven from Montreal on impulse. The sex is desperate and cathartic — Shane1 arrived already wearing a plug, unwilling to waste a second.
But the next morning, after Shane1 drives away, Ilya2 collapses against his front door and weeps until he can't stand. When the tears finally stop, he admits what he's been resisting for months: he needs professional help.
Words in Russian
Ilya2 finds Dr. Galina Molchalina,9 Ottawa's only Russian-speaking psychologist. In their first session, he talks for forty straight minutes about his mother — her hidden depression, her death when he was twelve, his father's cold insistence it had been an accidental overdose.
He describes finding her body, her hand dangling over the side of the bed. Tears fall without him noticing until Galina9 hands him tissues. In later sessions, he reveals his bisexuality, his secret relationship with Shane,1 and the terrifying thought that he might be following his mother's trajectory.
He doesn't tell Shane1 about the therapy. The relief of speaking his native language about his darkest thoughts is enormous, but so is the guilt of keeping yet another secret from the person closest to him.
Crowell's Veiled Threat
The NHL commissioner8 summons Shane1 to his Manhattan office and delivers a message wrapped in compliments. He praises Shane's1 charity work, then pivots: he's heard rumors about Shane's1 sexuality, and he'd appreciate if they stayed rumors. He cites the league's Pride initiatives as proof of inclusion, but his underlying message is unmistakable — activism is a distraction, and one openly gay star is plenty.
Shane1 leaves feeling like he's been given a warning disguised as a handshake. When he tells Ilya,2 Ilya2 is furious — not just at Crowell,8 but at the way Shane1 seems resigned to accept the leash. The commissioner8 has drawn a line, and both men now know exactly where the most powerful person in their sport stands on their existence.
Troy Gets What Ilya Can't
Toronto trades Troy Barrett5 to Ottawa after Troy5 publicly confronted a former teammate accused of sexual assault. Ilya2 initially dislikes Troy,5 but bonds with him over shared wounds — difficult fathers, secret identities. During a late-night walk after visiting a gay bar together, Troy5 comes out to Ilya2 as gay, and Ilya,2 freed by being trusted, reveals he's bisexual.
When Ilya2 tells Shane,1 the conversation curdles. Shane1 is jealous and dismissive, and Ilya2 snaps: Shane1 has parents, Hayden,3 and others who know their secret, while Ilya2 has almost nobody. The structural imbalance of their hidden life — Shane's1 cushioned by community, Ilya's2 hollowed by isolation — becomes impossible for either man to ignore any longer.
I Already Chose You
On Boxing Day, Ilya2 asks Shane1 to accompany him to a teammate's party. Shane1 refuses — too risky, too weird. The rejection ignites something that's been smoldering for months. They fight with escalating fury: Ilya2 accuses Shane1 of caring more about other people's opinions than about him; Shane1 demands to know if Ilya2 would choose him over hockey.
Ilya2 backs Shane1 against a wall, trembling with rage, and says quietly that he already made that choice — years ago, when he left Boston for Ottawa to be closer to Shane.1 He tells Shane1 to leave. Shane1 drives home in a daze, calls his mother7 in tears, and scrolls through Ilya's2 Instagram to discover it's a coded love letter to their relationship. Every post, for years.
Messages from a Falling Plane
In January, Ottawa's charter plane suffers engine failure and catches fire mid-flight. As the cabin fills with screaming, Ilya2 opens Instagram and begins typing messages to Shane,1 who is mid-game and unreachable. He writes that Shane1 is the best thing in his life.
That he loves him, maybe from the very first time they met. That whatever happens, his soul will stay with Shane.1 He presses his mother's crucifix against his chest and prays for more time. The plane makes a harrowing emergency landing — everyone survives.
Shane1 reads the messages afterward and falls apart in his hotel room, stunned by how close he came to losing everything without ever having claimed it. The hiding has cost them too much. They can't afford to waste any more time.
A Thousand Electric Candles
Shane1 fills Ilya's2 living room with battery-powered candles — dozens of them, on every surface — and drops to one knee. He tells Ilya2 he's done waiting, done hiding, done choosing safety over love. He asks Ilya Grigoryevich Rozanov2 to marry him.
Ilya,2 stunned silent long enough to terrify Shane,1 says yes. The ring doesn't quite fit his finger, so Ilya threads it onto the gold chain around his neck, where it settles against his mother's crucifix. They agree to come out publicly and marry the following summer — not in ten years when they're retired, but now.
They make love on the living room rug amid the glow of fake candlelight, foreheads pressed together, and for the first time in eleven years, their future feels like something they're running toward.
The Standing Ovation
In February, Troy Barrett5 publicly comes out as gay before Ottawa's Pride Night game against his former team. The arena gives him a sustained standing ovation. Ilya2 cheers with genuine pride — he helped Troy5 find this courage, watched him fall in love with Harris,6 Ottawa's social media manager, and supported every step. But privately, Ilya2 spirals with jealousy.
Troy5 gets to kiss his boyfriend in the locker room. Troy5 gets to stop lying. Ilya2 drives to Shane's1 house that night, needing to be held more than he needs to explain why. His therapist later observes that the joy and jealousy aren't contradictory — they're two faces of the same longing. The closet hasn't gotten smaller; it just feels that way now.
The Mirror in Hayden's Video
Hayden Pike,3 Shane's1 well-meaning best friend, records a short birthday greeting for a fan on a paid video platform called FanMail. He films it in his trophy room, which has a large mirror reflecting the side window.
In that mirror, perfectly framed, Shane1 and Ilya2 are kissing passionately in the yard — completely unaware. The fan posts the video on Twitter. Within hours, it's everywhere. Eleven years of careful secrecy, undone by a hundred-dollar birthday message to someone named Brad. Shane1 spirals; Ilya2 laughs until he can't breathe.
They call their agent,18 who begins drafting a statement. Both players are benched by Commissioner Crowell's8 order. Shane1 faces a hostile locker room in Montreal, where only Hayden3 defends him. His teammates' silence cuts worse than their anger.
I Choose Him
Crowell8 flies to Montreal with a prepared statement claiming the kiss was a prank on Hayden.3 It's a clean exit — most fans would want to believe it. Shane1 reads the statement carefully, then looks Crowell8 in the eye and tells him it isn't true. They're together.
They're getting married this summer. Crowell8 threatens that their careers are over. Shane1 stands, says he chooses Ilya,2 and walks out — having secretly recorded the entire meeting on his phone. In the elevator, Ilya2 pins Shane1 against the mirrored wall and kisses him with everything he has.
They post their own statement on Instagram with four photos and their agent's18 carefully worded text. The responses aren't all positive, but Shane1 and Ilya2 walk down a Montreal street holding hands, heads high, and don't look back.
Game Seven's Overtime Stumble
The playoffs pit Montreal against Ottawa in the first round, and the series reaches Game Seven in Montreal. In overtime, Shane1 chases Ilya2 on a breakaway but trips and falls. Ilya2 buries the puck, and Ottawa eliminates the defending champions. Some Montreal teammates and media pundits accuse Shane1 of falling on purpose to hand his fiancé the victory.
The suspicion cuts deeper than the loss itself — these men watched Shane1 carry them to three championships. He decides he's finished with Montreal, and when free agency opens, he signs with Ottawa. In July, they marry in their backyard, surrounded by teammates, family, and every person who kept their secret or welcomed their truth. The long game is finally over.
Epilogue
In October, Shane1 and Ilya2 stand side by side at Ottawa's home opener, wearing matching Centaurs jerseys for the first time. The arena is sold out — a transformation from the half-empty building Ilya2 once knew. Shane,1 without a captain's C on his chest for the first time in his career, takes his place in the lineup between rookies and veterans.
Ilya,2 still captain, is the last name announced. They grin at each other across center ice while their teammate Bood17 declares it's time to finally hang a banner from these rafters. Ilya2 has never been so sure of anything. His husband,1 his teammate, his former rival smiles back — and the season begins.
Analysis
The Long Game interrogates a specific modern cruelty: being allowed to exist but not to be witnessed. Shane1 and Ilya2 aren't facing legal persecution — they're fighting something more insidious, a culture that will tolerate their existence only if they make it invisible. Commissioner Crowell8 never says 'you can't be gay'; he says 'keep it comfortable.' The distinction is the novel's sharpest insight into how institutional homophobia operates in spaces that claim to have evolved.
Reid constructs a romance in which the central obstacle isn't external prohibition but internalized complicity. Shane1 has organized his psychology around discipline and control — his diet, his routine, his secret — and mistakes rigidity for safety. Ilya2 has restructured his entire life around proximity to Shane,1 abandoning Boston, selling his car collection, isolating from old friends, while insisting these sacrifices don't count. Both men participate in their own diminishment, and the novel is honest that love alone doesn't fix it.
The depression subplot resists easy resolution. Ilya's2 mental health doesn't improve because he loves harder or wins more games. Therapy is slow, medication is discussed as a real possibility, and Galina9 explicitly warns that hiding feelings from Shane1 will build a wall between them. The novel refuses the romantic notion that a partner can substitute for professional help.
Most crucially, The Long Game argues that the cost of hiding isn't just emotional — it's structural. Ilya2 has no support network, no one to call at two in the morning, no one at his own wedding besides Shane's1 people. The imbalance isn't metaphor; it's a material consequence of one partner bearing more of the secret's weight. Coming out, Reid suggests, isn't a single brave moment but a redistribution of burden — and the people who love you deserve to carry some of it.
Review Summary
The Long Game receives overwhelmingly positive reviews (4.52/5 stars), praised as an emotional sequel to Heated Rivalry. Readers celebrate the continuation of Shane and Ilya's romance, highlighting excellent mental health representation, humor, chemistry, and domestic moments. Ilya particularly captivates fans with his vulnerability and devotion. Some readers express frustration with Shane's self-absorption and his team's homophobic response to their forced outing. Reviewers appreciated the authentic portrayal of depression and the characters' deep love, though a few found the plot repetitive or were disappointed by narrative choices around the outing storyline. Most found it a satisfying, tear-jerking conclusion.
People Also Read
Characters
Shane Hollander
Montreal's meticulous captainShane Hollander is the captain of the Montreal Voyageurs, a three-time Stanley Cup champion who has built his identity around discipline, excellence, and control. Gay and deeply closeted for most of his career, Shane operates with a meticulous anxiety that extends from his strict performance diet to his paranoid management of his secret relationship. He loves Ilya2 with an intensity that frightens him, but his instinct is always to protect what they have by keeping it invisible. His closest friendships—with Hayden Pike3 and J.J. Boiziau4—are constrained by what he can't reveal. Psychologically, Shane confuses discipline with safety: he believes that if he controls enough variables, nothing can go wrong. The story tests whether he can surrender that control in the arena that matters most.
Ilya Rozanov
Ottawa's magnetic, wounded captainIlya Rozanov is the captain of the Ottawa Centaurs, a dazzling forward who traded a contender in Boston for a struggling franchise—all to be closer to Shane1. Bisexual and charismatic, Ilya projects confidence that conceals a deepening depression rooted in childhood trauma: his mother's suicide when he was twelve, his father's cruelty, and the loneliness of hiding his truest self. He craves connection desperately but pushes people away when they approach his pain. His humor—irreverent, filthy, disarming—is both genuine and defensive. Where Shane1 overcontrols, Ilya under-communicates, stuffing grief into silence until it detonates. His journey centers on accepting that vulnerability isn't weakness, and that the people who love him can carry some of his darkness.
Hayden Pike
Shane's loyal, guileless best friendShane's1 best friend and Montreal teammate, a lovable, slightly dim family man with four young children and irrepressible loyalty. Hayden was one of the first to learn about Shane1 and Ilya2 and has kept their secret faithfully for years. His warmth and protectiveness make him Shane's1 emotional anchor on the team, and his willingness to defend Shane1 in hostile rooms reveals the depth of their bond. His well-meaning impulsiveness occasionally creates complications.
J.J. Boiziau
Shane's proud alternate captainShane's1 alternate captain in Montreal, a confident Quebecois-Haitian defenseman who is supportive of Shane's1 sexuality but wounded by being excluded from the bigger truth. J.J. tries to set Shane1 up on dates, believing his friend nurses an unrequited crush on Ilya2. His pride and protectiveness define a friendship that Shane1 values deeply but cannot fully trust with the most dangerous secret of his life.
Troy Barrett
Ilya's unlikely new friendA talented forward traded to Ottawa after confronting a former teammate's sexual misconduct. Initially abrasive, Troy hides deep vulnerability behind aggression and bravado. His relationship with his domineering father mirrors Ilya's2 own paternal wounds, creating an unexpected bond between the two men. Troy's journey toward self-acceptance runs parallel to Ilya's2, and their growing friendship gives Ilya2 something he desperately needs: someone on his team who understands.
Harris Drover
Ottawa's openly gay heartOttawa's openly gay social media manager, warm and quick-witted, beloved by the entire team. Harris's comfort in his own skin and generous spirit make him a gravitational center for teammates navigating their own identities. He manages the team puppy, Chiron, with infectious enthusiasm, and his close-knit family farm provides refuge for those lucky enough to visit. His authenticity represents the freedom Ilya2 craves but doesn't yet possess.
Yuna Hollander
Shane's fierce, practical motherShane's1 mother, a fierce and practical Korean-Canadian woman who manages their charity camps with relentless efficiency. She accepts Ilya2 into the family with an ease that sometimes startles him, calling him her favorite son to tease Shane1. Her directness—often echoing Ilya's2 own bluntness—provides Shane1 with grounding perspective during his worst spirals. She and Ilya2 are natural allies in the ongoing project of keeping Shane1 from self-destructing.
Roger Crowell
The league's smiling antagonistThe NHL commissioner, a physically imposing former football player who projects warmth while delivering threats. Crowell represents institutional homophobia dressed in corporate language—praising diversity while pressuring queer players to remain invisible. His meetings with Shane1 reveal a man who values order and brand management over human dignity. He wields his power through implication rather than direct prohibition, making him harder to fight and more dangerous to defy.
Galina Molchalina
Ilya's Russian-speaking therapistIlya's2 therapist in Ottawa, calm and perceptive, who becomes the first person to hear the full truth of his life in his native language. Galina guides Ilya2 through processing his mother's death, naming his depression, and recognizing the structural imbalance in his relationship with Shane1. Her steady, nonjudgmental presence represents the healing that years of secrecy have prevented.
Ryan Price
Shy retired player, accidental confidantA retired NHL defenseman, enormous and painfully shy, who accidentally discovered Shane1 and Ilya's2 relationship by walking in on them kissing at the charity camp. Gay himself and in a relationship with musician Fabian Salah11, Ryan becomes an unlikely trusted friend. His anxiety mirrors Shane's1, and his partnership with Fabian11 models the openness that Shane1 and Ilya2 hunger for.
Fabian Salah
Ryan's magnetic musician boyfriendRyan Price's10 boyfriend, a striking queer musician whose unapologetic sensuality challenges Shane's1 assumptions about visibility. His probing questions during a double date force both men to examine the cost of their secrecy.
David Hollander
Shane's quiet, kind fatherShane's1 father, who bonds deeply with Ilya2 over jigsaw puzzles, Yahtzee, and homemade dinners. His steady, understated warmth provides Ilya2 with the paternal care he never received.
Wyatt Hayes
Ottawa's cheerful, nerdy goalieOttawa's starting goalie, perpetually optimistic despite years on a losing team. His sharp observational skills and comic-book enthusiasm make him a steadying, lovable presence in the locker room.
Rose
Shane's movie-star ex and confidanteShane's1 famous ex-girlfriend, a movie star who remains one of his closest friends. She advises Shane1 to prepare a backup plan for being outed and helps him explore his personal style.
Luca Haas
Ottawa's starstruck Swiss rookieOttawa's shy rookie from Switzerland who idolized Ilya2 growing up. His artistic talent and earnest admiration draw out Ilya's2 gentler side as a mentor and captain.
Coach Wiebe
Ottawa's progressive young coachOttawa's first-year head coach, whose empathy, fairness, and genuine kindness contrast sharply with Montreal's old-school coaching staff. His warmth helps transform a perennial loser into a team worth believing in.
Zane Boodram
Ottawa's ebullient team cheerleaderIlya's2 left-wing linemate, a tattooed Trinidadian-Canadian who serves as Ottawa's unofficial social director. His infectious energy and loyalty keep the locker room positive through losing streaks.
Farah Jalali
Shane and Ilya's strategic agentShane1 and Ilya's2 shared agent, composed and strategic. The first professional they tell about their relationship, she later helps them control the narrative when their secret is exposed.
Scott Hunter
The NHL's openly gay starThe league's most prominent openly gay player and captain of the New York Admirals. He seeks out Shane1 and Ilya2 to offer solidarity and recruit them into a coalition fighting toxic hockey culture.
Plot Devices
Hayden's FanMail Video
Accidental outing mechanismHayden Pike3 records birthday greeting videos for fans on a paid website called FanMail. In one video filmed in his trophy room, a large mirror reflects the view through a window where Shane1 and Ilya2 are kissing passionately outside. Hayden3 doesn't notice before sending it to the fan, who posts it on Twitter. This single piece of content destroys eleven years of careful secrecy overnight, serving as the catalyst for the story's climactic sequence. The device is devastating in its banality—not a tabloid photographer or a vengeful ex, but a mirror, a window, and a well-meaning friend's hobby. It transforms the central question from 'will they be discovered?' to 'what happens now that everyone knows?'
The Ring on the Crucifix Chain
Symbol of grief joined to hopeWhen Shane1 proposes, the engagement ring doesn't quite fit Ilya's2 finger. Rather than resize it, Ilya2 threads the ring onto the gold chain he always wears—the one holding his dead mother Irina's crucifix pendant. The ring and crucifix resting side by side against Ilya's2 chest becomes a private talisman: his mother's faith alongside his living love, his grief beside his joy. Hidden under his jersey during games, pressed against his skin, the chain carries the weight of everything Ilya2 has lost and everything he stands to gain. Its eventual visibility to others marks how far Ilya2 has traveled from hiding.
The Irina Foundation
Public cover and genuine missionShane1 and Ilya's2 joint mental health charity, named after Ilya's2 mother, funds organizations and runs summer hockey camps for kids. The foundation is their only public collaboration, providing a plausible explanation for their closeness while genuinely honoring Irina's memory. The camps bring together a cast of allies—Ryan Price10, Max Riley, Hayden Pike3—who form a protective community around the couple. The foundation also embodies the paradox at the heart of their lives: they advocate publicly for mental health awareness while Ilya2 privately battles the same illness that killed his mother. It functions as both a shield for their secret and a mirror reflecting what they haven't yet confronted.
Ilya's Recurring Dream
Grief externalized as nightmareThroughout the story, Ilya2 dreams of his dead mother lying in the hammock behind Shane's cottage. She's alive, smiling, and Ilya2 calls for Shane1 to come meet her. Shane1 never arrives in time. The dream recurs across the novel's timeline, serving as a barometer of Ilya's2 emotional state—each repetition more desperate, more fragile. It externalizes two of his deepest fears: that the people he loves will vanish before he can hold them, and that the two halves of his life—his grief and his love—can never occupy the same space. When he begins therapy, this dream is one of the first things he discusses with Galina9.
The Cottage by the Lake
Sanctuary and beautiful prisonShane's1 lakeside cottage, roughly two hours from Ottawa, serves as the couple's private universe. It's where they spend every summer, where Ilya2 got a loon tattoo to mark the place, where Shane1 keeps their framed photos. The cottage represents the life they can only live in fragments—unhurried mornings, shared cooking, laughter without surveillance. It functions as both paradise and prison: the only place they can be fully themselves, and a constant reminder that such freedom requires isolation. Their dream of living openly is, in essence, the dream of making everywhere feel like the cottage—and the story charts whether they'll have the courage to try.