Plot Summary
Codes and Consequences
Edda St. James, just eighteen, is a telephone operator for the American Expeditionary Forces during World War I, stationed on the French front. Her days are governed by ever-changing codes, meant to keep military communications safe from enemy ears. The job is both routine and perilous, requiring her to memorize code names and connect calls under the threat of bombs and espionage. Edda's sense of self is shaped by the seriousness of her work and the constant pressure to perform flawlessly. The codes are not just a professional necessity—they become a metaphor for the secrets and traumas she carries, and for the ways in which her life, and the lives of those around her, can be changed or destroyed in a matter of seconds.
The Call at Dawn
After a grueling night shift in Washington, Edda receives a cryptic phone call just before dawn. The voice on the other end pleads for help, insists she must "tell the truth before it's too late," and utters the word "Brightwood." The call is unsettling, both for its urgency and for the way it seems to pierce through Edda's carefully constructed defenses. She is left shaken, unable to dismiss the sense that the call is meant specifically for her, and haunted by the possibility that her past in France is catching up with her. The call becomes the catalyst for Edda's journey into her own memories and guilt, and for the unraveling of the secrets she has tried so hard to bury.
Across the Ocean
Seven months earlier, Edda arrives in France, alone and terrified, to join the ranks of the "Hello Girls"—American women sent to operate military switchboards near the front. She is greeted by Luc, a charming and supportive liaison, who encourages her and helps her believe she can succeed. Edda's first days are a blur of fear, camaraderie, and adaptation to the harsh realities of war. She bonds with her fellow operators, especially Mae, and learns to navigate the dangers and demands of her new role. The experience is transformative, forcing Edda to grow up quickly and to confront the limits of her own courage and competence.
Ghosts of the Front
Back in Washington, Edda struggles to adjust to civilian life. She is plagued by insomnia, nightmares, and a sense of alienation from those around her. Her friendship with Theo, a fellow boarder, is both a comfort and a source of tension—he is the only person who seems to understand her, but she cannot bring herself to share the full truth of her experiences. The mysterious call and the word "Brightwood" become a focal point for her anxiety, as she begins to suspect that someone knows what happened in France, and that her role in a tragic military blunder may not be as secret as she hoped.
Armistice and Aftermath
News of the armistice brings celebration to Washington, but for Edda, the end of the war is bittersweet. While the city erupts in joy, she is consumed by dread—if the soldiers are coming home, so too are the memories and consequences of what happened overseas. Edda's guilt over a failed connection that may have cost dozens of lives becomes unbearable. She fears exposure and judgment, and the sense that she is being watched or followed intensifies. The war may be over, but her personal battle is just beginning.
The Guilt That Follows
Edda's guilt is compounded by the realization that the mysterious calls are not random. She and Theo begin to investigate, compiling a list of the soldiers lost in the incident she believes she caused. Their search leads them to the families of the dead, and to the possibility that one of them is seeking retribution or closure. Edda is forced to confront the reality that her actions—or inactions—had real, devastating consequences, and that the line between victim and perpetrator is not always clear.
Shadows in the City
As Edda and Theo dig deeper, the sense of threat grows. Edda is followed through the city, and a rock is thrown at her in the night. She becomes increasingly paranoid, unsure whom to trust. The investigation leads them to the Dannenberg family, whose son was among the dead, and to a series of painful encounters with grief-stricken parents and siblings. Each visit is a reminder of the human cost of war, and of the impossibility of making amends for the past.
Searching for Answers
Edda and Theo's search takes them from Washington to Baltimore, as they try to match names, addresses, and telephone numbers to the families of the lost soldiers. They pore over directories and pension records, looking for clues. Along the way, Edda is forced to revisit her own memories of France, and to reckon with the ways in which trauma has shaped her life. The investigation is both a quest for truth and a desperate attempt to find some measure of peace.
The List of the Lost
The list of the dead becomes a litany of loss, each name representing a life cut short and a family left behind. Edda imagines the stories of the boys she never knew, and the futures they will never have. The process of visiting their families is harrowing, but also cathartic—each encounter is a step toward understanding the scope of her own guilt and the limits of her responsibility. The search is as much about Edda's need for forgiveness as it is about solving the mystery of the calls.
Letters and Lies
Edda discovers that Theo has secrets of his own—he was not, as he claimed, kept from the war by a hunting accident, but by a self-inflicted wound meant to avoid combat. Their relationship is tested by revelations and misunderstandings, as both struggle with shame and the desire to be seen and understood. Letters, both real and forged, play a crucial role in the unfolding drama, serving as both evidence and metaphor for the ways in which people hide from the truth.
Confronting the Past
Edda's investigation leads her to confront the Dannenberg family, and specifically Mr. Dannenberg, whose grief and anger have driven him to seek answers and justice. The confrontation is tense and emotionally charged, forcing both Edda and Mr. Dannenberg to articulate their pain and their need for closure. The encounter is not the resolution Edda hoped for, but it is a necessary step in her journey toward acceptance and healing.
The Truth in the Wires
The final pieces of the puzzle fall into place when Edda realizes that the calls were not about the military blunder, but about something even more personal and painful—a sexual assault by Luc, her mentor in France, who also preyed on other women. The word "Brightwood" was a code, a nickname, a thread connecting the victims. Edda learns that the calls were meant to prompt her to speak out, to break the silence that allowed Luc's abuse to continue. The revelation is both devastating and liberating, forcing Edda to confront the full truth of her experience.
The Weight of Silence
Edda grapples with the consequences of her silence, and with the knowledge that others suffered as she did. She is haunted by the suicide of a fellow operator, Louisa, and by the realization that justice is often elusive. The burden of unspoken trauma is heavy, but Edda begins to see that healing is possible—not through forgetting, but through acknowledgment and connection with others who understand.
Unfinished Conversations
Edda's journey is marked by conversations that are interrupted, incomplete, or impossible. She learns that closure is not always attainable, and that some wounds never fully heal. Yet, through her efforts to reach out to the families of the lost, and to share her own story, she finds a measure of peace. The act of telling the truth, however painful, becomes a form of resistance and survival.
The Dance and the Damage
Edda's memories of France are dominated by the assault she suffered at the hands of Luc, and by the betrayal of trust that followed. The experience leaves her scarred, both physically and emotionally, and shapes her relationships and sense of self. The dance that began as a celebration becomes a metaphor for violation, and for the ways in which power can be abused. Edda's struggle to process and articulate her trauma is central to her journey.
The Final Call
In the aftermath of the revelations, Edda must decide how to live with what she knows. She chooses to reach out to the families of the lost, to tell the truth about what happened, and to honor the memory of those who cannot speak for themselves. Her relationship with Theo remains complicated, marked by both affection and distance, but she is no longer defined by her guilt or her silence. The final call is not one of accusation, but of connection and hope.
Endings and Beginnings
The story ends not with a neat resolution, but with the recognition that life is a series of pauses and continuations. Edda attends a funeral, cleans her room, and prepares for a new day. She is changed by her experiences, but not destroyed. The grief she carries does not diminish, but life grows bigger around it. The act of telling the truth, of reaching out, and of choosing to keep living becomes her way forward. The codes may change, but the need for connection and understanding endures.
Characters
Edda St. James
Edda is the heart of the novel—a young woman marked by her service as a "Hello Girl" on the French front and by the traumas she endures there. Intelligent, sensitive, and deeply conscientious, she is driven by a need to atone for a mistake she believes cost lives, and by the unspoken pain of sexual assault. Edda's relationships are shaped by her guilt and her struggle to trust, especially with Theo, her closest friend and would-be confidant. Her psychological journey is one of moving from self-blame and silence to acceptance and the courage to speak out. Edda's development is a testament to resilience, and her story is a nuanced exploration of the costs of war, the complexity of trauma, and the possibility of healing.
Theo Graybill
Theo is Edda's neighbor and reluctant confidant, a young man whose easy humor masks deep wounds. He did not serve in the war as expected, having deliberately injured himself to avoid combat—a secret that fills him with shame. Theo's relationship with Edda is marked by both genuine care and the limitations of his own understanding. He is supportive, resourceful, and persistent, but also struggles with his own guilt and the fear of being truly seen. Theo's arc is one of self-revelation and the painful recognition that some wounds cannot be fixed by love alone.
Luc L'Enfant
Luc is the French liaison who welcomes Edda to France and becomes her mentor, teacher, and ultimately, her abuser. He is charming, intelligent, and seemingly supportive, but his true nature is revealed in his exploitation of power and trust. Luc's actions are the catalyst for much of Edda's trauma, and his death leaves her with unresolved questions and a sense of unfinished business. He embodies the dangers of unchecked authority and the ways in which systems can fail to protect the vulnerable.
Miss Genovese
Miss Genovese is Edda's supervisor at the Washington switchboard, a figure of authority who enforces rules and discipline. Beneath her stern exterior, she is deeply affected by the suffering of her colleagues, especially Louisa, and is driven by a desire for justice. Her own sense of guilt and helplessness leads her to orchestrate the mysterious calls, hoping to prompt Edda to speak out. Miss Genovese's character is a study in the complexities of responsibility, complicity, and the limits of institutional power.
Mae
Mae is Edda's roommate and fellow operator in France, admired for her skill and composure. She, too, is a victim of Luc's predation, and her presence is both a source of comfort and a reminder of shared trauma. Mae's ability to carry on, to support Edda, and to eventually reach out after the war highlights the importance of solidarity and the ways in which survivors can help each other heal.
Mr. Dannenberg
Mr. Dannenberg is the father of one of the soldiers lost in the incident Edda believes she caused. His grief is raw and consuming, driving him to seek answers and, perhaps, retribution. He represents the families left behind by war, and the ways in which loss can curdle into anger and blame. His interactions with Edda are fraught, but ultimately reveal the impossibility of simple closure.
Louisa Safechuck
Louisa is a fellow operator and Miss Genovese's roommate, whose suicide is a devastating consequence of abuse and institutional failure. Though she appears only in memory, her story is central to the novel's exploration of trauma, shame, and the need for truth. Louisa's fate is a warning about the costs of silence and the importance of bearing witness.
Aunt Tess
Aunt Tess is Edda's aunt and landlady, a suffragette and supporter of women's rights. She provides Edda with a home and a measure of independence, but is also limited in her ability to understand or help. Tess represents the older generation of feminists, fighting for change but sometimes missing the personal struggles of those closest to her.
Helen
Helen is Edda's colleague at the switchboard, persistent in her attempts to befriend and support Edda. She embodies the possibility of ordinary kindness and the importance of community, even when it is not fully reciprocated. Helen's presence is a reminder that healing often begins with small acts of care.
The Forty-Eighth Regiment
The lost soldiers of the Forty-Eighth are never seen directly, but their absence is felt throughout the novel. Each name is a story, each family a site of grief. They represent the countless lives altered or ended by war, and the ripple effects of trauma and loss.
Plot Devices
Codes and Ciphers
The daily-changing military codes are both a practical necessity and a powerful symbol. They represent the need for secrecy, the difficulty of communication, and the ways in which meaning can be obscured or lost. The codes mirror Edda's own efforts to hide her trauma and guilt, and the challenge of deciphering the truth—about herself, about others, and about the past.
Nonlinear Narrative and Flashbacks
The novel moves fluidly between past and present, France and Washington, memory and reality. This structure reflects the way trauma disrupts time, and allows the reader to experience Edda's disorientation and struggle to make sense of her experiences. Flashbacks are used to gradually reveal the full scope of what happened, building suspense and deepening emotional resonance.
Mystery and Investigation
The central mystery—who is making the calls, and why?—provides momentum and structure. Edda and Theo's investigation is both literal and metaphorical, a quest for answers that becomes a journey into the heart of grief, guilt, and healing. The process of elimination, the gathering of clues, and the eventual revelation of the truth are all classic elements of the mystery genre, repurposed here to explore psychological and moral questions.
Foreshadowing and Symbolism
The novel is rich in foreshadowing, with early references to codes, calls, and the dangers of the front hinting at later revelations. Objects like the reference letter, the coin purse, and the blueprint labeled "Brightwood" serve as symbols of hidden connections and unresolved trauma. The act of cleaning Edda's room, for example, becomes a metaphor for the slow, imperfect process of healing.
Multiple Endings and Unfinished Business
The story resists neat resolution, emphasizing instead the ongoing nature of grief, trauma, and recovery. Conversations are interrupted, apologies are incomplete, and justice is elusive. This narrative choice underscores the novel's central insight: that some wounds never fully heal, and that the work of living goes on regardless.
Analysis
Monica Hesse's The Brightwood Code is a masterful exploration of the hidden costs of war, the complexity of trauma, and the necessity of truth-telling. Through the lens of Edda's experience as a "Hello Girl," the novel interrogates the ways in which women's contributions and sufferings are often overlooked or misunderstood. The shifting codes and the mystery of the calls serve as metaphors for the secrets we keep and the difficulty of communication—both in war and in peace. Hesse's narrative structure, with its interwoven timelines and gradual revelations, mirrors the psychological reality of trauma, where past and present bleed into each other and healing is a nonlinear process. The novel refuses easy answers or tidy resolutions, insisting instead on the importance of bearing witness, reaching out, and making life "bigger" around grief. Ultimately, The Brightwood Code is a story about the power of connection—across time, across silence, and across the chasms created by loss. It is a call to remember, to speak, and to keep living, even when the codes change and the lines go dead.
Last updated:
