Key Takeaways
1. Prioritize Player Experience: The Core of Your Game
How the players feel during your game is far more important than if the game is about Cthulu or if worker placement is your main mechanic.
Focus on feelings. The most crucial element in board game design is the player experience and the feelings you want to evoke. While "fun" is a common goal, it's subjective; you must define what kind of fun—be it frantic, calming, challenging, or humorous—your game aims to deliver. This vision will guide all subsequent design decisions, from theme to mechanics.
Experience drives design. Once you pinpoint the desired player experience, the appropriate theme and mechanics often fall into place naturally. For instance, a "frantic" experience might necessitate simultaneous actions and a timer, while a "cooperative" feeling demands teamwork-focused mechanics. This approach ensures your game's elements work in harmony to achieve a cohesive and impactful player journey.
Story and roles. The intended player experience also dictates the game's narrative and the roles players embody. Whether they are heroes, villains, or even inanimate objects, their perspective should align with the emotional journey you're crafting. This foundational understanding helps you make consistent choices throughout development, ensuring every aspect contributes to the overarching player experience.
2. Embrace Iteration: Your First Version Will Be Terrible
Game design is an iterative process. It’s all about failure, watching how the game doesn’t work, and learning from it.
Expect initial flaws. Your very first game prototype, or Minimum Viable Product (MVP), will likely be far from perfect, and that's completely normal. The goal of this initial, rough version is simply to get your idea out of your head and onto the table quickly to see if the core concept works in reality, not just in theory. This rapid prototyping saves immense time and effort by identifying fundamental issues early.
Learn from failure. Don't be discouraged by a "broken" first playtest; view it as an invaluable learning opportunity. Each failure reveals what doesn't work, guiding you toward necessary improvements. This iterative mindset, where you constantly test, observe, and refine, is the hallmark of successful game design.
Quick, rough starts. Spend no more than 5-10 minutes assembling your MVP using basic materials like paper, pens, and scissors. The appearance doesn't matter at this stage; focus solely on testing the core mechanics and player experience. This rapid creation allows you to quickly pivot or discard ideas that aren't viable, preventing wasted time on elaborate but flawed concepts.
3. The 4 I's Framework: Your Guide to Game Development
Every time you create a board game you will go through a continuous four-step cycle that I refer to as The 4 I’s Framework: Inquire through playtesting, Identify any problems, Illuminate potential problems, Iterate and revise your game.
Structured improvement. The 4 I's Framework provides a systematic approach to developing your game from concept to completion. It ensures that every playtest and subsequent change is purposeful, moving your game closer to its final, polished state. This continuous cycle is the engine of game design.
Problem-solving cycle. The framework begins with Inquiring by running a playtest and observing player interactions. Next, you Identify problems by gathering specific feedback, focusing on what isn't working rather than immediate solutions. Then, you Illuminate potential solutions by brainstorming various ideas, either alone or with others. Finally, you Iterate by selecting the best solution, making a revision, and repeating the cycle.
Continuous refinement. This framework is applied repeatedly, sometimes multiple times within a single playtest session, and other times over longer periods between sessions. It transforms setbacks into opportunities for growth, ensuring that your game consistently evolves and improves based on real-world feedback.
4. Playtest Relentlessly and Seek Unbiased Feedback
If I’m not truly open to changing my mind, it means that I’m also probably not listening to people who have different opinions, which severely limits my potential for growth and improvement.
Feedback is fuel. Consistent playtesting with diverse groups is paramount for refining your game. Start with friends and family, but quickly move to strangers—other designers, avid gamers, or even online communities—to get unbiased, critical feedback. Their fresh perspectives will uncover issues you, as the designer, might overlook.
Ask specific questions. During playtests, avoid vague questions like "Did you like it?" Instead, ask targeted questions to pinpoint specific issues, such as "If you played this game again, and just one thing was different that made you think the game had improved, even only by 5%... what would be different?" This helps identify core pain points and guides your iterative changes.
Embrace critique. Don't take critical feedback personally; it's a gift meant to improve your game. Thank playtesters for their honesty, and if a suggestion is unclear or seems unhelpful, ask for clarification rather than becoming defensive. Pay particular attention to issues raised by multiple players, as these often indicate systemic problems that need addressing.
5. Don't Protect Ideas; Share Them to Improve
But honestly, ideas are a dime a dozen.
Ideas are cheap. Many new designers fear their ideas will be stolen, leading them to guard their concepts closely. However, an idea's true value lies in its execution, not its initial conception. Everyone is busy with their own projects, and the chances of someone stealing and successfully developing your exact idea are minimal.
Collaboration is key. Sharing your game idea, especially in the form of an early prototype, is crucial for its development. Feedback from others, particularly experienced designers, will help you identify flaws, discover new possibilities, and refine your game into something truly great. This open approach accelerates the design process and leads to a superior final product.
Avoid premature protection. Spending time and money on trademarks or patents early in the design process is often a waste. Publishers handle intellectual property if they sign your game, and they view designers who insist on NDAs or early trademarks as amateurish. Focus your resources on design and playtesting, not on protecting an undeveloped concept.
6. Cultivate a Designer's Mindset: Focus, Consistency, and Resilience
It is the greatest of all mistakes to do nothing because you can do only a little. Do what you can.
Consistency is paramount. Dedicate time daily to work on your game, even if it's just for a short period. This consistent effort builds momentum and hones your design skills, much like practicing any other craft. Break down tasks into tangible, actionable "next steps" to avoid procrastination and maintain progress.
Fight the "Resistance." Creative endeavors inevitably encounter self-doubt, procrastination, and the urge to give up—what author Steven Pressfield calls "the Resistance." Recognize these feelings as normal, but don't let them win. Take breaks, talk through problems, or play other games to get unstuck, but always return to your project.
Learn from mistakes. Your first game will be a significant learning curve, and you'll likely make mistakes, as the author did with his first game taking two years. Embrace these as lessons that accelerate your growth as a designer. The goal is to continuously move forward, improving with each iteration, rather than striving for an unattainable perfection.
7. Simplify and Stick to Your Game's Vision
Ultimately, you make the final decisions about what changes and what remains in your game.
Define your vision. Early in the design process, establish a clear vision for your game, including its core elements and the desired player experience. This vision acts as your compass, guiding decisions about what to keep, change, or cut, ensuring your game retains its unique "soul" and purpose.
Less is often more. When in doubt, simplify. Removing elements that don't enhance the player experience is usually more effective than adding new ones. Overly complex games can overwhelm players, leading to disengagement and analysis paralysis. Aim for interesting, meaningful choices, not an abundance of options.
Balance fun and realism. While a compelling theme adds depth, don't sacrifice fun for the sake of realism. If a realistic element makes the game tedious or slow, consider removing it. Your game should be enjoyable first and foremost. Remember, your game will evolve, but your core vision should remain the anchor.
8. Master the Rulebook: Clarity is King
The main purpose of rules are to learn a game and to refer back/refresh your memory.
Clear and concise. A well-written rulebook is essential for players to learn and enjoy your game without your direct guidance. Rules should be easy to follow, using simple, consistent language and terminology. Avoid jargon where possible, and clearly define any unique terms related to your game's theme.
Logical structure and visuals. Organize your rulebook logically, guiding players through setup, gameplay, and scoring in the order they'll encounter them. Incorporate helpful visuals, diagrams, and examples to illustrate concepts, actions, and board layouts. Many people learn visually, so images are as important as text.
Key elements for rules:
- Introduction and theme
- How to win (goal/objective)
- Setup (with pictures)
- How to play (with examples)
- Important considerations and exceptions
- Scoring and endgame
- Reference notes and a legend for icons/terms
Ensure consistency in icons, colors, and symbols to prevent confusion. Consider creating player reference cards for quick access to crucial information during play.
9. Know When Your Game is "Done," Not "Perfect"
Aim for Done, Not Perfect.
Recognize completion. One of the hardest challenges is knowing when to stop refining your game. You're ready for completion when playtesters offer very little feedback for improvement, and suggestions primarily focus on making the game "different" rather than "better." The game should consistently deliver the intended experience and run smoothly without your intervention.
Diminishing returns. Striving for absolute perfection is a trap that can prevent your game from ever being released. At some point, the effort invested in minor tweaks yields minimal improvements. Accept that no game will please everyone, and focus on creating a great game for your target audience, not a flawless one.
Publisher's role. If you plan to pitch to a traditional publisher, remember that they will likely make further changes to your game, regardless of how polished you believe it is. Their development team will refine it to fit their catalog and market strategy. Therefore, aiming for "done" rather than "perfect" is a pragmatic approach that allows you to move forward.
10. Build Community: Give Before You Get
The purpose of life is not to be happy. It is to be useful, to be honorable, to be compassionate, to have it make some difference that you have lived and lived well.
Reciprocity in action. Actively engage with the board game community by playtesting other designers' games and offering constructive feedback. This generosity fosters goodwill and encourages others to reciprocate when you need help with your own projects. Being a helpful, supportive member builds your reputation and network.
Continuous learning. Immerse yourself in the broader gaming world by exploring online forums, blogs, podcasts, and conventions. Learn from experienced designers, observe successful game mechanics, and understand market trends. This ongoing education is vital for your growth as a designer and for identifying opportunities.
Contribute value. Share your insights, discoveries, and experiences with the community. Whether it's a prototyping tip, a playtesting lesson, or a helpful resource, contributing value establishes you as a knowledgeable and respected voice. This not only helps others but also builds a following that may support your future games.
11. Choose Your Publishing Path Wisely: Traditional vs. Self-Publishing
No one option is necessarily better than the others, they’re just different. You have to choose the one that’s right for you.
Understand your goals. Once your game is complete, you face a critical decision: pursue a traditional publisher, self-publish (via crowdfunding or direct sales), or opt for simpler alternatives like Print-on-Demand or Print and Play. Each path has distinct pros, cons, and demands, so align your choice with your personal goals, risk tolerance, and available time.
Traditional publishing. This route offers broad distribution and handles manufacturing, marketing, and fulfillment, allowing you to focus on design. However, it means relinquishing creative control, potentially waiting years for release, and earning smaller royalties. Publishers also have specific submission guidelines and may reject games that don't fit their catalog.
Self-publishing (crowdfunding/direct). Crowdfunding platforms like Kickstarter offer lower financial risk and gauge market demand before production. It grants creative control and higher potential profits but demands significant time and effort in marketing, budgeting, manufacturing, shipping, and customer service—essentially running a business. Direct sales require even more upfront investment and marketing effort.
Alternatives and considerations. Print-on-Demand (e.g., The Gamecrafter) offers minimal investment and creative control but limited market exposure and higher per-unit costs for customers. Print and Play (PnP) is the simplest, often free, way to share your game, ideal for playtesting or niche audiences. Ultimately, your choice depends on whether you prioritize creative control, financial upside, ease of process, or simply sharing your creation with friends and family.
Last updated:
