Key Takeaways
1. Choose "Mother Lode" Ideas with Built-in Potential
Pixar goes for the mother lodes.
Select rich concepts. Pixar excels at choosing ideas that are inherently engaging and offer multiple layers of dramatic and narrative possibilities. These "mother lodes" often involve relatable concepts placed in unique, imaginative worlds, like toys being alive or emotions living inside a person's head. Such ideas provide a fertile ground for creative set pieces and visual richness.
Built-in stakes. Strong ideas come with powerful, built-in emotional weight and physical stakes. This makes them immediately enticing and accessible to audiences. For example:
- Toys fearing obsolescence and abandonment.
- Monsters needing to scare children for energy.
- A rat dreaming of being a gourmet chef.
These core concepts provide immediate conflict and drive.
Foundation for growth. A strong core idea acts like a seed containing the potential for the entire story. Every element, character, and plot development should ideally stem from and enrich this central concept, ensuring efficiency and focus throughout the narrative.
2. Embrace Discomfort: More Discomfort Equals More Story
This state of discomfort is gold for writers for a couple of reasons.
Force characters out. Good stories place protagonists outside their comfort zones, challenging what they want most by throwing the exact opposite at them. This immediate state of discomfort generates narrative questions and provides material for scenes. A rat cooking in a sewer is less dramatic than a rat cooking in a gourmet restaurant.
Propel emotional journeys. Being forced out of their element compels characters to work hard to regain comfort, driving actions, decisions, and emotions. This struggle is the heart of the story's inner narrative. Woody's discomfort when Buzz arrives forces him on a wild adventure and makes him confront fears about Andy's love.
Catalyst for change. Discomfort isn't just bad luck; it's a catalyst that forces heroes to react, grow, and change. Pixar creates pre-existing problems or flaws in characters' worlds that the plot then pushes to the extreme, ensuring the discomfort is deeply personal and related to their core issues.
3. Create Compelling Characters Who Care Deeply
Great characters care because they have strong opinions.
Characters must care. Beyond unique design and specific traits, compelling characters must deeply care about something – anything. We become invested in characters because they are invested in their world and the events happening around them. Woody's obsessive care for Andy is the basis for all his conflicts.
Strong opinions matter. Deep caring often stems from strong opinions, which amplify dramatic effect and serve as fuel for conflict. These opinions are usually rooted in a character's past experiences, especially painful ones, giving them depth and making their actions more intelligible and relatable.
- Elinor's opinions on duty in Brave stem from past wars.
- Helen's caution in The Incredibles comes from past hardships.
- Jessie's distrust in Toy Story 2 is born from abandonment.
Experience shapes beliefs. Pixar often uses meaningful sequences, like prologues or flashbacks, to show the experiences that shaped a character's core beliefs and opinions. These glimpses into the past provide texture and make present actions more meaningful, even transforming antagonists into relatable figures.
4. Build Empathy Through Specificity, Desire, and Determination
Empathy is about recognizing ourselves in someone else by getting to know their idiosyncrasies and life experiences.
Show their inner world. Empathy allows audiences to see themselves in characters, making the character a proxy for their own hopes and fears. This goes beyond superficial liking based on charisma; it requires revealing a character's specific idiosyncrasies, hobbies, routines, and inner life in an honest, relatable way. Wall-E's love for Hello, Dolly! and his coming-home ritual make him deeply human despite being a robot.
Focus on clear desires. Audiences quickly empathize with characters who clearly desire something, whether small or grand, and understand why they want it. This motivation propels the character and makes us root for them. Remy's desire to cook stems from his unique senses and feeling like an outsider among rats.
Exhibit determination. Characters must pursue their goals with determination, bravely battling self-doubt and never giving up until every imaginable course of action is exhausted. This relentless pursuit, even in the face of overwhelming odds, is inspiring and deeply satisfying to watch, reflecting a human ideal we admire. Characters may falter momentarily, but they always push forward.
5. Layer Your Story with Action, Bonding, and Inner Struggle
This triple and sometimes quadruple structure seems to satisfy all the reasons we go to the movies: high-end adventure, meaningful relationships, and deep emotional struggles.
Multilayered approach. Pixar films often employ a layered structure combining multiple narrative threads. Typically, this includes an epic, adventurous main plot with high stakes (e.g., searching the ocean, saving humanity), an interpersonal story of bonding between unlikely characters, and an internal emotional struggle for the protagonist.
Interconnected narratives. These layers are not isolated but are deeply interconnected, reinforcing one another. The emotional weight of the internal struggle gives meaning to the daring actions, and the bonding process often mirrors or facilitates the protagonist's inner change. Marlin's journey to find Nemo is intertwined with his struggle to overcome anxiety and his bonding with Dory.
Enhanced satisfaction. This complex structure satisfies diverse audience desires for action, relationships, and emotional depth. It also creates more opportunities for major events and character development, leading to richer, more satisfying stories. Sometimes, an additional parallel subplot is included, further adding complexity and engagement.
6. Drive the Narrative with Major Events as Crossroads
Major events are crossroads, which usually offer a chance for a character to cut their losses or continue bravely ahead.
Key turning points. Stories require a setup, trials, and resolution, punctuated by major events like the inciting incident, plot points, and climax. These events are integral to the main story, directly pertaining to the protagonist's core problem and driving the narrative forward. They are the "what happens" moments.
Decisions and consequences. Major events aren't just exciting scenes; they are crossroads where characters must make significant decisions that affect their path. These moments often offer a chance for either "destruction" (succumbing to the flaw, losing hope) or "construction" (overcoming the flaw, finding a new path).
- Marlin finding the address (Plot Point 1) offers hope.
- Marlin thinking Nemo is dead (Plot Point 2) brings despair.
- Carl deciding to fly his house (Plot Point 1) commits him to the adventure.
Relating to the core. Each major event should relate directly to the existing flaw introduced early in the story, either threatening it further or offering a chance to fix it. The scenes between these events depict the "hows" and "whys," keeping conflict alive and the audience invested in the protagonist's struggle.
7. Conflict Exposes Flaws and Propels Character Change
Change is the measuring unit of conflict.
Beyond physical struggle. While life-or-death situations are engaging, conflict is broadly defined as anything standing between the protagonist and their goal. The most powerful conflicts are internal, forcing characters to confront their flaws, beliefs, and fears. These emotional struggles are harder to convey but create deeper resonance.
Risking identity. Effective conflict puts something dear to the character at risk, often a part of their identity or core belief. Woody risking his loyalty to Andy for safety in Toy Story 2 is an example of this inner conflict dramatized externally. The struggle between opposing forces (loyalty vs. fear) creates dramatic tension.
Construction through change. The best conflicts offer a chance for both destruction (losing something) and construction (building something new). This construction comes from believable character change, which is inherently difficult and moving. Characters must dismantle old parts of themselves to build anew, emerging stronger and better equipped to face future threats. This change is the ultimate measure of the conflict's impact.
8. Antagonism Comes in Many Forms, Not Just Villains
Antagonism refers to anything that stands between your protagonist and their goal.
Obstacles are diverse. Antagonism isn't limited to mustache-twirling villains; it can be a character, object, concept, environment, or even the protagonist's own flaws. The vast ocean in Finding Nemo is a major antagonist, as is Marlin's anxiety. Identifying diverse sources of opposition enriches the story.
Evil vs. Troublesome. Sentient antagonists can be "evil" (malicious, indifferent to harm) or "troublesome" (mean well but inadvertently cause grief). Even "evil" villains like Lotso are more compelling when their actions are rooted in understandable, albeit twisted, experiences. "Troublesome" antagonists, like Russel in Up, create conflict through their nature or goals clashing with the protagonist's.
"Good" villains have principles. Pixar often features "good" villains who appear malicious but have a benevolent core belief aimed at benefiting their community, acting with integrity according to their principles. Anton Ego seeks to elevate food criticism, and Dean Hardscrabble aims to maximize scaring efficiency. They aren't purely self-interested and have lines they won't cross, making them complex and sometimes redeemable.
9. Develop Ideas by Exploring Worlds and Subverting Expectations
One of the great joys of Pixar’s films is the way they subvert expectations.
Explore your universe. Developing an idea involves deep exploration of the fictional world, discovering its inhabitants, rules, and ways of life. This process generates details that make the world feel real and provides material for scenes, satire, and drama, even if not all discoveries make it into the final plot. The details of the Axiom spaceship in Wall-E are a result of this exploration.
Subvert the familiar. Pixar excels at taking familiar concepts or settings and twisting them in unexpected ways, subverting audience expectations. This keeps the audience engaged and pushes the story into more original territory. Vegetarian sharks, talking dogs, or superheroes forced into suburban life are examples of this technique.
Creative limitations help. Imposing creative limitations can paradoxically aid development by forcing writers to find innovative solutions. Deciding not to include a love story, for instance, pushes the focus onto other relationship dynamics. These self-imposed constraints encourage deeper exploration within the chosen framework.
10. Endings Must Be Earned by Character Action, Not Coincidence
The final action must be a direct result of the journey your characters have taken.
Avoid deus ex machina. A satisfying ending is a direct result of the protagonist's actions and journey, not random chance. Coincidences might happen in life, but they should not resolve the main conflict in a story. Flik luring Hopper to the bird is earned; a random bird attack is not.
Tie back to the beginning. Strong endings often subtly reference or resolve elements introduced earlier in the story, sometimes details the audience may have forgotten. This creates a sense of cohesiveness and reinforces the meaning of the journey. Ellie's message in her scrapbook in Up provides a crucial, earned turning point for Carl.
Show the new world. The most moving endings demonstrate the positive ripple effect of the protagonist's journey, showing how they have changed themselves and, often, improved the world around them. This resolution should ideally be shown visually, illustrating the new, healthier state of the characters or their community. The multicolored memories in Inside Out visually represent Riley's emotional growth.
11. Theme Permeates Every Element of Your Story
Theme is what your story—your scenes, your chases, your one-liners—seeks to create and present.
Theme is universal. Theme is the abstract, universal concept your story is fundamentally about, distinct from the plot. It's the inherent human truth explored through the narrative. Finding Nemo's theme is parenthood, Ratatouille's is creativity and individuality, and Toy Story's is the passage of time and acceptance of change.
Emerges organically. Ideally, theme arises naturally from the chosen fictional universe and characters. The themes of obsolescence and loss are inherent to a story about toys. Once the core concept is chosen, the themes bound to it must be addressed and explored.
Weave it throughout. To make a theme clear and impactful, it must permeate every element of the story. This can be achieved by:
- Using supporting characters as embodiments of thematic values (Gusteau vs. Ego).
- Crafting antagonists as thematic mirror images of the protagonist (Syndrome vs. Mr. Incredible).
- Imbuing objects or locations with thematic meaning (Carl's house, Brave's bears).
- Stating the theme or variations of it through dialogue.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What is "Pixar Storytelling: Rules for Effective Storytelling Based on Pixar’s Greatest Films" by Dean Movshovitz about?
- Focus on Pixar’s Storytelling: The book analyzes the storytelling techniques that have made Pixar’s films so successful, moving, and universally beloved.
- Practical Guide for Writers: It serves as a practical guide for screenwriters and storytellers, breaking down Pixar’s narrative patterns, character development, and emotional impact.
- Film Examples: Movshovitz uses detailed examples from Pixar’s filmography, such as Toy Story, Ratatouille, and Inside Out, to illustrate each storytelling rule.
- Actionable Advice: The book offers actionable advice and “Do It Yourself” prompts for readers to apply Pixar’s methods to their own stories.
2. Why should I read "Pixar Storytelling" by Dean Movshovitz?
- Learn from the Best: Pixar is renowned for its emotionally resonant and structurally sound stories; learning their methods can elevate your own storytelling.
- Clear, Actionable Insights: The book distills complex storytelling concepts into clear, practical rules and examples.
- Applicable to All Writers: Whether you write screenplays, novels, or short stories, the principles are broadly applicable.
- Inspiration and Motivation: Movshovitz’s analysis is both educational and inspiring, encouraging readers to pursue their creative ambitions with integrity and heart.
3. What are the key takeaways from "Pixar Storytelling" by Dean Movshovitz?
- Start with a Strong Core Idea: Choose story ideas with deep emotional and narrative potential—Pixar calls these “mother lodes.”
- Character-Driven Stories: Compelling characters with strong desires, opinions, and backstories are essential for audience investment.
- Conflict and Change: Effective stories place characters in discomfort, forcing them to confront flaws and change in meaningful ways.
- Layered Structure: Pixar’s films often feature multiple narrative layers—action, bonding, and internal struggle—culminating in powerful double climaxes.
4. How does Dean Movshovitz define and explain the "mother lode" concept in "Pixar Storytelling"?
- Rich Story Potential: A “mother lode” is an idea with abundant narrative and emotional possibilities, making it easier to develop and more accessible to audiences.
- Built-in Stakes: These ideas naturally contain high physical and emotional stakes, which immediately engage viewers.
- Examples from Pixar: Concepts like “toys are alive” (Toy Story) or “emotions inside a child’s mind” (Inside Out) are cited as mother lodes.
- Guidance for Writers: Movshovitz encourages writers to seek out and develop ideas that offer multiple avenues for drama, character growth, and thematic exploration.
5. What advice does "Pixar Storytelling" give about creating compelling characters?
- Characters Who Care Deeply: Characters must be passionate about something, as this drives their actions and makes them relatable.
- Strong Opinions from Experience: The most interesting characters have strong, experience-based opinions that fuel conflict and growth.
- Unique and Specific Traits: Distinctive habits, flaws, and backgrounds make characters memorable and authentic.
- Emotional Honesty: Characters’ motivations and reactions should be rooted in emotional truth, not just “coolness” or originality.
6. How does "Pixar Storytelling" by Dean Movshovitz explain the process of creating empathy for characters?
- Three Levels of Liking: Movshovitz describes three levels—surface attraction, deeper interest, and full empathy where the audience’s emotions align with the character’s.
- Show Specificity and Vulnerability: Revealing characters’ routines, quirks, and vulnerabilities helps audiences relate on a personal level.
- Clear Desires and Motives: Characters with clear goals and strong motivations are easier to root for.
- Determination and Resilience: Audiences empathize most with characters who persist through adversity and only give up after exhausting all options.
7. What does "Pixar Storytelling" say about the role of conflict and drama in effective storytelling?
- Beyond Life and Death: Conflict isn’t just about physical danger; it’s about obstacles—internal and external—that challenge the protagonist’s core beliefs and desires.
- Emotional Stakes: The most powerful conflicts are rooted in what the character stands to lose emotionally, not just physically.
- Change Through Conflict: True drama forces characters to confront and change their flaws, leading to meaningful growth.
- Externalizing Internal Struggles: Pixar excels at making internal conflicts visible through plot devices, supporting characters, and visual metaphors.
8. How does "Pixar Storytelling" describe Pixar’s approach to story structure?
- Flexible Three-Act Structure: While acknowledging traditional structures (setup, trials, climax), Movshovitz emphasizes flexibility and story-specific pacing.
- Major Events as Turning Points: Key plot points (inciting incident, first and second plot points, climax) are tied directly to the protagonist’s core problem.
- Layered Storytelling: Pixar films often weave together action, bonding, and internal plots, creating a “multilayered storytelling cake.”
- Double Climaxes: Many Pixar films resolve the external plot first, followed by a quieter, emotional resolution that addresses the character’s internal journey.
9. What guidance does "Pixar Storytelling" offer on casting and designing supporting characters?
- Every Character Has a Function: Each character should serve a narrative purpose and contribute to the story’s core idea.
- Distinctiveness and Depth: Even minor characters are given unique traits, backstories, and motivations to make them memorable.
- Honesty Over Gimmicks: Originality should never come at the expense of emotional truth; characters must feel real within the story’s world.
- Visual and Emotional Design: Physical appearance and personality should reinforce each character’s role and emotional arc.
10. How does "Pixar Storytelling" by Dean Movshovitz approach the concept of antagonists and villains?
- Antagonism Beyond Evil: Antagonists can be malicious, benevolent, or simply troublesome; not all are “villains” in the traditional sense.
- Complex Motivations: The best villains have understandable, even relatable, motivations rooted in their own experiences and values.
- Mirror Images: Many Pixar antagonists reflect the protagonist’s own flaws or fears, serving as cautionary examples.
- Multiple Antagonists: Pixar often uses both external (villainous) and internal (troublesome or environmental) antagonists to challenge the hero.
11. What does "Pixar Storytelling" recommend for developing and evolving story ideas?
- Explore and Plot: Writers should both explore their fictional worlds for unique details and plot out key story beats that challenge the protagonist.
- Subvert Expectations: Surprising the audience by twisting familiar tropes or settings keeps stories fresh and engaging.
- Creative Limitations: Imposing constraints (e.g., no love story, or certain genre rules) can inspire more original storytelling solutions.
- Functionality of Details: Every imaginative element should serve a purpose in the plot or theme, not just exist for its own sake.
12. How does "Pixar Storytelling" by Dean Movshovitz address endings and theme in storytelling?
- Endings Rooted in Character: Satisfying endings arise from the protagonist’s actions and growth, not from coincidence or random events.
- Answer Forgotten Questions: Strong conclusions often resolve subtle questions or themes introduced early in the story.
- Visualizing Change: Pixar endings frequently show the ripple effect of the protagonist’s journey on their world, often through powerful visuals.
- Theme as Foundation: The theme should emerge organically from the story’s universe and be reinforced through characters, objects, and dialogue, making the narrative resonate on a universal level.
Review Summary
Pixar Storytelling receives mostly positive reviews, praised for its concise analysis of Pixar's storytelling techniques. Readers appreciate the practical advice and examples from popular films. Some find it ideal for beginners, while others desire more depth. The book is commended for its straightforward approach and insightful questions. Critics note it may be too basic for experienced writers. Overall, it's considered a valuable resource for aspiring storytellers, particularly those interested in animation and screenwriting.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub
digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.