Key Takeaways
1. Democracy is an Active Practice, Not a Passive State
Practicing democracy can enable us to grow, to learn, to care, and to act.
Democracy's promise. Democracy is more than a form of governance; it's a promise of dignity, equality, solidarity, and justice, realized through the equal value of each voice and collective agency. However, this promise has eroded, particularly since the 1970s, due to wealth concentration, political commodification, and the weakening of civic infrastructure. Many Americans only recognized this crisis after 2016, but the underlying issues have been decades in the making.
Reclaiming agency. The current moment, marked by widespread social and political challenges, demands a renewed commitment to democratic practice. Millions of Americans can strengthen democracy by actively engaging in its core processes: coming together, committing to shared purposes, deliberating, deciding, and acting collectively. This requires overcoming the tendency to rely on market solutions or individualistic approaches that undermine collective capacity.
Learnable craft. Practicing democracy is a learnable craft, rooted in decades of experience, research, and teaching. It involves a pedagogy of practice—explaining, modeling, practicing, and debriefing—within a "brave space" that encourages respectful feedback and continuous learning. This approach has been successfully adapted globally, proving that the skills for democratic renewal can be acquired and sustained.
2. Leadership is Enabling Shared Purpose Amid Uncertainty
Leadership is accepting responsibility (self) for enabling others (us) to achieve shared purpose under conditions of uncertainty (now).
Hillel's wisdom. Effective leadership begins with three ancient questions from Rabbi Hillel: "If I am not for myself, who will be for me? When I am for myself alone, what am I? If not now, when?" These questions underscore the importance of self-awareness, relationality, and timely action, especially when facing the unexpected. Leadership is not about having all the answers, but about knowing how to find them.
Head, hands, heart. Leadership is a holistic practice engaging the head (strategy), hands (skills), and heart (hope/courage). When confronted with uncertainty, leaders must assess their skills, strategize resource use, and find the hope and resilience to take necessary risks. This means leadership is about learning and enabling others to choose mindful responses over fearful reactions.
Practice over position. True leadership is defined by practice, not by formal position or authority. Many individuals without titles demonstrate leadership daily by inspiring courage, building community, and transforming resources into power. The goal is to cultivate many leaders, not just a single charismatic figure, to drive social change and democratic renewal.
3. Civic Relationships are the Essential Fabric of Collective Action
Civic relationships are the threads with which robust democracy is woven.
Beyond transactions. Relationships are fundamental to human existence, forming the basis of families, communities, and associations. Unlike fleeting transactions, relationships require mutual commitment to a shared future. Civic relationships, specifically, are built on shared purpose, values, and respect, enabling individuals to transcend narrow self-interests and forge common ground.
Intentional connection. Building civic relationships is an intentional act, crucial for transforming diverse individuals into a cohesive constituency. This process, exemplified by the Athenian shift from kinship to citizenship, allows for broader understanding of common interests and greater inclusivity. It counters the erosion of social capital caused by radical individualism and instrumental exchange.
One-on-ones and house meetings. Practical organizing tactics like one-on-one meetings and house meetings are vital for building these relationships.
- One-on-ones: Intentional conversations to share stories, explore values, and decide on mutual commitment. They foster self-discovery and genuine connection.
- House meetings: Leverage existing social networks by having hosts invite acquaintances to discuss challenges and commit to action, creating a cascade of engagement.
These methods turn informal connections into formal public relationships, scaling organizing efforts effectively.
4. Public Narrative Ignites Hope and Mobilizes Action
Public narrative, then, is a way we can harness the power of narrative to the work of leadership: accepting responsibility for enabling others to achieve shared purpose under conditions of uncertainty.
Why we care. Stories are the language of the heart, communicating values and motivating action in ways that facts alone cannot. They provide emotional resources to respond hopefully to disruptions, rather than fearfully. Public narrative, a framework of "story of self, story of us, and story of now," helps leaders articulate their "why" and inspire collective agency.
Story elements. A powerful story moment involves a challenge, a choice, and an outcome, teaching an experiential moral. By identifying with the protagonist, listeners feel the emotional content—fear, hope, courage—and grasp the underlying values. This process, akin to "agency training," equips individuals to make mindful choices in the face of uncertainty.
- Story of Self: Shares personal moments of hurt and hope, revealing motivating values and building moral authority.
- Story of Us: Recalls shared experiences and values, fostering solidarity and a collective identity.
- Story of Now: Confronts an urgent challenge, offers a plausible vision of hope, and calls for specific, timely action.
Empathetic bridge. Leaders use an "empathetic bridge" to engage with others' experiences of loss, difference, domination, and change. This involves acknowledging challenges, offering empathy (not claiming it), narrating hope, and offering clear choices. This approach helps restore agency by validating feelings and inspiring courageous, collective responses.
5. Strategy Transforms Resources into Collective Power
Strategy is how you turn what you have into what you need to get what you want.
Beyond tactics. Strategy is the "how" of organizing, a dynamic and creative practice of adapting intentional action to ever-changing conditions. It's not merely planning, but a hypothesis—a "theory of change"—about how to leverage resources to achieve valued change. Tactics are the specific actions that embody and test this strategy, ensuring efforts are purposeful, not just habitual.
Resourcefulness over resources. Organizing often pits limited resources against powerful status quo forces. The key is resourcefulness: creatively using available assets to gain leverage. The David and Goliath story illustrates this, where David's unique skills and perspective compensated for Goliath's overwhelming conventional resources. Good strategists identify and exploit points of leverage.
Strategic process. Effective strategizing involves a six-question process:
- Who are my people? Focus on their values, interests, and resources.
- What change do they want/need? Identify specific, plausible outcomes.
- What is their theory of change? Hypothesize how actions will lead to desired results, often through power analysis.
- What is their strategic goal? Define visible, measurable outcomes that build capacity.
- What tactics can they use? Design activities that leverage strengths, unify the constituency, and are consistent with values.
- What about timing? Align campaign rhythms with external and internal temporal dynamics.
This iterative process, often conducted by diverse leadership teams, ensures adaptability and impact.
6. Effective Action Demands Motivation, Commitment, and Measurement
If you can’t count it, it didn’t happen!
Mobilizing resources. Action is about making change happen on the ground by mobilizing and deploying resources. Organizers prioritize people's resources—time, bodies, imagination, agency—over external financial resources, as people-based power is essential for democratic empowerment. This counters the trend of donor-dependent activism that shifts accountability away from the constituency.
Motivation and commitment. Sustaining action requires intrinsically motivational work design and clear commitments.
- Motivational task design: Tasks should offer experienced meaningfulness, responsibility, and understood results, achieved through task significance, identity, skill variety, autonomy, and feedback. This fosters initiative and learning.
- The Four Cs of Commitment: Connect with the person, provide context for urgency and hope, make a specific commitment ask, and catapult them into action with clear next steps. Commitments, once made, tend to generate more commitments.
Evidence-based organizing. Action must be linked to specific, measurable outcomes with real deadlines. This allows for continuous learning, adaptation, and accountability.
- Tracking progress: Visible metrics (e.g., votes secured, people turned out) enable concrete assessment of success or failure.
- Learning from outcomes: Analyzing what worked and what didn't, without blame, allows for strategic adjustments and leadership development.
- Transparency: Openly sharing metrics builds trust and empowers participants to understand their impact and contribute to collective improvement.
7. Robust Structure Balances Continuity with Dynamic Change
When we build structure, we invest it with the authority of legitimate rules, processes, and procedures with which we can govern ourselves.
Structure creates space. Structure, derived from "to build," reduces uncertainty and conserves creative energy by establishing predictable frameworks for coordination, collaboration, and decision-making. It's not about stifling freedom, but about creating the necessary space for effective collective action. Without clear structure, groups often devolve into chaos or opaque, informal power dynamics.
Four structural tensions. Democratic organizing must navigate inherent tensions:
- Change and Continuity: Campaigns drive change, requiring urgency and adaptation; organizations provide continuity, needing predictability and coherence.
- Inclusion and Exclusion: Defining who is "in" (members, citizens) creates boundaries, which are necessary for trust and shared identity, but must be managed to avoid limiting participation.
- Unity and Diversity: Diversity fosters creativity and accountability, while unity enables focus and collective action. Balancing these is crucial for robust decision-making and performance.
- Parts and Wholes: Integrating local autonomy with regional/national strategy to achieve scale and broader impact, avoiding fragmentation or top-down control.
Managing tensions. These dilemmas can be managed through three principles:
- Distribute Responsibility: Empowering more people with leadership roles fosters responsiveness and engagement.
- Facilitate Collaboration: Designing interdependent work practices (e.g., teams, peer learning) enhances synergy and collective problem-solving.
- Preserve Dissent: Nurturing a culture that values diverse perspectives and open debate strengthens decision-making and accountability, preventing groupthink.
These principles are applied across all organizational activities: meetings, actions, and celebrations.
8. Developmental Leadership Scales Impact Through Teams and Coaching
An organizer’s job is to identify, recruit, and develop leadership who can identify, recruit, and develop more leadership, who can identify, recruit, and develop more leadership in a cascade of leadership.
Beyond lone heroes. Effective organizing requires a systematic commitment to developing leadership at scale. This means moving beyond the "lone leader" model to cultivate interdependent leadership teams. These teams, like a string quartet, leverage diverse strengths and foster collaborative leadership for shared purpose.
Effective teams. Successful leadership teams are:
- Bounded: Clear about who is on the team and how new members join.
- Stable: Members commit to regular engagement and terms of service.
- Diverse: Members contribute a range of skills, viewpoints, and constituency connections.
They operate with a shared purpose, clear norms (for decision-making, conflict, time), and interdependent roles, ensuring collective responsibility and accountability.
Snowflaking out. To achieve scale, developmental leadership adopts a "snowflake" model: each member of a core leadership team accepts responsibility for organizing their own team, and so on. This systematic approach to identifying, recruiting, and developing leaders ensures a continuous cascade of capacity building.
- Identifying: Based on deeds, not just words—looking for commitment, openness to learning, and relational capacity.
- Recruiting: Taking calculated risks, offering real responsibility, and learning from small failures.
- Developing: Through sustained training, coaching, and opportunities to earn leadership.
Coaching for growth. Ongoing coaching is vital for sustained leadership development. It's a direct intervention to improve effectiveness, focusing on overcoming motivational, educational, or strategic challenges. Coaches ask probing questions, listen with head and heart, and offer support (affirmation and challenge) to help coachees articulate their own solutions and integrate new practices.
9. People-Powered Movements are Essential for Democratic Renewal
Our challenge is linking social movement energy with organizational capacity to transform it into political, economic, and cultural power.
The current crisis. Since the 1970s, a political economy favoring the few (owners) over the many (workers) has eroded democracy. Monetized electoral processes, donor-dependent civil society, and an unrepresentative constitutional structure have concentrated power and exacerbated inequalities. The most disruptive reactions have often come from the right, attacking democracy itself.
Reclaiming power. To counter these forces, a new movement moment is needed, one that links social movement energy with robust organizational capacity. This requires going back to the basics of organizing: building relationships, sharing stories of shared values, strategizing resourcefully, acting courageously, and structuring interactions to include the many.
Transformative potential. Organizing is not just about solving immediate problems; it's about developing leadership, building organizations, and creating sustained power to challenge structural injustices. It transforms disempowered communities into empowered constituencies capable of changing the rules of the game, not just winning within existing ones. This is the essence of healthy democracy.
Last updated:
