Plot Summary
Bar Encounters and Boundaries
Cassie, a bold college senior, escapes Family Weekend by heading to a bar across town, seeking anonymity and distraction. There, she meets Erin, an alluring older woman, and their flirtation quickly escalates into a passionate, no-strings-attached hookup in the backseat of a car. Both women are drawn to each other's confidence and vulnerability, but neither expects to see the other again. The encounter is electric, freeing Cassie from her frustrations and giving Erin a taste of excitement she's missed since her divorce. Their connection is intense but seemingly fleeting, setting the stage for complications neither anticipates.
Family Weekend Fallout
The next morning, Cassie is roped into breakfast with her friend Parker and Parker's mother—who turns out to be Erin. The revelation is a gut punch for both women, who must mask their shock and attraction in front of Parker. The breakfast is a minefield of hidden glances and under-the-table flirtation, as Cassie and Erin struggle to maintain composure. Both are forced to confront the reality that their one-night stand is now tangled in their social circles, with the added complication of Parker's obliviousness. The tension is palpable, and the stakes are suddenly much higher.
Breakfast Tension, Secret Sparks
Cassie and Erin attempt to navigate their new roles as "parent" and "friend," but the chemistry between them simmers beneath the surface. Cassie's boldness and Erin's restraint clash and intertwine, leading to moments of secret contact and loaded conversation. Erin is torn between her desire for Cassie and her responsibility as a mother, while Cassie is both amused and frustrated by the situation. The two agree—at least in theory—to keep their distance, but the allure of the forbidden proves difficult to resist, especially as they continue to cross paths throughout Family Weekend.
A Cappella and Aftermath
At Parker's a cappella concert, Cassie and Erin find themselves seated together, the tension between them mounting. Unable to resist, they sneak away for a heated make-out session in a bathroom, pushing the limits of their self-control. The encounter is both thrilling and dangerous, as they risk exposure and the wrath of Parker. Afterward, both women are left reeling—Cassie with a sense of triumph and longing, Erin with guilt and exhilaration. The night cements their connection, making it clear that their story is far from over.
Best Friends, Hidden Truths
Cassie confides in her best friend Acacia about her tryst with Erin, seeking advice and absolution. Acacia is shocked but supportive, helping Cassie process her feelings and the potential fallout. The conversation forces Cassie to confront her own patterns of avoidance and her complicated relationship with intimacy. Meanwhile, Erin grapples with her guilt and the fear of damaging her relationship with Parker. Both women are caught between desire and duty, their secret threatening to unravel the fragile balance of their lives.
Drunk Texts and Consequences
Cassie, feeling reckless and lonely, drunk texts Erin a series of explicit messages, leading to a tense and revealing phone call. The incident exposes the depth of Cassie's longing and Erin's conflicted feelings. Both are forced to reckon with the risks of their connection, especially as Parker and Acacia begin to notice changes in Cassie's behavior. The episode serves as a wake-up call, highlighting the dangers of secrecy and the difficulty of maintaining boundaries when emotions run high.
Winter Break, Close Quarters
Parker invites Cassie to spend winter break at her home, bringing Cassie and Erin under the same roof for two weeks. The arrangement is fraught with tension, as both women struggle to maintain appearances while navigating their unresolved feelings. They establish ground rules—no sex while Parker is home, no visible marks—but the rules are quickly tested as their attraction proves impossible to contain. The close quarters force them to confront the reality of their connection and the impossibility of keeping it hidden forever.
Rules, Risks, and Restraint
Cassie and Erin's relationship deepens as they steal moments together, pushing the boundaries of their agreement. Their encounters become more intimate and emotionally charged, blurring the line between casual and committed. Both women are acutely aware of the risks, especially as Parker remains oblivious. The tension between desire and discretion heightens, culminating in a series of passionate encounters that leave both women questioning what they truly want—and what they're willing to risk to have it.
Confessions in the Shower
A stolen moment leads to a passionate encounter in the shower, breaking all the rules they set for themselves. The intimacy of the moment forces both Cassie and Erin to confront their feelings and the reality of their situation. The encounter is a turning point, marking the shift from a purely physical relationship to something deeper. Both women are left vulnerable, their defenses lowered, and the possibility of a real relationship begins to emerge, even as the risks grow ever more apparent.
Summer of Secrets
Cassie lands a prestigious job in Boston, bringing her closer to Erin and further complicating their relationship. They continue to see each other in secret, balancing their desire with the need for discretion. The summer is a whirlwind of stolen weekends, passionate nights, and the constant threat of discovery. Both women are happier than they've been in years, but the secrecy takes its toll, especially as Parker's presence looms large. The illusion of control begins to crack, and the need for honesty becomes impossible to ignore.
Parker's Discovery
The truth comes out in dramatic fashion when Parker's father discovers Cassie and Erin together, forcing a confrontation that can no longer be avoided. Parker reveals that she has known about their relationship for months, having pieced together the clues and confided in Acacia. Rather than reacting with anger, Parker offers a surprising level of understanding and acceptance, recognizing the happiness Cassie and Erin bring each other. The revelation is both a relief and a reckoning, as all parties must come to terms with the new reality.
Forgiveness and Forward Motion
With the secret out, Cassie, Erin, and Parker begin the process of rebuilding trust and redefining their relationships. Honest conversations lead to forgiveness and a renewed sense of connection. Cassie and Erin are finally able to be together openly, their relationship deepening as they navigate the challenges of blending their lives. Parker's acceptance is hard-won but genuine, and the trio finds a new equilibrium. The experience leaves them all changed, more honest, and more willing to fight for what—and who—they love.
Facing Feelings, Facing Fears
Cassie and Erin are forced to confront their deepest fears and insecurities, admitting their love for each other and choosing vulnerability over self-protection. The journey is messy and imperfect, but both women are determined to build a life together, despite the obstacles. They learn to communicate openly, support each other's dreams, and embrace the uncertainty of the future. Their love becomes a source of strength, helping them face whatever challenges come their way.
Choosing Each Other
Cassie and Erin's relationship culminates in a series of joyful milestones—moving in together, celebrating holidays, and building a chosen family with Parker and their friends. Their love story is marked by resilience, laughter, and the willingness to make mistakes and grow together. The couple's commitment is solidified through mutual support and the shared belief that happiness is worth fighting for, even when it means breaking the rules.
Fourth of July Fireworks
Surrounded by friends and family, Cassie and Erin celebrate the Fourth of July, their relationship now an open secret. The holiday becomes a symbol of their journey—messy, joyful, and full of unexpected beauty. The couple's love is affirmed by their community, and the fireworks serve as a metaphor for the passion and excitement they bring to each other's lives. The night is a celebration of love, acceptance, and the power of chosen family.
Epilogue: Scuba Diving Promises
Years later, Cassie and Erin's love story comes full circle as they propose to each other in front of their friends and family. Their journey has been marked by mistakes, forgiveness, and the courage to choose each other again and again. The scuba diving metaphor—facing the unknown together—becomes a promise for the future. Surrounded by love and laughter, Cassie and Erin embrace their happily ever after, knowing that the best adventures are the ones they share.
Analysis
Mistakes Were Made is a bold, heartfelt exploration of love, desire, and the messy process of growing into oneself—at any age. By centering a taboo romance between a college senior and her best friend's mother, the novel challenges conventional boundaries and asks what it means to choose happiness in the face of judgment and risk. The story's emotional arc is driven by secrecy, vulnerability, and the gradual dismantling of self-imposed barriers. Through alternating perspectives, readers witness the protagonists' parallel journeys toward self-acceptance and mutual trust. The novel's humor, banter, and rich supporting cast ground its more sensational elements, making the characters' struggles and triumphs feel authentic and earned. Ultimately, Mistakes Were Made is a celebration of chosen family, the courage to make mistakes, and the transformative power of love that refuses to fit into neat boxes. Its message is clear: happiness is not about following the rules, but about finding the people who make you brave enough to break them—and then choosing them, again and again.
Review Summary
Mistakes Were Made received mixed reviews, with an average rating of 3.92 out of 5. Many readers praised the steamy romance and chemistry between the main characters, Cassie and Erin. The age gap and forbidden romance aspects were generally well-received. Some appreciated the character development and emotional depth, while others found the relationship dynamics uncomfortable or problematic. The book was noted for its high level of sexual content and humor. Criticisms included pacing issues, underdeveloped plot, and concerns about the power dynamics in the relationship.
People Also Read
Characters
Cassie Klein
Cassie is a senior physics major with a sharp wit and a penchant for breaking rules. Scarred by a difficult childhood and a history of abandonment, she relies on her best friend Acacia and her own resilience to navigate life. Cassie's bravado masks a deep vulnerability and a longing for connection, which she finds unexpectedly in Erin. Her journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns to trust, to be vulnerable, and to fight for the love she never thought she deserved. Cassie's relationships—with Acacia, Parker, and ultimately Erin—force her to confront her fears and redefine what it means to belong.
Erin Bennett
Erin is a successful doctor and devoted mother, recently divorced and struggling to balance her own desires with her responsibilities. Haunted by the expectations of her late mother and the fallout of her marriage, Erin is both cautious and deeply passionate. Her encounter with Cassie reignites a sense of adventure and self-worth, challenging her to prioritize her own happiness. Erin's relationship with Parker is central to her identity, and her greatest fear is hurting her daughter. Through her connection with Cassie, Erin learns to embrace imperfection, take risks, and believe she is worthy of love and pleasure.
Parker Bennett
Parker is a freshman in college, navigating the complexities of friendship, family, and first love. Caught between her parents' divorce and her own coming-of-age, Parker is both mature and vulnerable. Her relationships with Cassie and Acacia are lifelines, but she struggles with feelings of betrayal and abandonment when secrets come to light. Parker's journey is one of forgiveness and growth, as she learns to accept change, advocate for herself, and support the happiness of those she loves—even when it challenges her own comfort.
Acacia Webb
Acacia is Cassie's lifelong best friend, a source of unwavering support and honest counsel. She is fiercely protective, quick-witted, and unafraid to call out her friends when they're being foolish. Acacia's loyalty is matched by her pragmatism; she helps Cassie navigate her feelings for Erin and mediates conflicts within the group. Her own relationship with Donovan is stable and loving, providing a contrast to the chaos around her. Acacia embodies the power of chosen family and the importance of having someone who always has your back.
Adam Bennett
Adam is Erin's ex-husband and Parker's father, a figure who represents both stability and the limitations of tradition. He is supportive in his own way but often fails to understand the emotional complexities of those around him. Adam's discovery of Cassie and Erin's relationship serves as a catalyst for truth-telling and growth, forcing all parties to confront their assumptions and priorities.
Rachel
Rachel is Erin's best friend and confidante, unafraid to challenge Erin's choices while offering unconditional support. She provides comic relief and sage advice, encouraging Erin to pursue happiness and reject societal expectations. Rachel's presence is a reminder that friendship can be a source of both accountability and joy.
Gwen
Gwen is a former RA and acquaintance of Cassie's, representing the path not taken. Her interactions with Cassie highlight Cassie's growth and the choices she makes in pursuit of genuine connection. Gwen's confidence and boundaries serve as a foil to Cassie's impulsiveness.
Emerson Webb
Emerson is Acacia's older brother and a steady presence in Cassie's life. He provides comic relief and a sense of family, often acting as the responsible adult in the group's escapades. Emerson's relationship with Cassie is platonic but deeply meaningful, underscoring the importance of chosen family.
Lila, Caleb, Madison, Haylee
These secondary characters populate the world of Keckley College and Nashua, providing context, camaraderie, and occasional drama. Their presence reinforces the themes of community, acceptance, and the messiness of growing up.
Mama Webb and Mr. Ben
Acacia's parents serve as surrogate family for Cassie, offering stability, warmth, and guidance. Their acceptance and support are crucial to Cassie's development and sense of belonging.
Plot Devices
Dual Perspectives and Alternating Narration
The novel alternates between Cassie and Erin's perspectives, allowing readers to experience the story's emotional complexity from both sides. This structure deepens the narrative, highlighting misunderstandings, parallel desires, and the gradual convergence of their journeys. The dual narration also underscores the generational and experiential differences between the characters, enriching the exploration of age, power, and vulnerability.
Secret Relationships and Dramatic Irony
The central plot device is the secret romance between Cassie and Erin, which creates dramatic irony as readers are privy to information other characters lack. The secrecy heightens stakes, fuels misunderstandings, and propels the narrative toward inevitable revelation. The device also serves as a metaphor for the risks and rewards of authenticity, challenging characters to choose honesty over comfort.
Found Family and Chosen Community
The novel foregrounds the importance of chosen family—friends who become lifelines when biological family falls short. Acacia, Parker, and the Webbs provide stability and acceptance, counterbalancing the uncertainty of romantic and familial relationships. This device reinforces the theme that love and belonging are not limited by blood or tradition.
Symbolism: Scuba Diving and Space
Scuba diving and space travel recur as symbols of venturing into the unknown, facing fears, and choosing to leap despite uncertainty. These metaphors encapsulate the emotional journey of the protagonists, who must leave the safety of old patterns to build something new together. The recurring motif of "going scuba diving together" becomes a shorthand for mutual commitment and the willingness to embrace life's mysteries as a team.
Humor and Banter
Witty dialogue, running jokes, and playful teasing provide relief from the story's heavier moments. Humor is used both as a defense mechanism and as a means of connection, allowing characters to navigate awkwardness, express affection, and defuse tension. The banter between Cassie and Erin, as well as among the friend group, grounds the narrative in realism and warmth.
Coming-of-Age and Self-Discovery
Both Cassie and Erin undergo significant transformation, learning to trust themselves, communicate honestly, and prioritize their own happiness. The coming-of-age arc is not limited to the younger characters; Erin's journey is equally about reclaiming agency and redefining her identity post-divorce. The plot device of parallel growth underscores the universality of self-discovery, regardless of age.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
