Key Takeaways
1. Intuition Alone Falls Short in Understanding People
But there are times when we want to consciously evaluate someone’s personality.
Beyond gut feelings. While we all possess an innate ability to form rapid, intuitive impressions of others, this unconscious process often proves insufficient for deeper understanding. Relying solely on instinct can lead to significant misjudgments in crucial relationships, career choices, or parenting decisions. A systematic framework is essential to move beyond superficial assessments and avoid common mistakes.
Lack of a coherent system. The challenge lies in the absence of a structured method for personality assessment in everyday life. We are constantly exposed to a jumble of contradictory ideas from various sources—religious, moral, literary, and psychological—making it difficult to organize our observations coherently. This book aims to provide a "coherent arithmetic of personality" to bridge this gap.
Organizing observations. By learning a systematic approach, we can better organize the vast amount of data we already possess about people and begin to notice characteristics we might have overlooked. This structured thinking enhances our ability to make clearer assessments, understand motivations, and navigate relationships more effectively, whether for protection, connection, or simply appreciation of human diversity.
2. The Big Five Traits Provide a Universal Language for Personality
The words that describe personality traits can be boiled down to just five large domains...
Lexical foundation. The scientific quest to systematically describe personality began by analyzing language itself. Researchers, starting with Gordon Allport, compiled thousands of personality-describing words from dictionaries. Through statistical techniques like factor analysis, these words were grouped into five overarching, enduring dispositions, known as the Big Five.
The OCEAN/CANOE model. These five universal traits, or domains, are:
- Openness to Experience: Imaginative, intellectual, artistic, curious.
- Conscientiousness: Organized, disciplined, dutiful, achievement-oriented.
- Extraversion: Outgoing, assertive, gregarious, excitement-seeking.
- Agreeableness: Cooperative, compassionate, trusting, good-natured.
- Neuroticism: Emotionally unstable, anxious, prone to negative feelings.
Each domain encompasses six more specific "facets" that allow for a nuanced understanding of individual differences.
Practical application. Applying the Big Five framework helps organize intuitive assessments into a clear profile, such as "moderately extraverted, very agreeable and conscientious, a little neurotic, and very open." This structured vocabulary allows for more thoughtful comparisons between individuals, highlighting distinguishing characteristics and providing a foundation for deeper analysis.
3. Troublesome Patterns Reveal Maladaptive Behavioral Tendencies
The reason words such as workaholic and drama queen are so popular is that they’re not just shorthand ways of summing up some notable rankings.
Beyond single traits. While the Big Five describes general tendencies, certain combinations of traits can form "troublesome patterns" that clinicians identify. These "Top Ten" patterns, derived from the DSM-IV, are not rigid categories but rather dimensional expressions of behavior that, in extreme and inflexible forms, can cause significant distress to individuals and those around them.
The Top Ten patterns: These include:
- Antisocial (disregard for others' rights)
- Avoidant (social inhibition, inadequacy)
- Borderline (instability in relationships, self-image, emotions)
- Compulsive (preoccupation with order, perfectionism)
- Dependent (submissive, clinging behavior)
- Histrionic (excessive emotionality, attention-seeking)
- Narcissistic (grandiosity, need for admiration, lack of empathy)
- Paranoid (distrust, suspiciousness)
- Schizoid (detachment from relationships, restricted emotions)
- Schizotypal (discomfort in relationships, cognitive distortions, eccentricities)
These patterns can often be understood as extreme or maladaptive expressions of Big Five facets, such as a histrionic person exhibiting very high Extraversion combined with high impulsivity (Neuroticism) and low self-discipline (Conscientiousness).
Opinions of self and others. Psychiatrist Aaron T. Beck's cognitive therapy approach offers another lens, categorizing these patterns by a person's core beliefs about themselves and others. These include "I'm special" (narcissistic, histrionic, antisocial), "I'm right" (compulsive, paranoid), "I'm vulnerable" (avoidant, dependent, borderline), and "I'm detached" (schizoid, schizotypal). Understanding these underlying thought processes helps clarify why individuals with these patterns behave as they do.
4. Genes Lay the Foundation for Our Unique Personalities
Darwin predicted that our understanding of psychology would one day rely on knowledge of the genetic variations that affect behavior.
Darwin's foresight. Charles Darwin, observing the selective breeding of animals, recognized that inherited characteristics influenced not only physical traits but also behavior. He predicted that psychology would eventually be founded on understanding the genetic variations that shape mental powers and capacities, a revolutionary idea for his time.
Heritability of traits. Francis Galton, Darwin's cousin, pioneered twin studies, demonstrating that identical twins (sharing 100% of genes) exhibit significantly greater behavioral similarities than fraternal twins (sharing 50% of genes), even when raised apart. Modern studies using the Big Five confirm that personality traits are substantially heritable, with approximately 50% of individual differences attributable to genetic factors.
Many genes, small effects. Personality traits are not controlled by a single "personality gene" but by the combined action of thousands of gene variants. Each variant has a tiny effect, accumulating to influence complex traits like excitement-seeking or anxiety. This genetic diversity, maintained through natural selection, reflects evolutionary trade-offs, where both high and low expressions of a trait can offer advantages or disadvantages depending on environmental conditions.
5. Brain Development and Environment Continuously Shape Who We Become
Each brain—like each face—has its own innate building plans.
Personalized brain architecture. While our brains are built from a common human blueprint, each is uniquely sculpted by the interplay of our specific gene variants and individual life experiences. From fetal development through early adulthood, neurons migrate, form connections (synapses), and undergo continuous remodeling, guided by both genetic instructions and environmental signals.
Critical periods and lasting imprints. Brain development involves "critical periods"—windows of time when specific circuits are highly receptive to environmental information, shaping them in lasting ways. Examples include language acquisition in humans or imprinting in geese. Experiences during these periods, particularly in childhood and adolescence, can profoundly influence personality, creating deeply ingrained patterns that are difficult to alter later in life.
Gene-environment dialogues. The relationship between genes and environment is a dynamic, two-way street. Genetic predispositions can influence how individuals react to their environment (e.g., the MAOA gene variant affecting antisocial behavior in abused children). Conversely, environmental experiences, such as maternal care in rats, can lead to "epigenetic changes"—modifications to DNA that alter gene expression and have enduring effects on personality, even in identical twins.
6. Character Defines Our Moral Core and Values
Whenever we speak of character we are likely to imply a moral standard and make a judgment of value.
Character vs. personality. Historically, character was considered the moral aspect of personality, acquired through effort. While scientific psychology, led by Gordon Allport, sought to separate descriptive personality traits from moral judgments, our intuitive assessments of people inherently include a moral dimension. Traits like altruism or modesty, though descriptively part of personality, carry moral weight in common understanding.
Universal virtues. Despite cultural differences, research by Peterson and Seligman identified six "core virtues" universally admired across Eastern and Western traditions:
- Temperance (self-control, prudence)
- Courage (bravery, persistence)
- Humanity (kindness, love)
- Justice (fairness, citizenship)
- Wisdom (open-mindedness, love of learning)
- Transcendence (awe, spirituality)
These universal values, along with Robert Cloninger's categories of self-directedness, cooperativeness, and self-transcendence, provide a framework for evaluating a person's moral strengths.
Moral instincts and emotions. Darwin proposed that moral instincts evolved through natural selection, contributing to our capacity for empathy, gratitude, compassion, and even moralistic anger, contempt, and disgust. These emotions, linked to specific brain circuits, reward altruistic behavior and punish perceived unfairness, serving to maintain cooperation and social order. Our cultural values then provide the specific details and interpretations of these innate moral foundations.
7. Our Identity is Forged Through Personal Stories
To grasp it, we need to learn what makes a person’s life feel unified, purposeful, and meaningful, a view expressed in the form of a self-defining story.
The personal myth. Beyond traits and character, understanding a person requires delving into their "personal story" or "personal myth"—the narrative they construct to define who they are. This self-defining story integrates past experiences, current challenges, and future aspirations, providing a sense of unity, purpose, and meaning to their life.
Erikson's identity challenge. Erik Erikson highlighted adolescence as a critical period for identity formation, where individuals reconcile their abilities, goals, and ideals with social opportunities and expectations. This process, often unconscious, leads to a coherent sense of self. Even in adulthood, individuals may experience "identity crises" as they grapple with life changes, prompting a re-evaluation and reconstruction of their personal narrative.
Selective reconstruction. Our life stories are not mere factual records but imaginative interpretations, often involving "selective reconstruction" of memories to align with our evolving self-image. Figures like Oprah Winfrey and Steve Jobs exemplify this, crafting narratives that highlight resilience, ambition, and purpose, even if some details are reinterpreted. Listening to these stories, and understanding their underlying principles, offers profound insight into a person's motivations and guiding philosophy.
8. A Holistic Approach Integrates Traits, Patterns, Character, and Identity
To put together this big picture, I find it useful to follow the steps discussed in this chapter...
The complete picture. Truly making sense of a person requires integrating all dimensions of personality. Starting with our shared humanity, we then systematically layer on individual differences, moving from broad traits to specific patterns, moral evaluations, and finally, the overarching life story. This methodical appraisal helps to organize observations and intuitions into a coherent, living picture.
Steps for methodical appraisal:
- Common Humanity: Acknowledge shared human genome, brain, childhood, and cultural challenges.
- Big Five Profile: Assess Extraversion, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, Neuroticism, and Openness, noting prominent facets.
- Troublesome Patterns: Identify any of the "Top Ten" patterns, considering their adaptive or maladaptive nature and underlying beliefs about self and others.
- Moral Assessment (Character): Evaluate character strengths and weaknesses using universal virtues (temperance, courage, humanity, justice, wisdom, transcendence) and considering cultural influences.
- Life Story (Identity): Listen to and interpret the person's narrative, understanding their personal myth, guiding principles, and how they make sense of their past and future.
Dynamic understanding. This integrated view allows for a nuanced understanding, recognizing that while traits and patterns are relatively stable, values and life stories can evolve. By building this comprehensive picture, we gain an "organized form of intuition" that enables us to empathize, predict behavior, and engage more effectively with others.
9. Understanding Leads to Better Relationships, Not Just Change
What may, however, change in the process is the way you choose to relate to this person.
Stability and fluidity. While Big Five traits and personality patterns tend to stabilize by young to middle adulthood, other aspects of personality, such as values and identity, can be more fluid. Cultural shifts, significant life events (marriage, divorce, career changes, parenthood), and even psychotherapy can prompt individuals to revise their personal narratives and guiding principles.
Clarifying expectations. The goal of systematically understanding someone is not necessarily to change them, but to clarify your own understanding of their inherent trajectory. By recognizing what is deeply ingrained versus what might be more amenable to change, you can better discern the characteristics you admire, those you find challenging, and how they fit into the person's overall personality structure.
Informed engagement. This deeper understanding empowers you to choose how you relate to the person. It moves beyond spontaneous reactions to a more prepared and intentional engagement, much like Eisenhower's philosophy that "plans are useless, but planning is indispensable." Ultimately, the greatest value lies in the profound pleasure of appreciating the unique diversity and shared humanity of those with whom we share our lives.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Similar Books
