Plot Summary
Gator Park Beginnings
Faith and Kayla, both from the impoverished Gator Park trailer park in Mississippi, forge a fierce, codependent friendship. Their bond is built on shared dreams of escaping their dead-end lives, with Kayla as the charismatic leader and Faith as the loyal sidekick. Faith's mother's suicide and her subsequent move in with her uncle Randy deepen her longing for belonging and reinvention. Kayla's arrival, with her boldness and hunger for more, electrifies Faith's world. Their friendship is cemented by a shared sense of being outsiders, and a mutual promise: they'll get out together, no matter what. This chapter sets the emotional stakes and the dynamic of risk, loyalty, and the intoxicating hope that will drive them both.
The Well Incident
At fourteen, Kayla's hunger for attention and escape leads to a dangerous stunt: filming a parkour video at an abandoned well. Faith, pressured by Kayla, takes the leap and nearly dies when the safety rig fails. Kayla becomes a local hero for "saving" Faith, but the truth is more complicated—Kayla orchestrated the risk, and Faith paid the price. The incident cements their dynamic: Kayla as the instigator, Faith as the one who cleans up the mess. The trauma and betrayal linger, but so does the addictive thrill of their partnership. This near-death experience foreshadows the dangerous lengths they'll go for each other, and the costs of following someone over the edge.
Inventing Hannah Primrose
Disillusioned with their real lives, Faith and Kayla invent "Hannah Primrose," an Instagram persona embodying the Southern, privileged girlhood they crave. Kayla is the face; Faith, the ghostwriter. Their posts—carefully curated, aspirational, and tinged with longing—begin to attract followers. The project is both a creative outlet and a lifeline, offering them a taste of the attention and validation they lack. But the partnership is unequal: Kayla basks in the spotlight, while Faith's contributions remain invisible. The avatar becomes a third entity in their friendship, blurring the lines between reality and performance, and setting the stage for future betrayals.
Viral Fame and Fractures
As Hannah Primrose's following grows, so do the cracks in Faith and Kayla's friendship. Brand deals trickle in, but the rewards are meager compared to their ambitions. Kayla's hunger for fame intensifies, leading her to exploit their young fans and push boundaries Faith finds uncomfortable. Their first major fight erupts over Kayla's willingness to take money from followers, exposing the moral gulf between them. Faith's academic promise and Kayla's resentment simmer beneath the surface, as both girls begin to imagine futures that might not include the other. The intoxicating power of social media becomes both a ladder and a wedge.
Graduation and Goodbyes
Faith, encouraged by her teacher and uncle, secretly applies to Harkness College, a prestigious liberal arts school. She's accepted on a scholarship, fulfilling her mother's abandoned dream. Kayla, feeling betrayed and left behind, lashes out when she learns the truth during a disastrous night in New Orleans. Their friendship shatters—Kayla disappears, and Faith is left to grapple with guilt and relief. The promise to escape together is broken, and both girls are set adrift. The chapter closes on the ache of separation, the cost of ambition, and the realization that reinvention often means leaving someone behind.
Harkness Arrival
Faith arrives at Harkness, overwhelmed by privilege and tradition. Her roommate bails for Harvard, leaving Faith isolated in a single room. She struggles to fit in among wealthy, confident classmates, haunted by imposter syndrome and the weight of her past. The campus is a world apart from Gator Park, filled with rituals, secret codes, and unspoken hierarchies. Faith's loneliness is palpable, and her attempts to connect are awkward and fraught. The absence of Kayla is a constant ache, and the gap between who she is and who she pretends to be widens. The stage is set for new alliances and new dangers.
Alone Among Elites
Faith's outsider status is reinforced by her work-study job in the dining hall, where she observes her peers from the margins. She befriends Regina, another scholarship student, and meets Professor Wyman, a charismatic art historian who takes an interest in her. Faith is drawn to the world of art and conservation, finding solace in the meticulous, behind-the-scenes work. Meanwhile, Kayla's Instagram posts hint at a new life, stoking Faith's envy and longing. The tension between authenticity and performance, belonging and alienation, intensifies as Faith navigates the social minefield of Harkness.
Sorority Games
Faith is drawn into the world of sororities, rushing Alpha Rho and befriending Callie, a wealthy but insecure pledge. The rituals of Greek life—parties, pledging, and social climbing—offer a sense of belonging but come at a steep price. Faith lies about her background to fit in, and struggles to pay dues, ultimately accepting money from Kayla, who reappears with her own agenda. The sorority becomes another stage for performance, where status is earned through conformity and secrets. The cost of fitting in—financial, emotional, and ethical—mounts, and Faith's double life grows more precarious.
Kayla's Return
Kayla shows up at Harkness, reinvented and determined to reclaim her place in Faith's life. She poses as a student, seamlessly infiltrating Faith's world and dazzling her new friends. Their partnership is rekindled, but the old dynamics of control and dependence resurface. Together, they revive Hannah Primrose, pivoting the account to "dark academia" and leveraging the aesthetics of elite college life. Kayla's charisma wins over the campus, while Faith's anxiety about exposure and betrayal grows. The lines between reality and performance blur further, as both girls chase validation and power in a world built on appearances.
Double Lives
Faith and Kayla's scheme grows bolder: Kayla lives in the dorms under Faith's name, using borrowed IDs and stolen clothes. Their Instagram account soars, but the risks multiply. Faith juggles classes, work, and her secret life, while Kayla courts campus fame and dangerous men. The pressure to maintain the façade strains their friendship, and the threat of discovery looms. Faith's relationship with Professor Wyman deepens, adding another layer of secrecy and ethical ambiguity. The girls' ambitions—fame, love, escape—drive them to ever greater acts of deception, setting the stage for inevitable disaster.
Social Media Warfare
The Hannah Primrose account faces its first major backlash after Kayla posts provocative content. Trolls and misogynists flood the comments, and the girls scramble to control the narrative. Kayla's hunger for attention leads her to risky alliances and manipulations, while Faith becomes increasingly uncomfortable with the lies and exploitation. The account's success becomes a double-edged sword, attracting both opportunity and danger. The girls' partnership is tested by jealousy, competition, and the corrosive effects of online fame. The stakes are raised as their secrets threaten to spill into the real world.
The Professor's Secret
Faith's relationship with Professor Wyman turns romantic and sexual, offering her validation and a sense of being seen. Wyman, charming and enigmatic, draws Faith into his world of art, mentorship, and privilege. But the power imbalance is ever-present, and Faith's longing for approval makes her vulnerable. Unbeknownst to her, Wyman is repeating patterns of predation, targeting vulnerable scholarship students. The affair becomes a secret within a secret, and Faith's complicity deepens. The chapter explores the allure and danger of forbidden relationships, and the ways in which power can be both seductive and destructive.
Crossing Lines
Faith and Kayla's partnership reaches a breaking point as they discover Wyman's duplicity—he's been involved with other students, including Faith's friend Avery. Fueled by anger and a sense of injustice, the girls hatch a plan to blackmail Wyman, demanding $100,000 in exchange for their silence. The scheme is both an act of revenge and a desperate bid for agency in a world that exploits young women. The moral lines blur as Faith and Kayla justify their actions, convinced they're reclaiming power. But the plan sets off a chain reaction of consequences that neither can control.
The Art of Deception
The blackmail plot unfolds with mounting tension. Faith and Kayla confront Wyman, who is both shocked and oddly impressed by their audacity. The encounter is fraught with psychological games, shifting power dynamics, and the ever-present threat of exposure. Wyman negotiates, offering half the demanded sum, and Faith seizes the opportunity to sever ties with Kayla, who has become both a partner and a rival. The girls' friendship, once unbreakable, is now poisoned by mistrust and betrayal. The consequences of their actions ripple outward, ensnaring everyone in their orbit.
Blackmail and Betrayal
With the blackmail money in hand, Faith and Kayla's partnership implodes. Their final confrontation is a reckoning years in the making, as old wounds and resentments surface. Kayla, driving recklessly, loses control of the car on a dark, icy road. The crash is violent and final—Faith survives, but Kayla does not. In the aftermath, Faith is forced to construct a narrative that protects herself, implicates Kayla, and shields Wyman. The truth is buried beneath layers of lies, and the cost of survival is the loss of innocence, friendship, and self.
The Crash
The aftermath of the crash is a blur of police interviews, hospital visits, and media scrutiny. Faith crafts a story that casts Kayla as the architect of her own downfall, erasing her own complicity. The school distances itself, and the world moves on. Faith is left to grapple with grief, guilt, and the knowledge that she chose herself over her friend. The crash becomes a defining trauma, shaping her sense of self and her understanding of risk, loyalty, and the price of escape. The chapter is a meditation on survival and the stories we tell to live.
Aftermath and Lies
Faith navigates the fallout: police investigations, campus rumors, and the unraveling of her social world. Wyman, exposed but not destroyed, weathers the scandal by shifting blame onto Kayla. Faith's role as ghostwriter and accomplice remains hidden, but the weight of her actions lingers. The media frenzy turns Kayla into a cautionary tale, a "grifter" rather than a victim. Faith's relationships—with Callie, Avery, and others—fracture under the strain of secrets and betrayal. The chapter explores the elasticity of truth, the malleability of narrative, and the ways in which power protects the powerful.
Truths Unravel
Years later, Faith's story is retold in podcasts, articles, and viral posts. She comes forward, revealing her role in the blackmail and exposing Wyman's pattern of predation. The narrative shifts again: Faith is both villain and victim, activist and opportunist. The women Wyman exploited find solidarity, but the scars remain. Faith reinvents herself as an influencer, leveraging her notoriety into a new kind of power. The story ends with a meditation on legacy, the persistence of ghosts, and the possibility of redemption. The final image is of Faith, forever haunted by Kayla, but determined to claim her own voice.
Seven Years Later
In Florence, Faith is interviewed for a podcast about the case. She reflects on the painting of Judith Slaying Holofernes, the symbolism of female rage, and the stories we tell to survive. The world has moved on, but the questions linger: Could she have saved Kayla? Was she ever truly free of her influence? Faith's confession goes viral, sparking debate and controversy. She embraces her role as both storyteller and subject, acknowledging the complexity of her past and the impossibility of closure. The story ends with Faith, alone but self-possessed, posting to her followers—her life forever shaped by the stories she told, and the ones she lived.
Characters
Faith Thibodeaux
Faith is the novel's narrator and emotional core, a girl marked by loss, longing, and a desperate need to belong. Orphaned young and raised in poverty, she is both fiercely intelligent and deeply insecure. Her friendship with Kayla is the axis of her life—addictive, toxic, and formative. Faith's gift is storytelling: she is the ghostwriter behind Hannah Primrose, the architect of their shared myth. Her journey is one of self-discovery and moral ambiguity, as she navigates the treacherous waters of ambition, love, betrayal, and survival. Faith's greatest strength is her adaptability; her greatest flaw is her willingness to follow, even when it leads to ruin. Over time, she learns to claim her own voice, but not without profound cost.
Kayla Lightfoot
Kayla is Faith's best friend, rival, and mirror—an electrifying presence who craves attention, reinvention, and escape. Raised in instability and neglect, Kayla is both vulnerable and ruthless, using her beauty and charm to bend the world to her will. She is the face of Hannah Primrose, but also its most unreliable narrator, blurring the line between truth and performance. Kayla's hunger for more—fame, love, validation—drives her to dangerous extremes, often at Faith's expense. Her relationship with Faith is both loving and exploitative, a dance of power and dependence. Kayla's tragic flaw is her inability to stop pushing boundaries, and her story ends in self-destruction, leaving a legacy that haunts everyone she touched.
Professor Charles Wyman
Wyman is a celebrated art historian and Faith's lover, embodying both the allure and danger of power. He is brilliant, cultured, and attentive, offering Faith the validation she craves. But beneath the surface, he is a serial predator, targeting vulnerable scholarship students and using his influence to manipulate and exploit. Wyman's relationship with Faith is marked by genuine connection and profound betrayal; he is both a mentor and an abuser. His ability to compartmentalize, rationalize, and shift blame allows him to survive scandal, but at the cost of his integrity and the well-being of those around him. Wyman is a study in the seductive, corrosive effects of unchecked authority.
Callie Baker
Callie is Faith's first real friend at Harkness, a wealthy but anxious sorority pledge who struggles with self-esteem and belonging. She is drawn to Faith's authenticity and to Kayla's charisma, becoming entangled in their web of secrets. Callie's vulnerability makes her both a target and a witness to the darker side of campus life—sexual assault, substance abuse, and the pressures of conformity. Her friendship with Faith is genuine but ultimately limited by Faith's secrecy and self-absorption. Callie's arc is one of survival and quiet resilience, as she seeks healing and justice in a world that often fails to protect girls like her.
Avery Chen
Avery is a fellow scholarship student and member of the art conservation club. She is intelligent, perceptive, and initially overlooked by Faith, who is too absorbed in her own drama to notice Avery's struggles. Avery becomes a key figure in exposing Wyman's predation, connecting with other victims and pushing for accountability. Her relationship with Faith is fraught—marked by missed connections, mutual misunderstanding, and eventual solidarity. Avery represents the possibility of collective action and the importance of seeing beyond one's own pain. Her journey is one of empowerment and self-advocacy.
Regina Campbell
Regina is Faith's supervisor at the dining hall and a fellow scholarship student. She is practical, hardworking, and funny, offering Faith a model of resilience and ambition. Regina's success—eventually becoming a showrunner and SNL cast member—serves as a counterpoint to Faith's more tumultuous path. She is a reminder that survival and reinvention are possible, even in the face of adversity. Regina's presence grounds the narrative, providing both support and perspective.
Andy Burwell
Andy is a prominent Alpha Rho sorority member and campus leader. She embodies the privilege and entitlement of Harkness's elite, but also the anxieties of maintaining status. Andy's interactions with Faith are marked by condescension, pity, and occasional solidarity. She is both a gatekeeper and a bystander, enforcing the rules of the social order while benefiting from its inequities. Andy's arc is one of adaptation, as she leverages her skills into a successful career in politics.
Henry Taylor
Henry is a fraternity president and the embodiment of campus privilege and toxic masculinity. He is implicated in Callie's assault and later becomes a target of Kayla and Callie's blackmail scheme. Henry's response—defensiveness, retaliation, and eventual self-victimization—mirrors the broader culture's tendency to protect powerful men. He leverages his notoriety into social media fame, becoming a right-wing provocateur. Henry's character exposes the limits of justice and the persistence of impunity.
Ginny Spears
Ginny is the president of Alpha Rho, representing the ideal of Southern femininity and social capital. She is both welcoming and exclusionary, embodying the contradictions of Greek life. Ginny's interactions with Faith and Kayla are marked by superficial warmth and underlying suspicion. She is a symbol of the world Faith longs to enter but can never fully belong to. Ginny's arc is one of adaptation, as she transitions from campus royalty to social impact influencer.
Brenda Lightfoot
Brenda is Kayla's mother, a figure of neglect and instability. Her inability to protect or understand Kayla shapes her daughter's hunger for attention and escape. Brenda's grief after Kayla's death is performative and self-serving, highlighting the generational cycles of trauma and abandonment. She becomes a minor social media figure, capitalizing on her daughter's notoriety. Brenda's character underscores the novel's themes of loss, longing, and the search for validation.
Plot Devices
Dual Narratives and Unreliable Storytelling
The novel is structured around dual narratives: the public story (Hannah Primrose, the Instagram persona) and the private reality (Faith and Kayla's friendship, betrayals, and secrets). Faith's role as ghostwriter and narrator blurs the line between truth and fiction, inviting readers to question the reliability of every account. The use of social media as both a plot device and a metaphor for self-invention allows the story to explore the ways in which identity is constructed, commodified, and weaponized. Foreshadowing is woven through recurring motifs—wells, water, art, and performance—signaling impending danger and the cyclical nature of risk and reinvention. The narrative is punctuated by confessions, viral posts, and retrospective analysis, creating a layered, self-reflexive structure that mirrors the characters' psychological complexity.
Analysis
I'll Follow You is a razor-sharp exploration of female friendship, social media, and the ways in which young women are shaped—and warped—by the forces of class, gender, and technology. At its core, the novel interrogates the allure and danger of self-invention: the seductive promise that we can escape our origins, rewrite our stories, and become someone new. But every act of reinvention comes at a cost—betrayal, loss, and the erasure of self. The book is also a searing indictment of the systems that exploit and discard girls: predatory men, elite institutions, and the relentless churn of online attention. Through Faith and Kayla's story, Wang exposes the thin line between victim and perpetrator, performance and reality, love and manipulation. The novel's final act—Faith's viral confession and the reckoning that follows—offers no easy answers, only the hard-won insight that survival requires both complicity and courage. In the end, I'll Follow You is a haunting meditation on the stories we tell to survive, and the ghosts we carry with us, long after the credits roll.
Last updated:
