Plot Summary
Beach, Bucket List, Rescue
Paisley Donovan, haunted by her sister's death and her own heart condition, is determined to live fiercely, checking off items from her secret bucket list. At a Florida beach, she's thrown into the ocean by a drunken acquaintance, unable to swim, and nearly drowns. Jagger Bateman, a brash, tattooed flight school student, dives in and saves her, sparking an instant, electric connection. Their brief, charged encounter leaves Paisley breathless in more ways than one, but she's tethered to a careful life by her parents and her steady boyfriend, Will. Jagger, meanwhile, is drawn to Paisley's vulnerability and fire, even as he battles his own demons and ambitions. This moment marks the collision of two lives desperate to break free.
Flight School Rivalries Ignite
Back at Fort Rucker, Jagger and Will are both lieutenants in the Army's elite flight school, vying for top spots and the coveted Apache helicopter slots. Will, Paisley's boyfriend and her late sister's best friend, is the golden boy—honorable, rule-bound, and favored by Paisley's family. Jagger, rebellious and fiercely independent, quickly becomes Will's rival, both in the air and for Paisley's attention. The competitive, high-pressure environment breeds camaraderie and conflict, with pranks, punishments, and the ever-present threat of failure. As Jagger and Paisley's paths cross again, the stakes rise—not just for their careers, but for their hearts.
Family Expectations and Secrets
Paisley's life is tightly controlled by her parents, still grieving her sister Peyton's sudden death from a hidden heart condition. They treat Paisley as fragile, pushing her toward a pacemaker surgery she dreads. Her mother, especially, cannot let go of the past, calling Paisley by her sister's nickname and projecting her fears onto her remaining daughter. Paisley's struggle for autonomy is complicated by guilt, love, and the weight of family secrets. Meanwhile, Jagger's own family history is fraught—his mother's tragic death, his estrangement from his powerful, manipulative father, and the burden of caring for his troubled twin sister, Anna. Both Paisley and Jagger are shaped by the expectations and wounds of their families, seeking freedom and identity.
Library Encounters, Unspoken Tension
Fate throws Paisley and Jagger together again at the base library, where Jagger is assigned to help with renovations as punishment for a prank. Their chemistry is undeniable, but Paisley is loyal to Will and terrified of risking her heart. Jagger, for all his bravado, is captivated by Paisley's strength and vulnerability. Their friendship grows through banter, shared secrets, and late-night swimming lessons—Jagger teaching Paisley to swim, both literally and emotionally. The library becomes a sanctuary for their growing connection, a place where they can be themselves, away from the expectations and judgments of others.
Lessons in Trust and Water
Jagger's swimming lessons become a metaphor for Paisley's journey—learning to let go, to trust, to live despite fear. As they spend more time together, their emotional intimacy deepens, blurring the lines between friendship and something more. Paisley is torn between her loyalty to Will, her parents' expectations, and her own longing for freedom and passion. Jagger, haunted by his past and afraid of failure, finds himself wanting to be worthy of Paisley's trust. Their connection is tested by secrets, misunderstandings, and the ever-present threat of Paisley's fragile heart.
Hearts, Fears, and Friendships
The web of relationships tightens as Paisley's health worsens and her secret bucket list becomes a source of both hope and danger. Will's jealousy and sense of betrayal grow as he realizes Paisley's feelings for Jagger. Jagger's loyalty to his friends and his sister Anna is tested by his growing love for Paisley and the demands of flight school. The trio—Paisley, Will, and Jagger—are caught in a storm of ambition, love, and fear, each forced to confront what they truly want and what they're willing to risk.
Pranks, Punishments, and Polar Bears
A class prank—moving a massive polar bear statue—lands Jagger and his friends in hot water with the commanding general, who happens to be Paisley's father. The fallout exposes the cracks in the flight school brotherhood, as Will is forced to choose between loyalty and honor, and Jagger takes the fall for his friends. The incident brings simmering tensions to a boil, forcing Paisley to confront her feelings for both men and the cost of living by others' rules. The polar bear becomes a symbol of rebellion, loyalty, and the price of standing out.
Kisses, Confessions, Consequences
The tension between Paisley and Jagger finally explodes in a passionate, forbidden kiss, shattering the fragile balance of their lives. The fallout is immediate and painful—betrayal, guilt, and heartbreak for all involved. Paisley is forced to choose between safety and passion, between the life she's always known and the one she desperately wants. Jagger, reeling from rejection and his own sense of unworthiness, must confront his deepest fears and the consequences of his actions. The kiss is both a beginning and an end, a catalyst for transformation.
Breaking Points and Betrayals
The aftermath of Paisley and Jagger's kiss ripples through their world—Will's heartbreak, Paisley's guilt, and Jagger's self-doubt. Family secrets come to light, including the truth about Jagger's parentage and his sister's struggles. Paisley's health deteriorates, forcing her to confront the reality of her condition and the limits of her time. The characters are pushed to their breaking points, forced to make impossible choices about love, loyalty, and the future. Betrayals—real and perceived—threaten to destroy everything they've built.
Choices, Surgery, and Sacrifice
Paisley's heart condition reaches a crisis, and she must choose between a risky surgery and a pacemaker—a choice between truly living and merely surviving. Jagger, facing his own crossroads in flight school and family, must decide what he's willing to sacrifice for love. Both are forced to confront their deepest fears and desires, realizing that love is not about safety, but about risking everything. The surgery becomes a crucible, burning away illusions and forging a new understanding of what it means to be alive.
Healing, Hope, and Homecoming
Paisley survives her surgery, scarred but stronger, and Jagger is by her side, having chosen love over ambition. The couple reconciles, their love deepened by hardship and honesty. Family wounds begin to heal, as Paisley's parents learn to let go and Jagger finds acceptance and belonging. Will, too, finds his own path, letting go of the past and embracing the future. The characters emerge from the crucible transformed, ready to build a life together on their own terms.
Love's Leap, Life's Flight
With Paisley's health restored and Jagger's future as a pilot secured, the couple takes a literal and metaphorical leap—bungee jumping, swimming in the ocean, and finally, a proposal on the beach where it all began. Surrounded by friends and family, they choose each other, not in spite of their scars and fears, but because of them. Their love is fierce, free, and hard-won—a testament to the power of risk, honesty, and living with eyes turned skyward.
Epilogue: Fierce, Free, Forever
Paisley visits her sister's grave, reflecting on the journey that brought her here—through grief, fear, and love. She leaves behind her bucket list and her watch, choosing to live for herself, not for the past. Jagger joins her, and together they return to the beach, where Paisley finally swims in the ocean, free and unafraid. Jagger proposes, and Paisley says yes, their future wide open. Their story is one of survival, transformation, and the courage to love fiercely, forever.
Characters
Paisley Donovan
Paisley is a young woman living under the shadow of her sister Peyton's death from a hidden heart condition, and the suffocating expectations of her grieving parents. Diagnosed with the same condition, Paisley is determined to live fully, creating a secret bucket list of daring experiences. She is torn between her loyalty to her family and boyfriend Will, and her longing for autonomy, passion, and meaning. Paisley's journey is one of self-discovery—learning to trust, to risk, and to choose her own path, even when it means breaking hearts, including her own. Her relationship with Jagger awakens her to the possibility of love that is both wild and safe, teaching her that true living means embracing both fear and joy. Through pain, betrayal, and healing, Paisley emerges as a woman who is not just surviving, but fiercely, unapologetically alive.
Jagger Bateman (Prescott Mansfield)
Jagger is a brilliant, rebellious flight school student, covered in tattoos and haunted by a tragic past. Estranged from his powerful, manipulative father—a U.S. senator—and scarred by his mother's death and his twin sister Anna's addiction, Jagger has built walls of bravado and independence. He is fiercely loyal to his friends, but terrified of failure and intimacy. Meeting Paisley cracks open his defenses, awakening a longing for connection and belonging. Jagger's journey is one of vulnerability—learning to trust, to love, and to let himself be loved. His rivalry with Will, his struggles in flight school, and his devotion to Anna all test his limits, but it is Paisley who teaches him that true strength lies in risking everything for love. Jagger's transformation is from a man running from his past to one who chooses his own future, with eyes—and heart—turned skyward.
Will Carter
Will is Paisley's boyfriend and her late sister's best friend, the golden boy of flight school—disciplined, moral, and deeply loyal. He is the embodiment of safety and tradition, favored by Paisley's family and respected by his peers. Will's love for Paisley is genuine, but rooted in the past and shaped by grief. His rivalry with Jagger exposes his insecurities and the limits of his self-sacrifice. Will's journey is one of letting go—of Peyton, of Paisley, and of the need to be perfect. He ultimately chooses honor over ambition, sacrificing his own dreams for those he loves, and finding peace in acceptance and friendship.
Peyton Donovan
Peyton's death is the catalyst for the entire story, her absence shaping Paisley's life and choices. Larger than life, wild, and fearless, Peyton is both a source of inspiration and a burden for Paisley, who struggles to step out of her shadow. Peyton's secret—her knowledge of her own heart condition and her decision to live fully despite it—becomes a mirror for Paisley's own journey. In death, Peyton teaches Paisley the value of risk, honesty, and living for oneself.
Anna Mansfield
Anna is Jagger's twin sister, battling addiction and the fallout of their dysfunctional family. Her struggles are a constant source of pain and responsibility for Jagger, who repeatedly rescues her at great personal cost. Anna represents the limits of love and the impossibility of saving someone who doesn't want to be saved. Her presence forces Jagger to confront his own boundaries, guilt, and the need to choose his own life.
Magnolia and Richard Donovan (Paisley's Parents)
Paisley's parents are defined by their loss of Peyton, their fear for Paisley, and their inability to let go. Magnolia, especially, projects her grief onto Paisley, calling her by her sister's name and pushing for safety at all costs. Richard, though more supportive, is still bound by tradition and expectation. Their journey is one of learning to release control, to trust, and to love Paisley for who she is, not who they lost.
Josh Walker and Grayson Masters
Jagger's flight school roommates and closest friends, Josh and Grayson provide comic relief, support, and a mirror for Jagger's own struggles. Josh, with his own family burdens, understands Jagger's loyalty and pain, while Grayson's quiet strength and mysterious past offer stability. Both men are tested by the pressures of flight school, the fallout of pranks, and the demands of friendship, ultimately choosing loyalty and honor over ambition.
Morgan Bartley
Morgan is Paisley's lifelong friend, fiercely protective and unafraid to speak hard truths. She provides comic relief, emotional support, and a counterpoint to Paisley's fears. Morgan's own unrequited love for Will and her encouragement of Paisley's relationship with Jagger highlight the complexities of friendship, loyalty, and desire.
Senator Johnathon Mansfield
Jagger's estranged father is a U.S. senator, manipulative, ambitious, and emotionally distant. His actions—covering up family secrets, abandoning Anna, and interfering in Jagger's life—are the source of much of Jagger's pain and rebellion. The senator represents the dangers of power without love, and the necessity of choosing one's own path.
Dr. Larondy
Paisley's cardiologist, Dr. Larondy, is a steady, compassionate presence, guiding her through the maze of medical decisions. He respects Paisley's autonomy, supports her choices, and provides a counterpoint to her family's fear and control.
Plot Devices
Bucket List as Life's Compass
Paisley's bucket list is the central plot device, symbolizing her desire to live fully in the face of death. Each item—some wild, some mundane—serves as a catalyst for action, risk, and transformation. The list brings Paisley and Jagger together, challenges their fears, and ultimately forces them to confront what truly matters. The revelation that Paisley is finishing her sister's list, not her own, becomes a turning point, forcing her to choose life for herself, not for the dead. The list is both a map and a mirror, reflecting the characters' deepest desires and fears.
Dual Narration and Alternating Perspectives
The story alternates between Paisley and Jagger's perspectives, allowing readers to experience their inner worlds, secrets, and transformations. This structure creates dramatic irony, as readers know more than the characters, and heightens the emotional stakes. The dual narration also allows for exploration of gendered experiences of grief, ambition, and love.
Symbolism of Water and Flight
Water—beaches, swimming, drowning—recurs as a symbol of fear, risk, and rebirth. Jagger's role as Paisley's lifeguard is both literal and metaphorical, representing the possibility of rescue and the danger of surrender. Flight—helicopters, skydiving, bungee jumping—symbolizes ambition, escape, and the courage to rise above fear. Both motifs are woven throughout the narrative, reinforcing the themes of risk, transformation, and the search for freedom.
Foreshadowing and Parallelism
The opening rescue foreshadows Paisley's later medical crisis and Jagger's role in saving her. The rivalry between Jagger and Will anticipates the emotional and ethical choices they must make. The repetition of key phrases ("the best things are worth the burn," "eyes turned skyward") creates a sense of destiny and inevitability, while the parallel journeys of Paisley and Jagger—both seeking autonomy from family and the past—underscore the story's central message.
Family Secrets and Revelations
The gradual revelation of family secrets—Peyton's knowledge of her condition, Jagger's true identity, Anna's struggles—creates suspense and emotional depth. These secrets force the characters to confront the limits of love, the dangers of silence, and the necessity of honesty. The climactic confrontations and confessions are both devastating and liberating, clearing the way for healing and new beginnings.
Analysis
Rebecca Yarros's Eyes Turned Skyward is a powerful exploration of what it means to truly live in the shadow of death, grief, and expectation. At its core, the novel is about risk—the risk of loving, of letting go, of choosing one's own path in the face of fear and loss. Through the intertwined journeys of Paisley and Jagger, Yarros examines the ways we are shaped by family, trauma, and the stories we tell ourselves. The bucket list, both literal and symbolic, becomes a map for transformation, challenging the characters to move beyond survival and embrace fierce, unapologetic living. The novel's modern relevance lies in its honest portrayal of chronic illness, mental health, and the pressures of perfection, as well as its celebration of chosen family, vulnerability, and the courage to love. The lessons are clear: life is too short to play it safe; love is worth the burn; and freedom comes not from escaping fear, but from facing it with open eyes and an open heart. In the end, Eyes Turned Skyward is a testament to the power of second chances, the necessity of self-acceptance, and the enduring hope that, even in the face of loss, we can choose to live—and love—fiercely.
Last updated:
