Plot Summary
Early Morning Escape Plan
Agatha, a once-successful novelist, wakes before dawn, meticulously planning her escape from her stifling domestic life and her husband, Teddy. She's set to take the 6:40 train from Toronto to Montreal—a gift from Teddy meant as a writer's retreat, but for Agatha, it's a lifeline. Every movement is calculated to avoid waking Teddy or their son, Freddie. The house, bought with her book's success, feels more like a prison than a home. Agatha's internal monologue reveals her dissatisfaction with her marriage, her career, and her own body after a cancer diagnosis. The morning is thick with tension, regret, and the ache of unspoken resentments, setting the stage for a journey that is as much about escape as it is about self-confrontation.
Mud, Marriage, and Motives
Teddy's unexpected appearance disrupts Agatha's silent exit, forcing a ritual of goodbyes and "I love yous" that feel both necessary and suffocating. The mud he's tracked in becomes a symbol of their unresolved issues—his obliviousness, her simmering anger, and the way small irritations mask deeper wounds. Their exchange is loaded with subtext: Teddy's gift of the train ticket is both supportive and patronizing, a reminder of Agatha's stalled ambitions. The scene is a microcosm of their marriage—intimate, habitual, and quietly adversarial. Agatha's internal rules about farewells, born from her own brush with mortality, underscore the fragility of their family and the weight of what she's planning to do.
Boarding: Strangers and Stories
On the train, Agatha is surrounded by a cast of strangers: the competent attendant Dorcas, a mother-son pair (Vivien and Rupinder), and the abrasive businessman Finch. Each passenger is sketched with sharp, observational detail, their quirks and tensions immediately apparent. Agatha's writer's eye can't help but invent stories for them, even as she struggles to write her own. The train's business-class car is both a cocoon and a pressure cooker, its enforced proximity amplifying every personality. The storm outside mirrors the emotional turbulence within. Agatha's sense of purpose is undermined by creative paralysis, and the train's slow departure feels like the beginning of a journey into the unknown—both literal and psychological.
The Window Seat Dispute
Finch, entitled and oblivious, demands Agatha's window seat, setting off a battle of wills that exposes class, gender, and generational divides. Agatha's refusal is a small but significant act of self-assertion, a stand against the men who have always expected her to yield. The exchange is laced with unspoken threats and mutual disdain, but also a strange, grudging respect. Finch's presence is both a distraction and a catalyst, forcing Agatha to confront her own boundaries. The train's movement into the blizzard outside is echoed by the emotional storm brewing within the car. The power dynamics established here will reverberate throughout the journey, as alliances shift and secrets surface.
The Writer's Blocked Journey
Agatha's attempts to write are thwarted by anxiety, self-doubt, and the blank page. Her past success haunts her, and the pressure to produce another bestseller is paralyzing. The train's unreliable Wi-Fi becomes a metaphor for her disconnectedness—from her work, her family, and herself. Messages from Teddy and her friend Malee are both lifelines and reminders of what she's running from. The presence of her own book at the station newsstand is a cruel irony, a symbol of how far she's fallen from the woman on the back cover. Agatha's internal monologue is raw, honest, and laced with dark humor, capturing the existential dread of a writer who fears she has nothing left to say.
The Storm and the Red Car
As the train speeds through the blizzard, Agatha witnesses a horrific accident: a red car, full of a family, collides with a deer and flips, blood spraying across the snow. The moment is surreal, a flash of violence that shatters the monotony of the journey and leaves Agatha shaken. No one else seems to notice or care, and the event becomes a private trauma, a symbol of the randomness and brutality of fate. The accident is a turning point, heightening the sense of danger and vulnerability. It also foreshadows the violence to come, both on the train and within Agatha's own psyche.
The Ghost from the Past
Agatha is stunned to discover Cyanne, a former friend turned online antagonist, is on the train. Cyanne's presence is no coincidence—she blames Agatha for stealing her life and turning it into a bestselling novel. Their confrontation is electric, full of accusation, denial, and unresolved history. Cyanne's rage is both justified and unhinged, a mirror for Agatha's own guilt and self-loathing. The train car becomes a crucible, the past and present colliding in a space from which neither woman can escape. The threat Cyanne poses is both physical and existential, forcing Agatha to reckon with the consequences of her art and her ambition.
Cyanne's Confrontation
Cyanne's accusations escalate, her grip on Agatha's wrist a physical manifestation of the psychological hold she has. The argument exposes the blurred line between inspiration and theft, the ethics of turning real people into fiction. Cyanne's sense of betrayal is visceral, her pain raw and performative. Agatha's attempts to reason with her are futile; the wounds are too deep, the stakes too personal. The other passengers become uneasy witnesses, their own anxieties feeding into the growing sense of chaos. The confrontation is interrupted by a sudden, violent stop—the train lurches, bodies collide, and the fragile order of the car is shattered.
The Spider's Bite
After the jolt, Finch is found dead in his seat, his thumb blackened and blistered. Panic ripples through the car as the cause is revealed: a deadly Australian funnel-web spider, planted in a mesh bag on the seat. The realization that this was no accident—that someone on the train is a murderer—upends everything. Suspicion falls on everyone, alliances fracture, and the atmosphere turns poisonous. Agatha, who had switched seats with Finch, is forced to confront the possibility that she was the intended target. The spider's bite is both literal and symbolic, a manifestation of the venom that has been building among the passengers.
Panic, Blame, and Blood
As the train remains stranded, tensions escalate. Rupinder, the diabetic son, suffers a medical crisis—his insulin is running out, and help is nowhere in sight. Vivien's desperation turns to rage, and when Dorcas, the attendant, is accused of lying about the phone and withholding help, Vivien snaps. In a moment of panic and self-defense, she stabs Dorcas with a broken bottle, killing her. The car is now a crime scene, the boundaries between victim and perpetrator blurred. Agatha and Cyanne are forced to cover up the truth to protect Vivien, moving Dorcas's body and concocting a story for the authorities. The moral center of the group collapses, replaced by a primal will to survive.
The Locked Car and the Lie
With two bodies and a dying boy, the remaining passengers are trapped in a web of lies and necessity. Agatha and Cyanne, once adversaries, become reluctant co-conspirators, united by the need to protect Vivien and themselves. The discovery of a discarded train uniform in the snow suggests the real killer—possibly the missing trainee—has escaped, but the evidence is ambiguous. The group's collective guilt and fear are palpable, each person haunted by what they've done or failed to do. The storm outside is matched by the storm within, as the survivors grapple with the cost of their choices and the uncertainty of rescue.
The Mother's Desperation
Vivien, pushed to the edge by her son's deteriorating condition, attempts to break out of the train, convinced that only direct action can save him. Agatha, moved by empathy and her own maternal fears, tries to help, but the physical and psychological barriers are immense. The group finally smashes a window to create an escape route, braving the blizzard in search of help. The act is both a literal and symbolic shattering of the constraints that have bound them. The outside world, once a source of hope, is revealed to be just as hostile and indifferent as the train itself.
The Shattering of Order
Jeff, the gentle giant, volunteers to trek through the snow to find help, leaving the others behind. His departure is both heroic and tragic, a sacrifice that underscores the randomness of fate. As the train's power returns and it lurches back to life, Jeff is left stranded in the blizzard, his fate uncertain. The survivors are forced to confront the consequences of their actions—the lies they've told, the lives they've taken, and the bonds they've formed. The restoration of order is bittersweet, marked by loss, guilt, and the knowledge that nothing will ever be the same.
The Window to Survival
With the train moving again and rescue imminent, Agatha and Cyanne orchestrate a cover story to protect Vivien and themselves. The truth of what happened—the murders, the betrayals, the failures—is buried beneath a narrative of self-defense and survival. The authorities, overwhelmed by the chaos of the storm, accept the story at face value. The group's complicity is sealed, their fates intertwined by shared secrets. Agatha, ever the writer, is both relieved and haunted by the power of narrative to shape reality. The line between fiction and truth is irrevocably blurred.
The Traitor in the Snow
As Agatha processes the aftermath, she uncovers evidence that Teddy, her husband, may have been on the train in disguise, possibly orchestrating the murder that nearly claimed her life. The realization is both devastating and liberating, forcing Agatha to confront the depths of betrayal and the limits of forgiveness. The matchbook from Teddy's restaurant, the worn-down heel of a boot, and the pattern of events all point to a conspiracy that is both intimate and unfathomable. Agatha's sense of self is shaken, but she is also awakened to the possibility of reclaiming her life and her art.
The Final Lie
Agatha and Cyanne are questioned by the police, their stories carefully aligned to protect themselves and Vivien. The detective, weary and distracted, is easily convinced by their narrative. The real killer—the missing trainee, or perhaps Teddy—remains at large, the truth obscured by layers of deception. Agatha's skill as a storyteller becomes her salvation, but also her burden. The cost of survival is the loss of innocence, the acceptance of moral ambiguity, and the knowledge that justice is a matter of perspective. The train journey ends, but the journey toward self-understanding continues.
Aftermath and Reckoning
Agatha returns home to Teddy and Freddie, forever changed by what she has endured and what she has done. The reunion is fraught with unspoken questions and unresolved tensions. Agatha's relationship with Teddy is both shattered and renewed, their intimacy rekindled by shared trauma and mutual need. The truth of what happened on the train is left unspoken, a secret that binds them as tightly as any vow. Agatha's sense of self is fractured but resilient, her capacity for love and creativity restored by the ordeal. The cost of survival is high, but the possibility of redemption remains.
Homecoming and Truths
In the days that follow, Agatha begins to write again, channeling her pain and experience into a new novel. The act of creation is both cathartic and redemptive, a way to make sense of the chaos and reclaim agency over her life. The boundaries between fiction and reality remain porous, but Agatha embraces the ambiguity, finding meaning in the act of storytelling itself. Her relationship with Teddy is transformed, marked by honesty, vulnerability, and a renewed commitment to living fully in the face of mortality. The journey ends not with answers, but with the courage to keep asking questions.
Characters
Agatha St. John
Agatha is a once-successful novelist whose life has unraveled after a cancer diagnosis, creative paralysis, and a marriage strained by resentment and unspoken fears. Her relationship with Teddy is complex—marked by love, disappointment, and mutual dependence. Agatha's psyche is a battleground of guilt, ambition, and self-doubt; she is both victim and perpetrator, capable of empathy and cruelty. Her journey on the train is a crucible, forcing her to confront the consequences of her art, the limits of her morality, and the possibility of redemption. Agatha's development is marked by increasing self-awareness, a willingness to embrace ambiguity, and a hard-won acceptance of her own flaws and desires.
Teddy
Teddy is Agatha's husband, a restaurateur whose outward devotion masks deeper insecurities and possible duplicity. His gift of the train ticket is both an act of love and a subtle assertion of control. Teddy's relationship with Agatha is fraught with unspoken grievances, small betrayals, and the weight of shared history. The revelation that he may have been on the train in disguise, orchestrating events from the shadows, recasts him as both protector and potential threat. Teddy's psychology is defined by denial, pride, and a desperate need to preserve his family, even at great moral cost. His development is ambiguous, leaving readers to question the nature of love, loyalty, and complicity.
Cyanne Candel
Cyanne is a former friend of Agatha's, now her most vocal critic and would-be nemesis. She believes Agatha stole her life for a novel, and her sense of betrayal is all-consuming. Cyanne is both victim and aggressor, her pain real but her actions increasingly unhinged. Her presence on the train is a catalyst for chaos, forcing Agatha to confront the ethical boundaries of art and friendship. Cyanne's psychology is shaped by envy, insecurity, and a desperate need for validation. Over the course of the journey, she oscillates between vulnerability and rage, ultimately becoming a reluctant ally in the cover-up. Her development is a study in the corrosive power of resentment and the possibility of uneasy reconciliation.
Finch Weatherby
Finch is a wealthy, abrasive passenger whose sense of entitlement and disregard for others make him both a target and a red herring. His demand for Agatha's seat sets off a chain of events that culminates in his death by spider bite—a murder that is both random and symbolic. Finch's psychology is defined by arrogance, denial, and a brittle sense of superiority. His backstory, revealed through a bitter divorce and a self-inflicted injury, adds layers of pathos and irony. Finch's role as a victim is complicated by his own actions, and his death serves as a catalyst for the unraveling of order on the train.
Dorcas
Dorcas is the train's business-class attendant, a paragon of competence and order whose authority is both comforting and oppressive. Her attempts to maintain control in the face of chaos are ultimately her undoing. Accused of lying and withholding help, Dorcas becomes the focus of the group's collective fear and rage, culminating in her murder by Vivien. Dorcas's psychology is shaped by duty, pride, and a deep need to be useful. Her death is both a tragedy and a turning point, exposing the fragility of social order and the ease with which the innocent can become scapegoats.
Vivien
Vivien is a mother traveling with her diabetic son, Rupinder. Her identity is defined by care, sacrifice, and a fierce protectiveness that borders on martyrdom. As Rupinder's condition deteriorates, Vivien's composure unravels, and her desperation leads her to violence. Her murder of Dorcas is both an act of self-defense and a tragic mistake, a moment of madness born from love and fear. Vivien's psychology is marked by guilt, denial, and a relentless drive to save her child at any cost. Her development is a study in the limits of endurance and the moral ambiguity of survival.
Rupinder
Rupinder is Vivien's nineteen-year-old son, a university student with diabetes whose medical emergency becomes the central crisis of the narrative. His vulnerability exposes the inadequacy of the adults around him and the fragility of life in the face of systemic failure. Rupinder's psychology is shaped by a desire for independence, embarrassment at his condition, and a deep, if unspoken, love for his mother. His seizures and near-death experience force the group to confront their own helplessness and the limits of their compassion. Rupinder's fate is a barometer for the group's morality and cohesion.
Jeff (Jeffrey Valentine)
Jeff is an imposing, kind-hearted passenger whose physical strength and emotional intelligence make him both protector and outsider. His willingness to help, even at great personal risk, marks him as a moral center in a world gone mad. The revelation that he is a famous writer adds irony and depth to his character, highlighting the gap between appearance and reality. Jeff's psychology is defined by empathy, humility, and a quiet sense of purpose. His disappearance into the snow is both a loss and a release, a final act of self-sacrifice that underscores the randomness of fate.
The Trainee
The trainee is a shadowy figure whose disappearance coincides with the murder, making him the prime suspect in the eyes of the survivors. His identity is ambiguous—possibly a vagrant, a hit man, or a real employee gone rogue. The discovery of his discarded uniform in the snow adds to the mystery, but his true motives remain obscure. The trainee's psychology is unknowable, a blank space onto which the fears and suspicions of the group are projected. His role is to embody the threat of the unknown, the danger that lurks just beyond the boundaries of the familiar.
Malee
Malee is Agatha's old friend in Montreal, a minor but significant presence who represents the life Agatha might have had—stable, supportive, and unremarkable. Her messages are a lifeline, a reminder of connection and possibility. Malee's psychology is shaped by resilience, humor, and a capacity for forgiveness. She serves as a foil to the chaos of the train, a touchstone for Agatha's better self.
Plot Devices
Locked-Room Mystery on a Moving Train
The novel uses the classic locked-room mystery structure, trapping a diverse group of characters in a confined space—a business-class train car—during a snowstorm. The physical isolation is mirrored by psychological isolation, as each character is forced to confront their own secrets, fears, and desires. The storm outside is both a literal and metaphorical barrier, heightening the sense of claustrophobia and urgency. The narrative unfolds in real time, with each chapter marking the relentless passage of hours. Foreshadowing is deftly employed: the mud in the hallway, the spider, the missing insulin, and the locked doors all serve as harbingers of disaster. The use of multiple red herrings, shifting points of suspicion, and unreliable narrators keeps the reader—and the characters—off balance. The ultimate revelation that the true threat may have come from within Agatha's own home (Teddy) adds a final twist, blurring the line between victim and perpetrator, fiction and reality.
Analysis
Eva Jurczyk's 6:40 to Montreal is a masterful exploration of the intersection between art, ethics, and survival, set against the backdrop of a snowbound train journey that becomes a crucible for its characters' deepest fears and desires. The novel interrogates the boundaries between fiction and reality, inspiration and theft, self-preservation and complicity. Through Agatha's journey, Jurczyk examines the cost of ambition, the corrosive power of resentment, and the redemptive potential of storytelling. The locked-room structure amplifies the psychological tension, forcing characters into acts of violence, betrayal, and unexpected solidarity. The narrative's refusal to offer easy answers—about guilt, justice, or redemption—mirrors the messiness of real life, where survival often depends on the stories we tell ourselves and each other. In the end, 6:40 to Montreal is less a whodunit than a meditation on the ways we are all both authors and characters in the unfolding drama of our lives, forever haunted by the ghosts of what we have done and what we have left unsaid.
Last updated:
