Plot Summary
The Wrong Schedule
Kiana Roubini2 arrives at Greenwich Middle School on the first day with her stepmother,14 who rushes off with the baby before registering her. While waiting, she is nearly run over by a rusty pickup driven by Parker Elias,3 a farm boy with a provisional license. In the chaos, his schedule gets mixed into her scattered belongings.
Tired of the office, she follows the schedule to room 117, an isolated classroom. She pushes open the door to find a fire roaring in a wastebasket and students roasting marshmallows over it. The smoke, the chaos, and the unnervingly indifferent teacher1 confirm she has accidentally walked into the 'Unteachables' class, the school's dumping ground for misfits.
Kiana's accidental entry introduces the story's central theme: the power of mistaken identity. She isn't supposed to be there, but her presence will catalyze transformation. The trash can fire is a literal and figurative signal of the class's volatility and the school's neglect. This opening establishes the setting as a place where rules are broken and expectations are nonexistent, setting the stage for a narrative that questions what 'unteachable' really means.
The Poison Assignment
Mr. Kermit,1 55, has been counting days to early retirement, bitter since a cheating scandal 27 years ago derailed his career. Superintendent Thaddeus,9 still holding a grudge, assigns him to SCS-8, the self-contained special class of notorious problem students. Thaddeus9's goal is to make Kermit1 quit in despair before he can collect his pension.
Kermit1 recognizes the trap but resolves to endure, vowing to outlast Thaddeus.9 On his first day in room 117, he pours his giant mug of coffee over the bonfire, killing it without comment, and surveys the chaos: a sleeping boy,7 a kid with crutches,5 and a girl so fearsome no one dares sit near her.8 He settles in for ten months of misery.
This turning point reframes the conflict as institutional rather than merely personal. Thaddeus uses students as pawns in a vendetta, illustrating how school hierarchies can punish teachers through student placement. Kermit's apathy is a self-protective shell, forged by years of scapegoating. His decision to 'endure' rather than engage indicates the depth of his burnout, but his stubbornness also hints at a latent resilience. The coffee extinguishing the fire is a perfect visual metaphor for his desire to douse any spark that might reignite his passion.
The Gecko Escape
Miss Emma Fountain,10 the young teacher next door, invites SCS-8 to join her class for Circle Time, a kindergarten-style sharing circle. During the exercise, the class's chaotic energy peaks: Aldo4 accidentally knocks Barnstorm5's crutch into the terrarium of Vladimir, Miss Fountain10's pet gecko. The lizard bolts, and despite a frantic search, it escapes into the hallway.
Later, Kermit1 finds Vladimir hiding in his decrepit car and returns him, only to overhear Miss Fountain10 on the phone with her mother describing him as a burnt-out failure. Kermit1 is stung because Miss Fountain10 is the daughter of his ex-fiancée, Fiona, who left him after the cheating scandal. The encounter forces him to confront the life he lost.
Emma Fountain functions as a living reminder of Kermit's personal trauma and the potential he abandoned. Her cheery but infantilizing methods clash with the middle school reality, yet her earnestness cracks his defenses. The gecko's escape and strange survival in the Coco Nerd's rusted floor parallels the students' own misplacement: they, too, find refuge in unlikely corners. Kermit's eavesdropping deepens his shame but also plants a seed of defiance; he is seen as a failure, but it's not entirely the truth.
Operation Grinch
When the school excludes SCS-8 from Spirit Week and a shipment of vuvuzelas arrives, the class seethes. Knowing the horns drive Kermit1 berserk, they plot to steal them. Parker3 drives his pickup to the loading bay while Elaine8 creates a diversion by stomping on Barnstorm5's foot. The group loads the boxes and speeds across the lawn to the Greenwich River.
A crowd of teachers and the superintendent9 give chase. As they dump the vuvuzelas into the water, Kermit1 arrives, furious and bewildered. In the scuffle, he falls in, and the students, thinking he's drowning, leap in after him. Soaked and shocked, Kermit1 finally understands: this chaos is actually loyalty.
The Grinch comparison is apt: like the Whos, the Unteachables act out of misguided but sincere care. This event marks the first time the class acts as a unit on behalf of their teacher, reversing the typical dynamic of teacher-as-protector. The river plunge is a baptism of sorts; Kermit is dunked in their reality, forced to see them not as adversaries but as allies. The absurdity of the act (stealing noise-makers, a non-violent crime) underscores the book's moral universe: intention matters more than outcome, and loyalty can be messy.
An Essay Earns Puffy-Tails
Shaken by the river incident, Kermit1 begins to transform the classroom. He reads an essay Kiana2 wrote about mass transit, realizes she's brilliant, and gives her an A+ along with the first puffy-tail on the Goodbunnies chart Miss Fountain10 installed. A puffy-tail economy erupts as students scramble to earn the fluffy rewards for good deeds and academic work.
Into this new atmosphere walks Jake Terranova,11 the now-successful car dealer who, as a seventh grader, stole the test answers and caused the cheating scandal that ruined Kermit.1 He apologizes publicly to the class and offers his dealership for field trips, trying to make amends. Kermit1 is deeply reluctant but Miss Fountain10 insists.
The puffy-tail chart, initially an infantilizing gimmick, becomes a flexible tool for Kermit to rebuild his teaching practice. By creating an economy around it, he teaches math, responsibility, and the value of effort. The arrival of Jake Terranova is a second chance at closure: the person who destroyed Kermit's career returns to offer material and emotional restitution. The tension between Kermit's resentment and Jake's guilt creates a complex dynamic where forgiveness is not immediately granted but a process, reflecting real psychological healing.
Elaine's Hidden Strength
Through regular field trips to Terranova Motors,11 the students discover new skills: Parker3's mechanical instinct earns mechanics' praise; Elaine8's raw strength loosens a stripped bolt, leaving adults in awe. Back at school, Barnstorm5 sees three football players bullying Mateo6 in the restroom.
He confronts them, but it's Elaine8's fearsome reputation that makes the attackers flee. Afterwards, the class learns the truth: the legends of her violence are greatly exaggerated. She's not a monster but a quiet, smart girl who has been unfairly labeled. This revelation cements a new trust among them, and the 'Unteachables' become a real team.
The subplot of Elaine's false reputation is a microcosm of the book's central critique: labels are often projections, not truths. Her physical size and silence make her an easy canvas for school mythology, yet she is the most studious and gentle. The field trip's practical, hands-on learning provides the first authentic successes for many students, bypassing their academic deficits. The defense of Mateo mirrors the class's growing solidarity: they protect each other not because they're heroes, but because they've learned that the system won't. This newfound unity prepares them for the larger battle ahead.
The Termination Letter
The class studies hard for the state science assessment, motivated by Kermit1's call to prove the school wrong. Kiana,2 still unregistered, aces the test, but her score is invalidated. Dr. Thaddeus9 uses a contractual clause to claim Kermit1's students have declining grades, cherry-picking data to declare him an ineffective teacher.
Principal Vargas12 delivers the termination notice to a stunned Kermit.1 Effective December 22, he is fired, and his early retirement is denied. Numb, Kermit1 leaves the school building, only to watch his ancient Chrysler Concorde's engine literally fall out onto the pavement. He walks away, feeling as broken as his car.
The firing is the culmination of institutional injustice. Thaddeus's manipulation of test scores mirrors the original cheating scandal in reverse: now the teacher is cheated out of his livelihood by a corrupt administrator. The image of the engine falling out of the Coco Nerd is a powerful metaphor for total collapse: Kermit's life, like the car, has been patched together for years, and the one thing that kept him going (his students' success) fails to protect him. Kiana's invalidated score adds a layer of tragic irony: she, the accidental student, could have saved him if only the bureaucracy had seen her.
Secret Rebuild at Midnight
When Jake11 reveals Kermit1's firing to the class, Kiana2 remembers that the science fair winner gets points added to assessment scores, enough to reverse the termination. Despite Kermit1's earlier refusal, the class decides to enter in secret, using Jake11's shop. Their project: the Coco Nerd itself.
Over weeks, they strip the ancient car to its frame and rebuild a monstrous 585-horsepower engine, with Rahim7 designing a leaping frog logo and a new paint job of red with silver flecks. Parker3's mechanical skills lead the work, while Elaine8 provides brute strength. Miss Fountain10 covers for them, taking them to the dealership after school. Kermit1 must not know.
The secret rebuild is a physical manifestation of the class's emotional reconstruction. Each bolt they tighten is a metaphor for the connections they've formed; the engine's power represents the potential they've unlocked in themselves and in their teacher. The frog logo, a nod to the 'Ribbit' nickname, reclaims a mockery into an emblem of pride. The clandestine nature of the project highlights their commitment: they're not doing it for credit but for love. It's a beautiful inversion of the typical teacher-student gift, and it places the students in the role of restorers of a broken adult's life.
Flames and a Forgotten Name
At the science fair, the class's project looks unimpressive until a note directs the judges outside. Parker3 roars up in the gleaming hot rod, a banner reading 'FIRE RIBBIT? NO WAY!' trailing behind. But the racing fuel's heat ignites the banner, setting nearby hedges ablaze and nearly hitting a mud-splattered Dr. Thaddeus.9
The chaos costs them first place; they place second, not enough to add the needed points. In the commotion, however, Parker3's grandmother, Grams,13 who hasn't remembered his name in years, suddenly shouts 'Parker!' with perfect clarity. Amid disaster, the boy gets back his identity.
The science fair climax is a perfect tragicomic set piece: the class's grand gesture of rebellion and gratitude is partially undone by its own excess, mirroring their earlier vuvuzela fiasco. They don't win the system's approval, which underscores the book's message: institutional validation is not the ultimate goal. The real victory is relational. Grams's memory breakthrough offers a parallel salvation; just as the class fails to save Kermit's job through official channels, Parker is gifted something more precious through love and presence. The flaming banner's message, 'FIRE RIBBIT?', becomes a literal and figurative burning question that demands an answer.
Newspaper Vindication
Mrs. Landsman,15 whom the class pranked earlier, learns of their despair over Kermit1's imminent departure. She tells her son, a newspaper reporter, the whole story. He writes an exposé for the Greenwich Telegraph, headlining 'SUPERINTENDENT TO SUPER TEACHER: YOU'RE FIRED!'
The article highlights Kermit1's transformation of the class, quotes Jake11's admission of the old scandal's true culprit, and directly shames Thaddeus.9 The community erupts in support. Dr. Thaddeus,9 buried under calls and emails, is forced to rescind the termination. Principal Vargas12 joyfully informs Kermit1 he can finish the year and retire with full benefits.
The resolution through journalism reflects the power of narrative: the students' story, told honestly, overcomes bureaucratic spin. Mrs. Landsman's transformation from antagonist to ally demonstrates that even the most traditional figures can be moved by genuine human achievement. The article's call-out of Thaddeus by name holds him personally accountable, a rare instance of institutional justice in a system that usually protects its own. However, the victory is tinged with irony: Kermit's reinstatement comes from public pressure, not from the education system's own values, suggesting that change often requires outside disruption.
Aldo's First Puffy-Tail
Kermit1 returns to room 117 with the good news and announces that he has changed his mind: he will not retire. The students erupt in celebration. Later, Aldo4 finishes 'Where the Red Fern Grows', the first novel he has ever read completely. He is devastated by the dogs' deaths and sobs openly in class.
Kermit1 awards him a puffy-tail for demonstrating empathy, his very first. Overwhelmed, Aldo4 removes the puffy-tail and offers it to Kiana2 to repay his debt, but Kiana2 forgives the loan. Aldo4 throws his arms around her in a hug, a moment of raw emotional growth for the boy who once could barely contain his rage.
Aldo's catharsis over a book about loyal dogs parallels his own journey: like Old Dan and Little Ann, he has learned devotion. His tears are not weakness but evidence that he has moved from reactive anger to receptive feeling. The puffy-tail, originally a joke, becomes a tangible symbol of earned humanity. Kermit's decision to stay is a rejection of the system's timeline of burnout; he has discovered that purpose is renewable. The debt forgiveness by Kiana is a gift of grace, suggesting that relationship economies transcend transactional justice. The hug between Aldo and Kiana seals the class's transformation from a group of isolated misfits into a family.
No Longer a Short-Timer
Kiana2's mother finishes her movie and lands a new role in Vancouver, offering to bring Kiana2 along with a studio-hired tutor. For months, Kiana2 had been a 'short-timer', emotionally refusing to commit to Greenwich. Now, she makes her choice: she declines.
She decides to stay with her father, stepmother,14 and baby Chauncey, and to remain in SCS-8 with the Unteachables. She tells her mom she's unteachable anyway, using the label as an inside joke and a badge of belonging. The girl who accidentally walked into the wrong classroom has found exactly where she's meant to be.
Kiana's decision completes the novel's thematic arc: home is not a place but a constructed belonging. Her initial detachment was a survival mechanism against impermanence, but the class's mutual investment gave her something worth rooting for. By embracing the 'unteachable' label, she transforms it from a stigma into a chosen identity, much like the class did with the frog logo. Her integration into the blended family mirrors the class's integration: both are messy, imperfect, and deeply committed. The short-timer becomes a permanent member, proving that it's never too late to plant roots.
Analysis
Gordon Korman's 'The Unteachables' is a sharp, warm-hearted dismantling of the industrial education model, disguised as a middle-grade comedy. The book's central critique targets the pathology of labeling: both students and teachers are sorted, stigmatized, and discarded based on narrow metrics. The seven 'unteachables' suffer not from incapacity but from institutional neglect. Parker3 is dyslexic, not dumb; Aldo4 lacks emotional regulation, not intelligence; Elaine8 is strong, not violent. Their teacher, Kermit,1 is not incompetent but traumatized, frozen by a system that punished him for a student's crime. The novel demonstrates through its alternating first-person narration that each person is the unreliable hero of their own story, but collectively, their subjective truths converge into a shared reality of resilience. The puffy-tail economy is a brilliant narrative device: it transforms a childish gimmick into a flexible framework for teaching math, ethics, and social contract, all while mocking the very idea of external reward systems. The vuvuzela theft and the car rebuild are acts of creative civil disobedience that question who has the right to define 'spirit' and 'worth.' Kiana2's arc as a 'short-timer' who chooses to belong highlights the novel's deepest theme: identity is not assigned but constructed through commitment. The book posits that real teaching is a relational art, not a transfer of information, and that redemption whether for a burned-out teacher,1 a cheating student,11 or a so-called lost cause is always a collaborative project.
Review Summary
The Unteachables by Gordon Korman receives predominantly positive reviews (4.34/5 stars). Readers praise its humor, heart, and uplifting message about a burned-out teacher and struggling students who inspire each other. Many appreciate the multiple character perspectives and relatability, though some find the rotating POVs uneven. The book resonates with teachers and addresses flaws in education systems that write off struggling students. Common criticisms include predictability, lack of depth, and some unrealistic elements. Reviewers consistently note it's funny, touching, and easy to read, with several calling it a comfort book perfect for middle-grade readers and adults alike.
People Also Read
Characters
Mr. Zachary Kermit
burned-out teacher rebornAt 55, Kermit is a veteran teacher whose career was destroyed by a cheating scandal 27 years ago. He has spent decades in apathy, counting the days to early retirement while hiding behind crossword puzzles and a giant coffee mug nicknamed the Toilet Bowl. When forced into teaching the 'Unteachables', he initially endures but gradually rediscovers his passion through the students' unexpected loyalty. Beneath his gruff exterior is a deep sense of fairness and a dormant gift for teaching. He evolves from a man who dreads the classroom into one who forgoes retirement to keep shaping young lives.
Kiana Roubini
accidental class anchorA bright, observant eighth-grader from California, Kiana is only temporarily in Greenwich while her mother films a movie. She never officially registers; she stumbles into SCS-8 and stays out of convenience. Initially detached and viewing herself as a short-timer, she becomes the class's moral compass, using her intellect to advocate for others. Her well-written essay reignites Kermit1's teaching instinct, and she later spearheads the secret science fair project. Over time, she forms genuine bonds with the misfit class, ultimately choosing them over a chance to return to California.
Parker Elias
dyslexic farm boy driverA 14-year-old who holds a provisional license to drive his grandmother13 and farm produce, Parker sees letters as a scrambled puzzle. He struggles mightily with reading but reveals a natural mechanical genius. He is devoted to his grandmother13, who calls him 'kiddo' because she cannot remember his name. Through targeted reading help, anagrams, and the support of his class, Parker begins to decode words and build confidence. His moment of triumph comes not from a test score but when Grams13 finally says 'Parker'.
Aldo Braff
the angry redheadAldo is known for explosive anger, kicking lockers and throwing backpacks when frustrated. Beneath the rage, he craves connection but doesn't know how to express it. He hates schoolwork until he becomes engrossed in 'Where the Red Fern Grows', the first novel he ever finishes. His crush on Kiana2 softens his rough edges. By the end, he learns to manage his emotions, earning his first Goodbunny puffy-tail for showing empathy and sharing an unexpected hug that signals his profound growth.
Barnstorm Anderson
sidelined sports starOnce a celebrated three-sport athlete, Barnstorm is bitter after a knee injury costs him his identity. He masks vulnerability with arrogance and pranks, often targeting Aldo4. When he can no longer play, his competitive energy gets channeled into hoarding puffy-tails on the Goodbunnies chart. Through the class, he learns that his worth isn't tied to touchdowns and that true friends are more than fans. He becomes protective of his quirky classmates, especially Mateo6, and confronts his former football teammates when they bully him.
Mateo Hendrickson
the sci-fi analystMateo filters the world through pop culture, comparing everyone to characters from Star Wars, Star Trek, and comics. Eccentric and often socially awkward, he is fiercely loyal and surprisingly insightful. He names Kermit1 'the Grinch' and 'Squidward', which helps the class understand their teacher. His knowledge of fictional rebellions inspires the vuvuzela heist and the science fair project. He finds acceptance in SCS-8, where his quirks are celebrated rather than ridiculed, and he proves his courage when bullies target him.
Rahim Barclay
sleepless doodler prodigyRahim is a gifted artist who spends most of class asleep because his stepdad's rock band rehearses all night. Initially overlooked, his talent is recognized when Kermit1 arranges for him to attend community college art classes. As his sleep improves, he becomes more engaged, contributing sketches for class projects including the Coco Nerd's frog logo and the science fair banner. His gentle, observant nature adds a quiet depth to the class, and his artwork becomes a visual record of their journey.
Elaine Ostrover
mislabeled gentle giantTowering and physically powerful, Elaine is feared throughout the school due to exaggerated rumors of head-butting and destruction. In reality, she is quiet, academically capable, and rather gentle. Her brute strength loosens a stubborn bolt at the car shop, earning mechanics' respect. The class's realization that her fearsome reputation is false cements their unity. She becomes a loyal, protective friend, and her deep, rumbling voice belies a thoughtful mind that enjoys literature and science.
Dr. Thaddeus
vindictive superintendentA bureaucrat obsessed with image, Thaddeus has nursed a grudge against Mr. Kermit1 for 27 years over the scandal that embarrassed him when he was principal. He uses his power to assign Kermit1 the worst class as a trap, then later fabricates a reason to fire him by manipulating test data. He represents institutional pettiness and an education system that punishes rather than supports. His eventual humiliation comes through public exposure in a newspaper article.
Miss Emma Fountain
idealistic neighbor teacherThe young teacher in room 115 is the daughter of Kermit1's ex-fiancée. She employs kindergarten-style methods like Circle Time, bucket-filling, and a gecko named Vladimir. While her approach is often tone-deaf for middle school, her relentless optimism and genuine care provide crucial support. She orchestrates Jake11's return, volunteers to chaperone field trips, and helps the class with their secret project. Her budding romance with Jake Terranova11 helps heal old wounds.
Jake Terranova
repentant former cheaterKnown as Jumping Jake, the charismatic car dealer was the 12-year-old who stole and sold the national test answers, inadvertently destroying Mr. Kermit1's reputation. Now a successful businessman, he returns to make amends, offering his dealership for field trips and mentoring the students. His genuine guilt, hands-on help with the class, and eventual engagement to Miss Fountain10 win over even Kermit1, illustrating the long arc of redemption.
Principal Christina Vargas
supportive yet constrained allyA longtime colleague of Kermit1, Principal Vargas remembers the brilliant teacher he once was. She advocates for his field trips and tries to warn him about the superintendent9's schemes. Constrained by her position, she is unable to stop the unjust firing but plays a key role in the eventual reversal, always believing in the progress Kermit1 and the 'Unteachables' have made.
Grams
memory-impaired grandmotherParker3's beloved grandmother, a former bus station luncheonette worker, has dementia and calls him 'kiddo' because she can't remember his name. She provides comic relief and deep pathos. Her moment of clarity at the science fair, when she remembers and shouts 'Parker3!', is one of the book's most powerful emotional payoffs.
Louise
overwhelmed stepmotherKiana2's stepmother, nicknamed 'Stepmonster', is frazzled by her baby Chauncey and initially inattentive. However, she later steps up to advocate for Kiana2 to stay in SCS-8, revealing a genuine if clumsy maternal care. Her chaotic parenting provides both comic relief and a backdrop for Kiana2's decision to embrace her blended family.
Mrs. Landsman
substitute turned whistleblowerAn elderly, stern substitute teacher whom the class initially pranks. When she later covers their class and learns about Kermit1's unjust firing, she passes the story to her journalist son, resulting in the newspaper exposé that saves Kermit1's job. Her arc from antagonist to ally underscores the theme that understanding can change perceptions.
Plot Devices
Vuvuzelas
noise-makers of rebellionThe cheap plastic horns, ordered for school Spirit Week, represent mindless institutional demands that torment Kermit1. Their deafening noise drives him to visceral rage. The class's decision to steal the entire shipment and dump it in the river is their first collective act of defiance and care. The incident leads to a newspaper story that resurfaces the decades-old cheating scandal, setting off a chain of events that will ultimately save Kermit1's career. The vuvuzelas become a symbol of how the students will disrupt the system to protect what they value.
Goodbunnies Puffy-Tails
reward chart economyMiss Fountain10's vibrantly colored behavior chart awards Velcro cotton balls (puffy-tails) for good deeds and academic achievement. Initially an infantilizing gimmick, it is embraced by Kermit1 as a tool to incentivize the disengaged students. He expands it into a miniature economy where puffy-tails can be traded, lent, and saved, teaching concepts of debt, interest, and value. The chart becomes a visible measure of the class's transformation: Barnstorm5 hoards them obsessively, Kiana2 lends them freely, and Aldo4's first earned puffy-tail marks his emotional breakthrough.
The Coco Nerd
symbol car of renewalKermit1's 1992 Chrysler Concorde, bought with his ex-fiancée and held together by rust and neglect, symbolizes his frozen, damaged life. Its nickname comes from Parker3's jumbled reading of 'Concorde'. After Kermit1 is fired and the engine literally falls out, the students secretly rebuild it at Jake11's shop into a gleaming, 585-horsepower hot rod with a leaping frog logo. The transformed car, unveiled at the science fair, becomes the ultimate gift of gratitude and a physical manifestation of everyone's second chance. Its reconstruction mirrors Kermit1's own professional and emotional renewal.
The 1992 Cheating Scandal
backstory woundTwenty-seven years earlier, Jake Terranova11 stole a copy of the national aptitude test and sold it to classmates, resulting in a cheating scandal that was blamed on their teacher, Mr. Kermit1. This event shattered Kermit1's reputation, cost him his fiancée, and left him a scapegoat. Superintendent Thaddeus9 has never forgiven the embarrassment and uses his power to punish Kermit1. Jake11's return as a successful adult seeking forgiveness, and the eventual public airing of the truth, allows the old wound to heal, releasing Kermit1 from decades of shame.
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.