Key Takeaways
1. Innovation is a Battle Against Friction, Not Just a Quest for Fuel
To create change we must first understand the forces operating against change.
Fuel vs. Friction. The conventional approach to innovation focuses on "Fuel"—heightening the appeal of an idea through features, benefits, and messaging. However, this neglects the "Friction" that opposes change: psychological forces that create drag on innovation. Like a bullet's aerodynamics, reducing Friction is essential for an idea to take flight.
The Law of Attraction. Most innovators operate under the Law of Attraction, believing that adding enough value will convince people to say yes. This leads to feature creep and marketing sizzle, but ignores the underlying resistance to change. Overcoming Friction is just as important as adding Fuel.
The Four Frictions. The book identifies four primary Frictions: Inertia (desire to stick with what we know), Effort (energy needed to make change happen), Emotion (negative feelings created by change), and Reactance (impulse to resist being changed). Understanding and addressing these Frictions is crucial for successful innovation.
2. The Fuel-Based Mindset Overlooks Powerful Forces Against Change
The moment I start “selling” is the moment I lose them.
The Car Salesman Analogy. The typical car salesperson focuses on "Fuel"—highlighting features and benefits to convince buyers. Ali Reda, the world's best car salesperson, succeeds by reducing Emotional Friction, building trust, and acting as an advisor rather than a pushy salesman. This illustrates the power of addressing Friction over simply adding Fuel.
Limitations of Fuel. While Fuel is necessary to motivate change, it has limitations: bad is stronger than good (negativity bias), Fuel is costly (requires continuous application), Fuel is self-evident (benefits are often obvious), and Fuel can amplify Friction (unintended consequences). A Fuel-based mindset often leads to neglecting the forces working against change.
Fundamental Attribution Error. The Fuel-based mindset is reinforced by the fundamental attribution error, our tendency to attribute behavior to internal forces (motivation, intent) while minimizing situational causes (Friction). This leads us to focus on increasing motivation rather than removing obstacles.
3. Inertia: The Mind's Preference for the Known
New ideas advance one funeral at a time.
Status Quo Bias. Inertia captures the human mind's hardwiring to favor the familiar. This status quo bias explains why people are reluctant to embrace new ideas, even when the benefits are obvious. Familiarity breeds liking, making the known feel safer than the unknown.
Mere Exposure Effect. The mere exposure effect demonstrates that repeated exposure to something increases our liking of it. This explains why brand recognition is so important in advertising and why even small changes to familiar products can cause outrage.
Inertia Kills Innovation. Inertia leads to inaction, limiting the options we consider and hindering progress. It explains why Americans are socialists and Europeans are capitalists when it comes to sports, and why we tend to favor the system we are in, not because it is better, but because it is familiar.
4. Effort: The Law of Least Resistance Governs Adoption
Animals are designed to weigh the costs (energy spent) against the benefits (energy gained) when gathering food to maximize energy intake.
Optimal Foraging Theory. Like shore crabs choosing mussels, humans are programmed to find the most efficient way to achieve their goals. The law of least effort states that people will follow the path that provides the greatest rewards for the least possible energy expenditure.
Effort as a Friction. Innovation often requires Effort, such as learning new procedures or navigating unfamiliar systems. This Effort acts as a psychological Friction, undermining the appeal of new ideas. The easier the path, the more likely people are to follow it.
Dimensions of Effort. Effort has two dimensions: exertion (amount of energy required) and ambiguity (lack of clarity on how to achieve the goal). Reducing both exertion and ambiguity is crucial for overcoming Effort-based Friction.
5. Emotion: Unintended Negative Feelings Inhibit Innovation
The authors provide paradigm shifting frameworks that will help managers and entrepreneurs improve their odds of success.
Emotional Friction Defined. Emotional Friction refers to the unintended negative feelings (anxiety, fear, embarrassment) that inhibit a new idea or innovation. These feelings can be a significant barrier to adoption, even when the idea has clear functional benefits.
The Cake Mix Story. The initial failure of cake mix illustrates the power of Emotional Friction. While convenient, cake mix was initially seen as a soulless act, undermining the emotional value of baking as an expression of love and care. Adding eggs back into the recipe solved this problem.
Tinder vs. Match.com. Tinder's success stems from removing the Emotional Friction of rejection inherent in traditional dating sites like Match.com. By focusing on mutual interest, Tinder made online dating less daunting and more appealing.
6. Reactance: The Impulse to Resist Being Changed
Don't follow the conventional path of intensifying your persuasion; instead focus on reducing the friction that fuels resistance.
The Seat Belt Wars. The initial resistance to seat belt laws demonstrates the human tendency to resist being told what to do. Reactance is the impulse to protect our autonomy and push back against perceived threats to our freedom.
The Rat Experiment. Jay Weiss's rat experiment showed that even when experiencing the same level of pain, those with control over their environment (the lever) experienced less stress than those without. This highlights the importance of autonomy and freedom.
Strong Evidence Backfires. Presenting strong evidence can sometimes strengthen opposition, as people dig in to defend their beliefs. This is why deep canvassing, which focuses on self-persuasion, is more effective than traditional canvassing.
7. Overcoming Inertia: Transforming the Unfamiliar into the Familiar
Our preference for the familiar is so ingrained, it occurs even when we aren't consciously aware of it.
Acclimate the Idea. To overcome Inertia, innovators must transform the unfamiliar into the familiar. This can be achieved through strategies like repetition (mere exposure effect), starting small (incremental exposure), finding a familiar face (messenger matters), making it prototypical (fit the category), and using analogies (relate to what's known).
Make It Relative. People understand the world in relative terms. By managing the points of comparison, innovators can transform Inertia from a Friction into a Fuel. This can be achieved by adding an extreme option (making others seem reasonable) or highlighting undesirable options (making the preferred option more appealing).
The Wine List Strategy. The presence of a very expensive bottle of wine on a restaurant menu makes the other, less expensive bottles seem more reasonable by comparison. This illustrates the power of relativity in shaping our perceptions and choices.
8. Overcoming Effort: Streamlining the Path of Least Resistance
The key to dramatically increasing enrollments wasn't a Fuel‐based solution...The key was to make the application easier.
Reduce Exertion and Ambiguity. To overcome Effort-based Friction, innovators must reduce both exertion (physical and mental energy required) and ambiguity (lack of clarity on how to achieve the goal). This involves creating a roadmap (reducing ambiguity) and streamlining the behavior (reducing exertion).
The Chlorine Dispenser Example. The public chlorine dispenser program in Kenya succeeded by streamlining the water purification process, making it easier and more convenient for people to access clean drinking water. This involved removing the need to measure chlorine and wait for purification.
The University of Chicago Story. The University of Chicago increased applications by adopting the Common Application, reducing the Effort required for students to apply. This highlights the power of streamlining and the danger of underestimating its influence.
9. Overcoming Emotion: Quieting the Fears That Impede Progress
The insights Loran Nordgren and David Schonthal surface are important reminders of the care and attention designers need to bring a new idea to life and to build our shared future.
Focus on Why. To uncover Emotional Friction, innovators must focus on why people feel the way they do, rather than simply addressing their stated positions. This involves asking open, probing, and illuminating questions to understand the underlying motivations and anxieties.
Become an Ethnographer. Observing users in their natural habitat can reveal unspoken needs and concerns. Ethnography helps innovators see the world as users do, providing insight into how they actually behave without the filter of traditional market research.
Bring the Outside In. Involving the target audience in the innovation process can provide valuable insights into potential Emotional Frictions. This can be achieved by hiring customers, forming advisory boards, or conducting co-design workshops.
10. Overcoming Reactance: Helping Your Audience Persuade Themselves
The ability to elegantly overcome Friction is one of the most crucial skills an innovator can possess.
Self-Persuasion Defined. To overcome Reactance, innovators must shift from persuasion to self-persuasion, helping their audience to internalize the message and come to their own conclusions. This involves asking rather than telling, and creating opportunities for self-discovery.
Deep Canvassing. Deep canvassing, used by the Leadership Lab to promote transgender rights, demonstrates the power of self-persuasion. By asking open-ended questions and listening empathetically, canvassers help voters to challenge their own biases and come to new understandings.
Ask Yes Questions. Starting with questions that reveal acceptance and common ground can reduce Reactance and create a more receptive environment for new ideas. This involves building a "yes ladder" and framing decisions as experiments rather than commands.
Last updated:
FAQ
1. What’s "The Human Element" by David Schonthal about?
- Focus on Resistance to Change: The book explores why people resist new ideas, products, or innovations, even when they seem beneficial.
- Friction vs. Fuel: It introduces the concept that innovators often focus on making ideas more attractive (Fuel) but overlook the psychological forces (Frictions) that block adoption.
- Four Types of Friction: The core framework identifies four Frictions—Inertia, Effort, Emotion, and Reactance—that act as barriers to change.
- Practical Solutions: The book provides actionable strategies for identifying and overcoming these Frictions to accelerate the adoption of new ideas.
2. Why should I read "The Human Element" by David Schonthal?
- Essential for Innovators: If you’re launching new products, services, or initiatives, understanding resistance is crucial for success.
- Shifts Mindset: The book challenges the common belief that adding more value (Fuel) is enough, showing that removing barriers (Friction) is often more effective.
- Applicable Across Fields: The insights are relevant for entrepreneurs, marketers, leaders, designers, and anyone driving change.
- Backed by Research and Stories: The book combines behavioral science, real-world case studies, and practical tools, making it both credible and actionable.
3. What are the key takeaways from "The Human Element"?
- Friction is the Hidden Barrier: Most failed innovations aren’t lacking in appeal but are blocked by unseen psychological Frictions.
- Four Frictions Framework: Inertia (preference for the familiar), Effort (perceived difficulty), Emotion (negative feelings), and Reactance (resistance to being changed) are the main obstacles.
- Fuel Alone Isn’t Enough: Adding features, benefits, or incentives (Fuel) often fails or even backfires if Frictions aren’t addressed.
- Empathy and Discovery are Key: Understanding your audience’s real barriers requires empathy, observation, and sometimes ethnographic research.
4. What is the main argument or thesis of "The Human Element"?
- Overcoming Resistance is Critical: The book argues that the success of new ideas depends less on their appeal and more on the ability to remove psychological Frictions.
- Fuel vs. Friction: While making ideas attractive is necessary, it’s insufficient without addressing what holds people back.
- Innovators’ Blind Spot: Most change agents instinctively focus on Fuel and underestimate or ignore Friction, leading to stalled adoption.
- A New Approach to Change: The book advocates for a shift from persuasion to friction-reduction as the primary strategy for driving innovation.
5. What are the Four Frictions described in "The Human Element" and what do they mean?
- Inertia: The tendency to stick with what’s familiar, even when better options exist; people resist change because the status quo feels safer.
- Effort: The real or perceived difficulty of adopting a new idea, including both physical/mental exertion and ambiguity about what to do.
- Emotion: Negative feelings (anxiety, fear, embarrassment) that arise from change, often unintentionally triggered by the innovation itself.
- Reactance: The instinctive resistance to being changed or told what to do, especially when people feel their autonomy is threatened.
6. How does "The Human Element" by David Schonthal suggest overcoming Inertia?
- Acclimate the Idea: Increase familiarity through repetition, starting small, using familiar faces, making the idea prototypical, and drawing analogies to known concepts.
- Make it Relative: Present multiple options, add extreme or less desirable alternatives, and manage points of comparison to make the new idea seem more reasonable.
- Allow Time to Adjust: Give people time between introduction and decision, so the unfamiliar becomes more comfortable.
- Contextualize Change: Use reference points and analogies to help people relate the new idea to something they already understand.
7. What strategies does "The Human Element" recommend for reducing Effort Friction?
- Create a Roadmap: Provide clear, step-by-step instructions and identify when and how to act, reducing ambiguity and confusion.
- Streamline the Behavior: Remove unnecessary steps, automate processes, and make the desired action as easy as possible.
- Leverage Defaults: Make the preferred behavior the default option, so people follow the path of least resistance.
- Make “No” Harder: Increase the effort required to reject the new idea, nudging people toward acceptance.
8. How does "The Human Element" address Emotional Friction and what are the remedies?
- Identify Emotional Barriers: Use empathy, observation, and the “five whys” technique to uncover hidden anxieties or fears.
- Allow for Trial and Reversibility: Offer free trials, easy returns, or reversible decisions to reduce the emotional risk of trying something new.
- Include a Service Element: Provide support, reassurance, or human assistance to help users feel confident and cared for.
- Bring the Outside In: Involve target users in the design process or hire people with lived experience to ensure emotional needs are addressed.
9. What is Reactance in "The Human Element" and how can it be overcome?
- Definition of Reactance: Reactance is the impulse to resist being changed, especially when people feel pressured or excluded from the process.
- Avoid the Hard Sell: Pushing harder or providing more evidence often increases resistance rather than reducing it.
- Use Self-Persuasion: Ask questions that lead people to generate their own reasons for change, rather than telling them what to do.
- Co-Design and Participation: Involve the audience in designing the change, making them co-creators rather than passive recipients.
10. What practical tools and methods does "The Human Element" by David Schonthal provide for innovators?
- Friction Reports: Worksheets to diagnose and forecast the impact of the Four Frictions on any innovation or change initiative.
- Experience Timelines: Visual tools to map user journeys and identify moments of high Effort or Emotional Friction.
- Ethnographic Research: Techniques for observing users in their natural environment to uncover hidden barriers.
- Checklists and Tactics: Actionable questions and strategies at the end of each chapter to help apply friction-reduction methods.
11. What are some real-world case studies or examples from "The Human Element" that illustrate Friction Theory?
- Beach House Furniture: Customers loved the product but didn’t buy because they didn’t know what to do with their old sofa; removing this Friction increased sales.
- Dubai’s Entrepreneurship Program: Overcame cultural Inertia and Effort by creating Free Zones, roadmaps, and parental recognition to encourage student startups.
- Flyhomes Real Estate: Shifted from offering perks (Fuel) to removing Effort and Emotional Friction in homebuying, enabling more buyers to compete with cash offers.
- Marijuana Legalization: Used incremental steps (medical use first) and self-persuasion to overcome Inertia, Emotion, and Reactance, leading to widespread acceptance.
12. What are the best quotes from "The Human Element" by David Schonthal and what do they mean?
- “Our intuition tells us that for an idea to take flight, we need to give it thrust. And that's true. But imagine building an airplane without taking aerodynamics into account and only thinking about the power of the engines. This is precisely what we do when we launch a new idea or initiative. No wonder so few take flight.”
Meaning: Focusing only on making ideas attractive (thrust/Fuel) without reducing resistance (aerodynamics/Friction) leads to failure. - “Friction is the hidden barrier to innovation. It is the drag that holds back even the best ideas.”
Meaning: The unseen psychological forces, not lack of value, are what most often block adoption of new ideas. - “The secret to overcoming Reactance is to stop pushing for change. Rather than attempting to persuade others, we should help them to persuade themselves.”
Meaning: Self-persuasion and participation are more effective than pressure or argument in overcoming resistance. - “Proposing new ideas without designing their integration into the world is innovation half-done.”
Meaning: Success requires not just a good idea, but careful attention to how people will actually adopt it, including removing Frictions.
Review Summary
The Human Element receives mostly positive reviews, with readers praising its practical insights on overcoming resistance to change. Many find the book's focus on reducing friction rather than increasing motivation refreshing and applicable to both business and personal life. Some criticize the book for rehashing familiar concepts and examples, while others appreciate its concise presentation of counter-intuitive wisdom. Readers value the case studies and real-life examples, particularly those related to recent events like the COVID-19 pandemic. Overall, it's considered a valuable resource for leaders and innovators.
Similar Books
Download PDF
Download EPUB
.epub digital book format is ideal for reading ebooks on phones, tablets, and e-readers.
