Plot Summary
Home for the Holidays
Pediatric nurse Catalina Martinez comes home for her sister Gabriela's winter wedding, bracing herself for a month of family, small-town scrutiny, and the awkwardness of her ex-boyfriend Aiden now being her sister's fiancé. Catalina's relationship with her mother is strained, and her sense of displacement is heightened by her status as the "difficult" daughter. The town is alive with Christmas festivities, but Catalina feels like an outsider, especially as she's forced to interact with Aiden's best friend, Luke Darling—a charming, relentlessly upbeat ER doctor who seems to embody everything she distrusts in men. Catalina's return is meant to be temporary, but the emotional undercurrents of home tug at her in unexpected ways.
Awkward Family Ties
Catalina's family is determined to keep the peace, but the tension is palpable. Her mother's subtle criticisms and Gabriela's attempts at sisterly closeness only make Catalina more defensive. The family's dynamic is complicated by Catalina's history with Aiden, and the presence of Luke—Aiden's best friend and the best man—adds another layer of discomfort. Catalina's efforts to be helpful and present are undermined by her own insecurities and the feeling that she's always second-best. The holiday season, with its traditions and togetherness, only amplifies her sense of loneliness and longing for belonging.
The Doctor and the Nurse
Luke and Catalina's initial interactions are laced with sarcasm and mutual wariness. Both are medical professionals—Luke an ER doctor, Catalina a travel nurse—but their approaches to life and relationships couldn't be more different. Luke is open, warm, and eager to connect, while Catalina is guarded, quick-witted, and determined to keep her distance. Their chemistry is undeniable, but Catalina's self-protective instincts kick in, especially as she recognizes the risk of getting involved with someone so closely tied to her family's new dynamic. Still, small moments of laughter and shared vulnerability begin to chip away at her defenses.
Gingerbread Rivalry
At the town's holiday block party, a gingerbread house competition becomes a battleground for old rivalries and new alliances. Luke and Catalina are paired together, their competitive spirits clashing and then aligning as they work side by side. The playful banter and teamwork reveal a compatibility neither expected. For Luke, the event is a chance to show Catalina his genuine self, while for Catalina, it's a reminder of the joy she's been missing. The gingerbread house may collapse, but the walls between them start to weaken, hinting at the possibility of something more.
Walls and Wounds
Catalina's role as a NICU nurse brings her face-to-face with the fragility of life, and a particularly heartbreaking case leaves her raw and vulnerable. She struggles with guilt—not just for her patients, but for the way her choices have affected her family, especially Gabriela. Luke finds her in a moment of distress and offers quiet support, respecting her need for space while making it clear he cares. Their rooftop conversation under the winter sky becomes a turning point, as Catalina allows herself to be comforted, if only briefly, by someone else's presence.
Coffee Break Confessions
Late-night hospital shifts and bad coffee become the backdrop for deeper conversations. Luke and Catalina bond over the challenges of medicine, the weight of responsibility, and the loneliness that comes with their careers. Luke's easy humor and willingness to be vulnerable draw Catalina out, and she finds herself confiding in him about her fears and regrets. Their text exchanges grow increasingly flirtatious, blurring the line between friendship and something more. Both are aware of the risks, but the pull between them is undeniable.
Sisterly Complications
Gabriela senses the growing connection between Catalina and Luke and confronts her sister, worried that another romantic entanglement could drive them apart again. The sisters have a difficult but necessary conversation, acknowledging the pain of the past and their mutual desire to rebuild trust. Catalina promises not to let a man come between them, but the conversation leaves her even more conflicted about her feelings for Luke. The sisters' bond, though tested, begins to heal as they agree to prioritize each other's happiness.
LEGO Invitations
Luke, hoping to bridge the gap, invites Catalina to help him build a massive, limited-edition LEGO set—a gesture that speaks to her childhood passions and longing for connection. The invitation is orchestrated with the help of Gabriela and Aiden, who see the potential for healing and happiness in their union. Catalina is hesitant, fearing the implications of getting closer, but the shared project becomes a safe space for intimacy and laughter. Piece by piece, they build not just a LEGO set, but a foundation of trust and affection.
Building Trust, Piece by Piece
As they spend late nights assembling the LEGO set, Catalina and Luke's relationship deepens. They share stories, inside jokes, and quiet moments of understanding. The physical attraction simmers beneath the surface, but it's the emotional intimacy that surprises them both. Luke's patience and sincerity help Catalina lower her guard, while Catalina's vulnerability allows Luke to show his own imperfections. Their connection becomes a source of comfort and joy, challenging Catalina's belief that she's destined to be alone.
Rooftop Vulnerabilities
A particularly difficult night at the hospital brings Catalina to a breaking point, and Luke finds her on the rooftop, struggling with grief and self-doubt. He offers silent companionship, allowing her to process her emotions without judgment. The moment is charged with unspoken feelings, and when Luke finally reaches out, the barriers between them crumble. Their first kiss is both a release and a promise—a recognition that what they share is real, even if it's complicated. Catalina is terrified of the consequences, but for the first time, she allows herself to hope.
Holiday Block Party
The town's holiday celebrations bring everyone together, and Catalina finds herself drawn into the warmth of community and family. Luke's efforts to include her, from baking traditional desserts to participating in the town's parranda, show his commitment to making her feel at home. The festivities become a backdrop for Catalina's gradual acceptance of her place in Lake Wisteria—not just as a visitor, but as someone who is loved and needed. The sense of belonging she's always craved begins to take root.
Parranda and Pudding
The Martinez family's Puerto Rican traditions, especially the parranda and the making of coquito and tembleque, become a celebration of heritage and healing. Luke's willingness to embrace these customs—and his earnest, if imperfect, attempts to participate—endear him to Catalina and her family. The night is filled with music, laughter, and a sense of continuity, as old wounds are soothed by new memories. Catalina realizes that love can be found in the most unexpected places, and that letting people in doesn't mean losing herself.
Christmas Eve Connections
Christmas Eve at the Martinez home is a turning point for Catalina and Luke. Surrounded by family, friends, and the chaos of holiday traditions, they find moments of quiet connection. A small, thoughtful gift—a LEGO doctor keychain—becomes a symbol of their growing affection. The night ends with a deepening of their physical and emotional intimacy, as they finally give in to their desires. For Catalina, the experience is both exhilarating and terrifying, as she confronts the possibility of real, lasting love.
The Speech and the Kiss
The wedding day arrives, and Catalina is tasked with delivering the maid of honor speech. With Luke's encouragement, she finds the courage to speak from the heart, acknowledging her own fears and hopes for love. The speech is a cathartic moment, allowing her to let go of guilt and embrace the future. Luke's unwavering support and pride in her accomplishment solidify their bond. The night ends with a passionate kiss, sealing their commitment to each other, even as the future remains uncertain.
Wedding Day Promises
Gabriela and Aiden's wedding is a joyful, emotional affair, bringing closure to old wounds and opening the door to new possibilities. Catalina and Luke navigate the complexities of their relationship in the public eye, balancing family expectations with their own desires. The festivities are a testament to the power of forgiveness, growth, and the courage to choose happiness. As the newlyweds embark on their journey, Catalina and Luke are left to define what their own future will look like.
New Year's Eve Choices
As the year draws to a close, Catalina and Luke are confronted with the reality of her impending departure for a new nursing assignment in California. The prospect of a long-distance relationship is daunting, but neither is willing to let go of what they've found. Amidst the fireworks and celebrations, they make a tentative promise to try, trusting that their connection is strong enough to withstand the distance. The new year begins with hope, uncertainty, and the knowledge that love is worth fighting for.
Long-Distance Goodbyes
Catalina's move to California is bittersweet, marked by late-night calls, longing, and the ache of absence. Both she and Luke struggle with the challenges of distance, but their commitment to each other never wavers. Catalina's experiences in Los Angeles reaffirm her desire for home and belonging, while Luke's steadfast support gives her the courage to dream of a future together. The months apart become a test of their love, ultimately strengthening their bond and clarifying what truly matters.
Coming Home
When Catalina returns to Lake Wisteria, she and Luke are finally able to build the life they've both longed for. Their shared apartment, filled with LEGO sets and laughter, becomes a sanctuary from the hardships of their work. Luke's heartfelt proposal—delivered in the most "them" way possible—cements their commitment to each other. Surrounded by family, friends, and the traditions that once felt suffocating, Catalina finds peace in the knowledge that she is loved, seen, and finally home.
Characters
Catalina Martinez
Catalina is a fiercely independent pediatric nurse who has built emotional walls to protect herself from disappointment and pain. Her history of feeling like the "difficult" daughter and the awkwardness of her ex dating her sister have left her wary of intimacy and reluctant to trust. She is deeply loyal, especially to her family, but struggles with guilt and self-doubt. Catalina's journey is one of learning to accept love, forgive herself, and allow vulnerability. Her relationship with Luke challenges her to confront her fears and embrace the possibility of happiness, while her bond with Gabriela is a testament to the enduring power of sisterhood.
Luke Darling
Luke is the quintessential "good guy"—an ER doctor with a savior complex, a penchant for dad jokes, and a heart of gold. Outwardly confident and endlessly supportive, he hides his own wounds from a childhood marked by emotional distance and high parental expectations. Luke's desire to help others sometimes masks his fear of not being enough. His attraction to Catalina is immediate and profound, and he pursues her with patience, humor, and unwavering sincerity. Through their relationship, Luke learns to let go of perfectionism and accept love in its messiest, most authentic form.
Gabriela Martinez
Gabriela is Catalina's younger sister and the "golden child" of the family. Warm, optimistic, and eager to please, she often finds herself caught between her own desires and the expectations of others. Her relationship with Aiden is a source of joy, but her bond with Catalina is tested by past misunderstandings and the fear of losing her sister's closeness. Gabriela's journey is one of learning to assert her own needs while supporting those she loves, and her forgiveness and encouragement are crucial to Catalina's healing.
Aiden
Aiden is Catalina's ex-boyfriend and Gabriela's fiancé (later husband). Kind, steady, and pragmatic, he serves as a bridge between the sisters and a model of healthy masculinity. His decision to end things with Catalina and pursue Gabriela is handled with care, and his friendship with Luke is a source of comic relief and emotional grounding. Aiden's presence forces Catalina to confront her past and make peace with her choices.
Mrs. Martinez (Mami)
Catalina and Gabriela's mother is a former pageant queen who struggles to connect with her eldest daughter. Her high standards and tendency to compare her daughters create tension, but beneath her critical exterior is a deep love and a desire to do better. Her journey mirrors Catalina's, as both women learn to communicate honestly and accept each other's differences.
Mr. Martinez (Papi)
The Martinez patriarch is a steady, loving presence who anchors the family's Puerto Rican heritage. His warmth and humor provide comfort to his daughters, and his partnership with Mrs. Martinez is a model for the kind of love Catalina ultimately seeks.
Monica, Nancy, and Winny
These three friends provide comic relief, emotional support, and a sounding board for Catalina's anxieties. Their group chat is a lifeline during Catalina's travels, offering advice, encouragement, and a reminder that she is not alone in her struggles.
Josefina Lopez
As the town's event coordinator, Josefina embodies the spirit of Lake Wisteria. Her enthusiasm for tradition and her role in organizing the parranda highlight the importance of community and cultural roots in Catalina's journey.
Aiden's Parents
Warm, inclusive, and loving, Aiden's parents offer Luke the kind of familial acceptance he never received at home. Their embrace of both Luke and Catalina underscores the theme that family is not just about blood, but about the people who choose to love and support you.
Lake Wisteria
The small town, with its holiday traditions, gossip, and close-knit community, is both a source of comfort and conflict. It represents the tension between the desire for escape and the longing for home, ultimately serving as the backdrop for Catalina's transformation.
Plot Devices
Alternating Perspectives
The story unfolds through alternating chapters from Catalina and Luke's points of view, allowing readers to experience their internal struggles, hopes, and fears firsthand. This structure creates dramatic irony, as each character's insecurities and desires are revealed to the reader before they are shared with each other, heightening tension and empathy.
Forced Proximity and Second Chances
The novella leverages the classic romance device of forced proximity—Catalina's extended stay for her sister's wedding, shared family events, and overlapping work schedules—to bring the protagonists together. The "second chance" motif is echoed in both the sisters' relationship and Catalina's willingness to risk love again.
Symbolic Objects
The recurring motif of building—whether gingerbread houses, LEGO sets, or family traditions—serves as a metaphor for the slow, deliberate work of trust and intimacy. Coffee breaks and shared meals become moments of vulnerability, while the family's coquito and tembleque recipes symbolize heritage, continuity, and the sweetness of belonging.
Text Messages and Group Chats
The use of text threads, group chats, and digital communication provides insight into the characters' personalities and relationships. These exchanges offer levity, reveal hidden fears, and allow for confessions that might be too difficult face-to-face.
Foreshadowing and Callbacks
Early references to Catalina's love of LEGOs, Luke's baking, and the sisters' childhood games foreshadow later moments of connection and growth. The story is rich with callbacks—inside jokes, repeated gestures, and shared memories—that reinforce the characters' development and the deepening of their bond.
Analysis
Lauren Asher's My December Darling is more than a holiday romance—it's a nuanced exploration of how we build (and rebuild) our lives, relationships, and sense of self. Through the lens of a small-town winter, the novella examines the ways guilt, grief, and fear can isolate us, and how vulnerability, forgiveness, and community can bring us back to ourselves. Catalina's journey from guarded outsider to beloved partner is mirrored in her evolving relationships with her family, her hometown, and her own heart. Luke's steadfastness and gentle persistence challenge the notion that love must be dramatic or grandiose; instead, the story celebrates the quiet heroism of showing up, listening, and choosing each other every day. The use of holiday traditions, cultural heritage, and playful motifs (like LEGOs and gingerbread houses) grounds the romance in the rhythms of real life, making the characters' growth feel both earned and universal. Ultimately, the novella suggests that home is not a place, but a feeling—and that love, in all its messy, imperfect glory, is always worth the risk.
Last updated:
