Key Takeaways
1. Mindfulness: More Than Just "Present Moment" Awareness
“What is mindfulness? Is it a scientifically proven method for reducing stress? An evidence-based strategy for improving performance? A path to complete liberation from suffering? Or is it simply a way to live a more contented life? With directness and warmth, Oxford University’s Sarah Shaw explains why the answer to each of these questions is yes.”
A transformative concept. Mindfulness, or sati in Pāli and smṛti in Sanskrit, is often understood as simply "being in the present moment." However, its Buddhist origins reveal a far richer and more complex meaning. It's a dynamic, attentive awareness that integrates scholarly wisdom with skillful modern application, offering a path to liberation from suffering and a more contented life.
Beyond pop culture. The term transcends its popular self-help interpretations, delving into historical and spiritual depths. It's not merely a technique for stress reduction or performance enhancement, but a crucial element within a complete system for understanding the mind, clearing problems, and fostering ethical behavior. This broader context reveals its true potency, often obscured by modern simplifications.
An inherent birthright. Mindfulness is presented as an innate human capacity, like a bubbling spring, refreshing and new each time it arises. It allows us to live, observe, experience, and remember, guiding us to natural springs of awareness. This quality is always ongoing, susceptible to new interpretations and enactments, yet fundamentally accessible to all.
2. The Middle Way: Mindfulness as Balance and Skillfulness
“The balanced, even note, the equipoise of the middle way, describes the mind that is awake and on its way on the path to freedom.”
Avoiding extremes. The Buddha's life story exemplifies the "middle way," a path between excessive indulgence and severe asceticism. This principle of balanced equipoise is central to the Eightfold Path, where each factor, from right view to right concentration, aims for skillfulness (sammā)—an aptness that causes no harm and avoids both clinging and rejection.
Navigating life's complexities. Mindfulness is the intuitive alertness that finds this middle way in every situation. Whether navigating a busy roundabout, engaging in a conversation, or observing the breath in meditation, it allows for the requisite amount of attention without over-focusing or becoming slack. It's the ability to pay attention, find balance, and maintain awareness of the whole context.
An animating force. The Eightfold Path's factors are distinct yet interdependent, like instruments in an orchestra. None can truly flourish without mindfulness. It ensures that actions, speech, livelihood, and effort are "right," fostering a mind that is clear, non-attached, and free from confusion, leading to genuine peace and equanimity.
3. Mindfulness's Core Functions: Guarding, Discriminating, and Remembering
“With mindfulness as his gatekeeper, the noble disciple abandons the unskillful and brings into being the skillful.”
The gatekeeper of the senses. Mindfulness acts as a vigilant gatekeeper, guarding the "sense doors" (eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, and mind). It observes what enters and leaves, discerning what to admit and what to exclude, not through judgment, but through an instinctive ethical sense that recognizes threats to well-being.
Active and discerning. Beyond passive observation, mindfulness actively "takes up" (upagaṇhanā) what is beneficial and "does not drift away" (apilāpana) from skillful states. It's like a wise advisor, guiding the mind towards helpful actions and away from unskillful ones, ensuring decisions are made with care and awareness of consequences.
Remembering to remember. While shifting from its ancient meaning of pure memory, mindfulness retains a crucial aspect of remembrance. This includes:
- Recollecting past skillful states
- Bearing in mind qualities to cultivate (e.g., loving kindness, compassion)
- Proactively bringing to mind auspicious subjects (anussatis) like the Buddha, Dharma, Sangha, or the impermanence of life.
This active remembrance helps sustain alertness and cheerfulness in daily life and meditation.
4. Mindfulness and Concentration: Inseparable Partners in Meditation
“Mindfulness and concentration are needed, as well as effort: the musician needs to listen and be aware of the instrument.”
The path to jhāna. The Buddha's own awakening was sparked by remembering the joy of deep meditation (jhāna). In calm meditation (samatha), mindfulness and concentration are an ancient, inseparable pairing. Mindfulness sustains attention, preventing distractions, while concentration brings unification and peace.
Stages of calm. The Discourse on the Fruits of the Life of the Recluse outlines the meditative journey, where mindfulness is aroused continuously, guarding the senses, fostering contentment, and then leading into the four jhānas. As the mind deepens, mindfulness becomes increasingly subtle and refined, crucial for sustaining the profound happiness and equanimity of these states.
Wisdom and calm. Mindfulness acts as the bridge between wisdom and calm, ensuring they work together. Wisdom without calm can be cold or detached, while calm without wisdom lacks true insight. Like the two wings of a bird, they are held in balance by mindfulness, allowing the meditator to enter and emerge from deep states with clarity and control.
5. The Four Foundations: A Graduated Path to Liberation
“The text shows a way of being in the world—without being ensnared by categories, identifications, or limitations that prevent the mind from being free—in any situation.”
A comprehensive manual. The Mahāsatipaṭṭhāna-sutta is a foundational text, outlining four domains for mindfulness: body, feelings, mind, and dhammas (events/phenomena). Each domain is contemplated internally, externally, and both, with ardency and clear comprehension, guiding the practitioner towards liberation.
Progressive dissolution. The sutta offers a step-by-step journey, starting with the individual body and gradually expanding awareness. It moves from concrete physical sensations to the subtle arising and ceasing of feelings, mental states, and ultimately, all phenomena. This process dissolves attachment to a fixed "self," revealing impermanence, unsatisfactoriness, and nonself.
Freedom in every moment. By systematically examining these foundations, the mind learns to experience events without clinging or being ensnared by labels. This leads to a firm foundation in all worlds—the conditioned and the unconditioned—allowing the practitioner to return to daily life with different eyes, seeing the path to freedom in every situation.
6. Mindfulness in Buddhist Psychology: Inherently Skillful and Ethical
“If there is a bad mood, for example, and one is mindful of that, there will be, according to this system, some moments when the mind is skillful and has mindfulness and some moments where it does not.”
Mapping the mind. Abhidhamma, the "higher teaching," provides a precise psychological system, analyzing mental and physical phenomena moment by moment. It defines "skillful" (kusala) consciousness and asserts that mindfulness is a defining feature of all skillful states, transforming how universal factors like contact, feeling, and volition operate.
The company of the beautiful. When mindfulness arises, it is never alone. It is always accompanied by other "beautiful" mental factors, such as:
- Faith
- Self-respect
- Regard for consequences
- Nongreed (generosity)
- Nonhate (loving kindness)
- Equipoise (equanimity)
These factors ensure an intuitive ethical sense, guiding the mind towards actions that are helpful and wholesome.
A liberating system. Abhidhamma offers a practical "checklist" for meditators to understand their mental states, distinguishing skillful from unskillful. It suggests that even a momentary flash of mindful, skillful consciousness contains the potential for the entire path to liberation, encouraging the repetition of wholesome states to sustain their flow and supplant unskillfulness.
7. Mahāyāna's Expansive View: Emptiness and the Bodhisattva Vow
“As long as space abides, and as long as the world abides, so long may I abide, destroying the sufferings of the world.”
A new vehicle. Mahāyāna Buddhism, emerging centuries after the Buddha, introduced profound shifts, emphasizing emptiness, the innate luminosity of the mind, and the universal bodhisattva vow—a commitment to liberate all sentient beings before one's own final awakening. This expansive vision re-contextualized mindfulness.
Exchange of self and others. Śāntideva's Bodhicaryāvatāra champions the "exchange of self and others," where one protects others as oneself, recognizing that suffering is universal. Mindfulness, in this context, extends its field of awareness to include the infinite ocean of beings, fostering "great compassion" and prioritizing collective liberation over individual salvation.
Emptiness as lived experience. Mahāyāna texts challenge conventional perceptions of reality, arguing that all phenomena are "empty" of inherent existence. Mindfulness, particularly in the Madhyamaka school, becomes a tool for investigating and dissolving fixed categories of body, feelings, mind, and events, leading to a direct experience of emptiness and the interconnectedness of all things.
8. East Asian Adaptations: Devotion, Kōans, and Everyday Practice
“A special transmission outside the scriptures / Without depending on words or letters / Directly pointing to the human mind; / Seeing the innate nature, one becomes a Buddha.”
Cultural integration. Buddhism in China, Korea, and Japan adapted to local traditions like Daoism and Confucianism, leading to unique expressions of mindfulness. The emphasis shifted from individual self-abandonment to a more communal and socially integrated practice, often incorporating devotion and the transformative power of everyday actions.
Diverse techniques. East Asian schools developed distinct methods for arousing mindfulness:
- Pure Land: Recitation of Amitābha Buddha's name (niàn-fó) as a constant, background mindfulness, linking inner peace to an auspicious heavenly realm.
- Chan (Zen): Use of gōng’àn (kōans)—paradoxical questions—to disrupt discursive thought and trigger sudden awakening, fostering constant, non-conceptual awareness.
- Huayan/Tiantai: Emphasized the interpenetration of all phenomena (Indra's net) and the inherent buddha nature, making every mindful action a reflection of the vast universe.
Mindfulness in action. The principle of "a day without work is a day without food" in Chan monasteries highlights the value of mindful labor. Everyday activities like sweeping the floor, tea ceremonies (chadō), or calligraphy (dōs) become profound expressions of mindfulness, transforming routine into a graceful enactment of the awakened mind.
9. Tibetan Buddhism: Visualization and Lineage as Mindfulness Aids
“When the secret of recollection is revealed, / every memory is but an illumination / of self-knowledge in the ever-present state, / untainted by ego consciousness.”
A rich tapestry. Tibetan Buddhism, influenced by Indian tantric traditions, integrates vibrant rituals, visualizations, and a deep reverence for lineage. Mindfulness is cultivated through practices that engage the entire being, from physical prostrations to complex mental evocations of deities.
Visualization as refined mindfulness. Deity visualization practices, like Bhaiṣajyaguru, require highly refined mindfulness. The practitioner meticulously creates an internal world of offerings, invocations, and mantras, sustaining a detailed mental image. This process:
- Engages all senses and the body through gestures (mudrās)
- Develops subtle attention to internal states
- Temporarily suspends external distractions
- Culminates in the dissolution of the visualization into emptiness, fostering non-attachment.
Lineage and collective memory. The remembrance of incarnate lamas and teachers, through biographies, songs, and the selection of new rebirths, instills a deep, collective mindfulness of the tradition's history and teachings. This living connection to the past reawakens wisdom and compassion in the present, extending awareness to all beings as part of a larger, interconnected vow.
10. Breathing Mindfulness: The Sublime Root Practice for Calm and Insight
“The breath is impermanent, often unsatisfactory, and cannot be owned. Therefore, it is a natural object for insight practice and for the cultivation of an understanding of the three signs of existence: impermanence (aniccā), dissatisfaction (dukkha), and nonself (anattā).”
The "most sublime" object. Breathing mindfulness (Ānāpānasati) is revered as the "root" meditation, suitable for anyone, anytime. It naturally trains the five faculties (faith, vigor, mindfulness, concentration, wisdom) and is a direct path to understanding the three signs of existence, leading to both deep calm (samatha) and liberating insight (vipassanā).
Sixteen stages of awareness. The Ānāpānasati-sutta outlines sixteen stages in four tetrads, progressively deepening awareness of the breath in relation to:
- Body: Long/short breaths, experiencing the whole breath-body, tranquilizing bodily formations.
- Feelings: Experiencing joy, happiness, mental formations, tranquilizing mental formations.
- Mind: Experiencing the mind, gladdening, concentrating, and releasing the mind.
- Dhammas: Contemplating impermanence, dispassion, cessation, and relinquishment.
These stages weave through the seven factors of awakening, guiding the mind to equanimity.
Varied approaches. Different teachers emphasize distinct aspects:
- Buddhadāsa: Focuses on investigation, joy, and insight, noting breath changes.
- Traditional Thai: Emphasizes consciously chosen breath lengths for developing flexibility between jhānas.
- Nyanaponika Thera: Advocates "bare attention" to the abdomen for insight, allowing the breath to deepen naturally.
- Chan/Zen: Views the breath as a "swinging door" to penetrate the nature of "I."
All approaches stress the importance of a teacher and integrating breath awareness into daily life.
11. Modern Mindfulness: Benefits and the Importance of Context
“Mindfulness, it seems, is flexible, intuitively ethical, and attentive and respectful of all beings, including oneself.”
Secular success. The modern secular mindfulness movement, pioneered by Jon Kabat-Zinn's Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR), has successfully adapted Buddhist practices for mental health and stress reduction. Its core definition—"Paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and nonjudgmentally"—has proven highly effective in therapeutic contexts.
Beyond "bare attention." While concepts like "bare attention" and "nonjudgmental awareness" are valuable practical guidelines, they represent specific aspects rather than the full scope of mindfulness in Buddhism. Traditional Buddhist understanding emphasizes that mindfulness is inherently ethical, discriminating what is helpful, and always accompanied by other wholesome mental factors.
The wholeness of things. In Buddhist theory and practice, mindfulness is intertwined with:
- Ethical appreciation: Guiding actions towards well-being for self and others.
- Interconnectedness: Fostering a sense of connection with all beings.
- Flexibility and good humor: Essential for navigating mental patterns without rigidity.
It's a dynamic capacity that sustains psychological health and balance, leading to a "wholeness of things" where separation dissolves and wisdom arises.
Last updated:
Review Summary
Mindfulness by Sarah Shaw receives mostly positive reviews (3.92/5 stars). Readers praise its comprehensive survey of mindfulness across Buddhist traditions, from ancient India through modern secular applications. Reviewers appreciate Shaw's dual expertise as Oxford scholar and meditation practitioner, noting her engaging writing style and extensive bibliography. The book traces "sati" through Theravada, Mahayana, and Vajrayana traditions while emphasizing mindfulness's ethical dimensions. Some critics find it overly academic or technical, particularly early chapters defining terminology. Most recommend it as essential reading for understanding mindfulness's deep historical and philosophical roots beyond contemporary usage.
