Plot Summary
Childhood Roots, Adult Wounds
Wren and Ellis meet as children in Spunes, Oregon, their lives entwined from the start. Their friendship grows into a deep, passionate love, but life's hardships—teen pregnancy, early marriage, and the pressure of responsibility—leave scars. Both become caretakers, always putting others first, but struggle to communicate their own needs. Their love is both a source of comfort and pain, evolving as they grow up together, but eventually, the weight of unspoken wounds and unmet expectations leads to their divorce. Even years later, the echoes of their shared past haunt them, making it difficult to move on or find closure.
Letters Across the Fireline
While working as a firefighter far from home, Ellis receives a care package from Wren's bakery, meant for a stranger. Inside is a letter from "Salem Meridian" (Wren's maiden name), asking about two horses lost in a wildfire. The letter is witty, vulnerable, and unmistakably Wren. Though she doesn't know he'll receive it, Ellis is drawn to reply, using only the initial "L." Their anonymous correspondence becomes a lifeline, allowing them to share hopes, regrets, and memories without the baggage of their real identities. Through these letters, they rediscover the intimacy and humor that once defined their relationship.
Stranger, Still Familiar
As the letters continue, Wren and Ellis—still unaware of each other's true identity—find themselves opening up in ways they never could before. They discuss their failed marriage, their son Sam, and the ache of wanting more from life. The anonymity gives them permission to be honest about their pain, their mistakes, and their lingering feelings. Each letter is a mix of playful banter and raw confession, and both begin to hope for closure, or perhaps something more. The search for the lost horses becomes a metaphor for their own longing to know if love can survive disaster.
Hope, Horses, and Healing
News finally arrives: the two horses survived, found together after the fire. The relief is bittersweet, as it forces Wren and Ellis to confront the reality of their own separation. The horses' endurance through chaos and their reunion becomes a symbol of hope—maybe not all is lost, and maybe some bonds can be restored. The letters end, but the emotional impact lingers. Both Wren and Ellis are left wondering if they, too, could find their way back to each other, or if their time has truly passed.
Co-Parenting and Old Chords
Despite their divorce, Wren and Ellis remain united in raising their son, Sam. When Sam is accepted to his dream college, the family comes together in celebration, stirring up old memories and unresolved feelings. The prospect of Sam leaving home forces Wren and Ellis to confront the emptiness between them. Their interactions are careful, polite, but charged with unspoken longing. The shared pride in their son is a reminder of what they once built together, and what they might still salvage.
Accidental Encounters, Lingering Tension
A series of accidental encounters—at the barn, family gatherings, and around town—keep Wren and Ellis in each other's orbit. Each meeting is fraught with tension, nostalgia, and the ache of what's been lost. They struggle to maintain boundaries, but the familiarity and chemistry between them are undeniable. Both are haunted by the question: is it possible to start over, or are they destined to remain strangers with a shared past?
Family, Friends, and Ghosts
The small town of Spunes is a web of interconnected relationships. Wren's best friend Sage, Ellis's siblings, and their extended family all play roles in their journey. The community's gossip, support, and expectations add pressure, but also provide comfort. Family crises, like Silas's accident and Sage's new romance, force Wren and Ellis to reevaluate what matters most. The ghosts of their marriage—resentment, grief, and unspoken love—hover over every interaction, making it hard to move forward.
The End of the Letters
With the horses found and the fire contained, Ellis ends the anonymous correspondence. Wren is left with a sense of loss, realizing how much the letters meant to her. The abrupt end is a catalyst for both to reflect on what they truly want. Wren tries to date, seeking closure, but every new relationship pales in comparison to what she had with Ellis. The ache of unfinished business grows, and both are forced to confront the reality that closure may only come from facing each other, not from moving on.
Holidays and Heartbreak
Thanksgiving and Christmas bring the family together, but also highlight the distance between Wren and Ellis. A misunderstanding—Wren seeing a text from another woman on Ellis's phone—deepens her sense of loss and jealousy, even as she tries to convince herself she's ready to move on. Ellis, meanwhile, is working on himself, going to therapy, and trying to find closure. The holidays become a crucible, forcing both to acknowledge the depth of their unresolved feelings and the pain of loving someone from afar.
A Proposal for Closure
With Sam leaving for college, Ellis proposes a road trip for just the two of them after dropping Sam off. He frames it as a chance for closure, but both know it's an opportunity to see if there's anything left between them. Wren is hesitant, fearing old wounds will reopen, but agrees on the condition that they use the trip to honestly examine their past—no romance, just truth. The stage is set for a journey that will test their ability to forgive, communicate, and possibly love again.
The Road Trip Pact
Wren and Ellis set ground rules for the trip: separate rooms, no sex, and a commitment to talk through their history. They agree to revisit the moments that broke them, to share their journals, and to ask the hard questions. The journey is awkward at first, but the physical proximity and shared experiences begin to break down their defenses. Old habits resurface, but so do the qualities that made them fall in love. The road trip becomes a crucible for vulnerability, honesty, and the possibility of reconciliation.
Revisiting the Past Together
As they travel, Wren and Ellis revisit the highs and lows of their relationship. They talk about their early love, the challenges of young parenthood, the pain of infertility, and the slow erosion of their marriage. Each conversation is a step toward healing, but also a risk—old resentments and misunderstandings surface, threatening to derail their progress. Yet, through laughter, tears, and shared memories, they begin to see each other with new eyes, recognizing the ways they both failed and the ways they still fit.
Unromantic Plans, Unraveling Hearts
Despite their best efforts to keep things platonic, the intimacy of the trip—shared meals, inside jokes, and physical closeness—rekindles their desire. A series of mishaps, including a comically disastrous cooking class and a pepper burn incident, force them to rely on each other and let down their guards. The unromantic settings become backdrops for genuine connection, and the lines between friendship, closure, and romance blur. Both are forced to admit that their feelings never truly faded.
Vineyard Confessions
In a vineyard, fueled by wine and honesty, Wren and Ellis confess their deepest fears and regrets. They talk openly about the pain of their infertility struggles, the resentment that built up, and the ways they failed to communicate. The confessions are raw and painful, but also cathartic. For the first time, they truly see each other—not as the people they were, but as the people they are now. The vineyard becomes a place of forgiveness, hope, and the tentative beginning of something new.
Pepper Burn and Vulnerability
A mishap with hot peppers during a cooking class leaves Ellis in pain and vulnerable, forcing Wren to care for him in a way that strips away all pretense. The physical comedy of the situation is matched by the emotional intimacy it creates. In the aftermath, they share a night of tenderness and passion, breaking their own rules but finding healing in each other's arms. The experience cements their renewed bond, showing that love can survive even the most ridiculous disasters.
Truths, Fights, and Forgiveness
As the trip nears its end, Wren and Ellis confront the hardest truths: Ellis never truly wanted another child, and Wren felt abandoned and unloved during their struggles. The fight is raw, but it leads to a breakthrough—both admit their fears, their failures, and their enduring love. Forgiveness is not easy, but it is real. They realize that their marriage ended not because they stopped loving each other, but because they stopped fighting for each other. Now, they choose to fight again, together.
Letters Revealed, Secrets Unveiled
Back home, Wren discovers the stack of anonymous letters and realizes Ellis was her pen pal all along. The revelation is both a shock and a relief, confirming the depth of their connection and the sincerity of his feelings. They talk openly about the deception, the reasons behind it, and the hope it gave them both. The letters become a symbol of their journey—proof that even when they were lost, they were still reaching for each other. With all secrets laid bare, they are finally free to choose each other again.
Choosing Each Other Again
With their wounds acknowledged and their love rekindled, Wren and Ellis decide to remarry. The proposal is spontaneous, heartfelt, and a testament to their growth. They involve their son, their families, and their community in a small, meaningful ceremony. The wedding is not about starting over, but about honoring the journey that brought them back together. Surrounded by friends, family, and the symbols of their shared life, they vow to keep choosing each other, every day, for everything left of forever.
Homecoming and New Vows
Wren and Ellis return home, not as the people they were, but as partners who have earned their second chance. They blend their families, their traditions, and their dreams, creating a life that honors both the pain and the joy of their past. Their new vows are written on their skin and in their hearts—a promise to fight, to forgive, and to love for everything left of forever. The story ends not with a perfect happily ever after, but with the hard-won hope that love, when chosen again and again, can endure.
Characters
Wren Byrd
Wren is a woman shaped by early responsibility, having become a mother and wife before she was ready. She is fiercely loving, creative, and deeply loyal, but struggles with self-doubt and the fear that she is "too much" or "not enough." Her identity is tied to her roles as mother, baker, and caretaker, often at the expense of her own needs. The divorce from Ellis leaves her unmoored, unable to find closure or move on. Through anonymous letters, therapy, and the road trip, Wren learns to confront her pain, own her desires, and ask for what she needs. Her journey is one of reclaiming agency, rediscovering hope, and choosing love not out of obligation, but out of genuine want.
Ellis Byrd
Ellis is the archetype of the strong, silent caretaker. As the eldest sibling, he took on parental responsibilities early, and later, as a young husband and father, he shouldered the burdens of providing and protecting. His love for Wren is deep but often unspoken, and his fear of failure leads him to withdraw rather than communicate. The trauma of infertility, family crises, and the eventual divorce leave him emotionally isolated. The anonymous letters allow him to express vulnerability, and therapy helps him confront his patterns. Ellis's arc is about learning to let go of control, trust others with his pain, and fight for love with openness and humility.
Sam Byrd
Sam is the beloved son of Wren and Ellis, embodying the best of both parents. His milestones—graduation, college acceptance—serve as catalysts for his parents' journey. Sam is mature, compassionate, and wise beyond his years, often acting as a peacemaker. His impending departure forces Wren and Ellis to confront the void between them and the legacy they want to leave. Sam's happiness and stability are both a source of pride and a reminder of what his parents once shared. He is the living proof that their love, however flawed, created something beautiful.
Sage Byrd
Sage is Ellis's sister and Wren's best friend, a grounding presence throughout the story. She is intuitive, nurturing, and unafraid to call out the truth, even when it's uncomfortable. Sage's own romantic journey parallels Wren's, and her happiness becomes both an inspiration and a challenge. She is the glue that holds the extended family together, offering wisdom, humor, and unconditional support. Sage's role is to remind Wren and Ellis of their worth and to model the courage it takes to choose happiness.
Silas Byrd
Silas, Ellis's brother, is a survivor—literally and emotionally. His near-fatal accident and subsequent recovery force the family to confront their vulnerabilities. Silas uses humor to mask pain, but his loyalty to both Wren and Ellis is unwavering. He is the first to challenge Ellis's self-sacrifice and to encourage both to seek help. Silas's journey is about healing, accepting support, and embracing change. He represents the messy, imperfect love that binds families together.
Micah Byrd
Micah, the youngest Byrd brother, is a free spirit, often on the move and chasing new dreams. His struggles with identity and purpose mirror the larger themes of the novel. Micah provides levity, but also moments of insight, reminding the family not to take life too seriously. His presence underscores the importance of forgiveness, second chances, and the freedom to reinvent oneself.
Savannah "Savvy" Meridian
Wren's mother, Savvy, is a model of resilience and self-sufficiency. Having raised Wren alone and built a successful business, she is both a role model and a cautionary tale. Her battle with illness and her late-in-life romance challenge Wren's assumptions about independence and happiness. Savvy's journey is about accepting help, embracing change, and finding joy in unexpected places.
Sage's Partner (Fisher)
Fisher, Sage's partner, is a calming influence and a source of stability. His relationship with Sage mirrors the themes of vulnerability, trust, and the courage to start over. Fisher's integration into the Byrd family highlights the power of chosen family and the importance of community in healing old wounds.
Lennon Kirby
Lennon, a young firefighter on Ellis's crew, serves as a confidante and sounding board. Her youthful perspective and candid advice push Ellis to confront his feelings and take risks. Lennon's role is to challenge the status quo, inject humor, and remind the protagonists that life is meant to be lived, not just endured.
The Town of Spunes
Spunes, Oregon, is more than a setting—it is a character in its own right. The town's smallness, interconnectedness, and history shape every decision Wren and Ellis make. Spunes is both a comfort and a constraint, a place of memory and possibility. Its rhythms, gossip, and traditions provide the backdrop for the story's exploration of belonging, identity, and the meaning of home.
Plot Devices
Dual Timeline and Epistolary Structure
The novel employs a dual timeline, weaving together the present-day journey with flashbacks and journal entries that reveal the history of Wren and Ellis's relationship. The anonymous letter exchange serves as both a plot device and a metaphor for the distance—and potential closeness—between them. This structure allows for deep character introspection, gradual revelation of secrets, and a sense of inevitability as the past and present converge.
Symbolism of Horses and Fire
The lost horses in the wildfire are a central symbol, mirroring Wren and Ellis's own journey through chaos and separation. Their survival offers hope that not all is lost, and that reunion is possible. Fire, both literal and metaphorical, represents destruction, transformation, and the forging of new beginnings. These symbols are woven throughout the narrative, providing emotional resonance and thematic depth.
Family and Community as Mirrors
The extended family, friends, and town serve as mirrors, reflecting Wren and Ellis's struggles and growth. Their stories—of love, loss, and resilience—provide context, support, and sometimes pressure. The community's involvement in their journey underscores the interconnectedness of personal and collective healing.
Road Trip as Emotional Journey
The road trip is both a literal and figurative journey, forcing Wren and Ellis into close quarters and new environments. Each stop along the way prompts reflection, confrontation, and growth. The rules they set—and inevitably break—create tension and opportunities for vulnerability. The trip's structure provides a framework for revisiting the past, testing the present, and imagining a future together.
Foreshadowing and Callbacks
The novel is rich with foreshadowing—small details, jokes, and traditions introduced early on resurface at pivotal moments. The origami birds, the bakery, the horses, and even the playlists all serve as callbacks, reinforcing the themes of memory, continuity, and the possibility of renewal.
Analysis
Left of Forever is a deeply moving exploration of love's endurance in the face of life's relentless challenges. At its core, the novel asks whether love is a matter of fate, choice, or both—and whether it can survive not just the storms of life, but the slow erosion of neglect, resentment, and silence. Through Wren and Ellis's journey, Tarah DeWitt examines the complexities of communication, the necessity of vulnerability, and the courage required to forgive—not just each other, but oneself. The story's structure—blending past and present, letter and action—mirrors the messy, nonlinear process of healing and reconciliation. The supporting cast and the town of Spunes ground the narrative in community, reminding readers that no relationship exists in a vacuum. Ultimately, Left of Forever is a testament to the power of second chances, the importance of choosing love every day, and the hope that, even after devastation, something beautiful can be rebuilt. The novel's lesson is clear: lasting love is not about perfection, but about the willingness to keep showing up, to keep fighting, and to keep choosing each other for everything left of forever.
Last updated:
