Key Takeaways
1. The Gray Man's Elusive Debut: The Francis McDonnell Abduction
Strangers stood out, so when the old man shuffled into view Mrs. McDonnell immediately noticed him.
A summer's day. On July 14, 1924, in Staten Island, eight-year-old Francis McDonnell vanished after being seen walking into Charlton's Woods with a peculiar, shabby old man. This "gray man" was observed by Mrs. McDonnell and a neighbor, George Stern, who, in a more innocent era, assumed Francis knew the man. This fatal miscalculation set the stage for a brutal crime.
Brutal discovery. The following morning, Francis's body was found severely beaten and strangled with his own suspenders, his clothes ripped, suggesting a sexual motive. The outrage was immediate, especially among the police, as Francis was the son of an officer. A massive search involving hundreds of officers and volunteers ensued, but the frail appearance of the old man initially cast doubt on his sole culpability.
Leads go cold. Despite extensive door-to-door inquiries, suspect roundups, and public appeals, the case quickly stalled. Numerous false leads emerged, including two hospital orderlies, an insane asylum escapee, and vagrants. One man, John Eskowski, was lynched by a mob before being cleared. The "gray man" had appeared out of nowhere to commit his atrocity and then vanished without a trace, leaving the community in fear and the police baffled.
2. Billy Gaffney's Vanishing Act: The "Boogeyman" Strikes Again
“The boogeyman took him,” was Billy’s solemn reply.
Another disappearance. On February 11, 1927, three-year-old Billy Gaffney disappeared from his Brooklyn tenement building while playing with his friend, Billy Beaton. Beaton's father found his son on the roof, who chillingly stated, "The boogeyman took him," a claim dismissed by police as childish fantasy. This abduction mirrored the McDonnell case in its suddenness and the elusive nature of the perpetrator.
Massive search. The police launched one of New York City's largest searches, with hundreds of officers and civilian volunteers scouring every corner of the city. Despite extensive efforts, including dredging the Gowanas Canal, no trace of Billy Gaffney was ever found. The case was officially treated as an abduction, though investigators initially suspected the boy had simply wandered off.
Crucial lead. Weeks later, a trolley car conductor, Anthony Barone, reported seeing an elderly man matching the "gray man's" description board his trolley with a crying child resembling Billy on the night of the disappearance. The man asked for directions to the Staten Island ferry. This lead, corroborated by others, was vigorously pursued but ultimately led nowhere, and the case went cold, leaving Billy's mother in deep despair.
3. Grace Budd's Tragic Lure: The Deceptive "Frank Howard"
“My name is Frank Howard, Mrs. Budd. I’m here with an offer that your boy might find interesting.”
Answering an ad. In May 1928, Edward Budd, 18, placed a classified ad seeking country work. On May 28, an elderly man, "Frank Howard," arrived at the Budd's Manhattan apartment, claiming to be a wealthy farmer from Long Island. He offered Edward a generous $15 a week, plus a job for his friend Willie Korman, instantly gaining the trust of the struggling Budd family.
Charming the family. Howard, neatly dressed and kindly, charmed Mrs. Budd with gifts of pot cheese and strawberries from his supposed farm. He gave five-year-old Beatrice a nickel and captivated ten-year-old Grace, praising her beauty and giving her 50 cents to buy candy. The Budds, desperate for their son to find work, saw no harm in the seemingly benevolent old man.
The fatal invitation. On Sunday, June 3, Howard returned, apologizing for a delay and inviting Grace to a niece's birthday party in "a fine building at 137th and Columbus." Despite initial hesitation, Albert Budd, wanting his daughter to "see much good times," gave permission. The Budds watched as their pretty, ten-year-old daughter, dressed in her best, walked away with the man they believed to be Frank Howard, unaware of the horror that awaited her.
4. The Chilling Confession Letter: A Breakthrough in Depravity
So horrific was this letter than King was at first tempted to disregard it as the ravings of some foul lunatic.
A planted story. Six years after Grace Budd's disappearance, Detective William King, obsessed with the cold case, planted a false story in the New York Daily News about a "cokie" knowing details of Grace's fate. This desperate tactic aimed to flush out the killer, and it worked. On November 12, 1934, a letter arrived at the Budd's apartment.
Unspeakable contents. Edward Budd read the letter, his face blanching as he absorbed its depraved contents. The anonymous author, claiming to be "Frank Howard," detailed his cannibalistic past in China, his taste for human flesh, and then chillingly confessed to luring Grace away, strangling her, dismembering her body, and roasting her "sweet and tender little ass" over nine days. The letter explicitly stated, "She died a virgin."
Authenticity confirmed. Despite its horrific nature, King recognized the ring of authenticity in the letter's specific details, such as the pot cheese and strawberries. Crucially, the letter mentioned an address, 409 East 100th Street, which fell within the police's earlier search area. A comparison of the handwriting with Howard's 1928 Western Union message confirmed it was a match, finally providing a concrete lead.
5. Detective King's Relentless Pursuit: Unmasking the Killer
King’s sleuthing instincts though, were abuzz with anticipation. Maybe, just maybe, his quest was nearing an end.
The envelope's clue. The back flap of the confession letter's envelope bore a partially obliterated address and the emblem "N.Y.P.C.B.A." (New York Private Chauffer’s Benevolent Association). Detective King deciphered "627 Lexington Avenue" and traced the stationary to the union. A young member, Lee Sicowski, admitted taking stationary, leading King to his previous address: 200 East 52nd Street, Room 7.
"Mr. Fish." At the new address, landlady Frieda Schneider recognized King's description, identifying the former tenant as "Mr. Fish." The register confirmed the name: Albert H. Fish. King compared the handwriting to the confession letter and the 1928 telegram—it was a match. Schneider also revealed Fish's son sent him a monthly check from North Carolina, which she held for him, and he was due to collect it mid-December.
The capture. King immediately set up a round-the-clock stakeout, even renting Room 7 himself. On December 13, 1934, Mrs. Schneider frantically called: Fish had arrived. King rushed back, confronting the frail old man. Fish, attempting to slash King with a razor blade, was quickly subdued. "I've got you now," King declared, ending a six-year hunt.
6. The Horrific Truth of Grace Budd's Murder: A Cannibal's Account
“I’m the man who took Grace Budd,” Fish said. “I took her from her home on June 3, 1928. I brought her to Westchester and I killed her that same afternoon.”
Initial denial, then confession. At police headquarters, Fish initially denied involvement in Grace Budd's kidnapping, despite admitting to writing the confession letter and posing as Frank Howard. Faced with King's evidence of potential identification by the Budd family and the vendor, Fish finally broke, confessing to taking Grace and killing her in Westchester that same afternoon.
The plan's evolution. Fish revealed his original target was Edward Budd, intending to overpower and mutilate him. However, upon seeing Grace, his plan shifted. He purchased a cleaver, saw, and butcher's knife, then cunningly lured Grace away under the pretense of a birthday party. He was astonished by the Budds' trust, allowing their daughter to leave with a stranger.
The gruesome details. Fish recounted taking Grace by train to Worthington, Westchester, and leading her to a secluded, abandoned "Wisteria Cottage." He stripped naked, arranged his tools, and called Grace inside. When she saw him, she screamed, "I'll tell momma!" Fish strangled her, then decapitated her with his tools, catching the blood in a paint bucket. He dismembered her body, disposing of the parts in nearby bushes and the head in an outhouse, returning days later for a more thorough disposal.
7. Physical Evidence and Public Outcry: Confirming the Atrocity
The jawbone was missing but it was unmistakably a skull, and judging from the size, the skull of a child.
Journey to Wisteria Cottage. To verify Fish's confession, detectives drove him to Wisteria Cottage in Westchester County on December 14, 1934. Despite the darkness and frigid air, Fish, almost excited, led them through the house, re-enacting the murder and dismemberment in chilling detail. This re-enactment was crucial for corroborating his story.
Discovery of remains. Outside, Fish led them to the spot where he'd disposed of Grace's body. Detective King soon found a small, yellowed skull, unmistakably that of a child, along with bone fragments. This discovery confirmed the horrific truth of Grace's fate. Local authorities, including the Greenburgh Police Chief and Westchester District Attorney, were called to secure the scene.
Public and family reaction. The news broke, drawing a frenzy of reporters and curious onlookers to Wisteria Cottage. The Budd family, awakened by a reporter, received the devastating news with stoic resignation. While the pain of their loss was still immense, the discovery of Grace's remains and the capture of her killer brought a sense of closure after six agonizing years. Edward Budd, upon seeing Fish, lunged at him, screaming, "You dirty old bastard!"
8. Albert Fish's Twisted Past: A Lifetime of Perversion
Fish’s life was one of unparalleled perversity,” he wrote. “There was no known perversion that he did not practice, and practice frequently.”
Early trauma. Born Hamilton Fish in 1870, Albert changed his name to escape childhood taunts. His father died when he was five, leading to his placement in an orphanage where he endured frequent beatings. This early trauma ignited his lifelong sadomasochistic tendencies, finding sexual arousal in both inflicting and receiving pain, and developing disturbing behaviors like coprophagia and urophagia.
Escalating depravity. Moving to New York, Fish became a painter, a job that gave him access to unattended children, whom he would lure to basements for rape and assault, often targeting black children knowing police were less likely to investigate. His marriage and six children did not curb his perversions; his wife's desertion in 1917 intensified his religious mania and self-harm, including inserting sewing needles into his groin.
Obscene letters. Fish also developed a habit of writing obscene letters, often posing as a Hollywood producer seeking a caretaker for his "mentally deficient" son who required beatings. He would escalate the depravity, eventually suggesting he wanted to drink the women's urine and eat their feces. One such letter led to his arrest in 1930, but Bellevue staff deemed him merely eccentric and harmless, unaware of his true monstrousness.
9. Connecting the Dots: Fish as a Serial Predator
What is remarkable about this story is the startling similarity to the Grace Budd case.
Unsolved cases resurface. Following Fish's arrest, detectives from various jurisdictions visited him, hoping to clear their cold cases. Witnesses also came forward, identifying Fish as the man who had attacked or attempted to attack them years prior. The similarities in Fish's modus operandi across these cases were striking, revealing a pattern of predatory behavior.
Benjamin Eiseman's escape. Benjamin Eiseman recounted an encounter ten years earlier, where Fish, posing as a house painter, lured him to a deserted Staten Island cabin. Eiseman was saved by an elderly black man's warning: "I seen many kids go into that house, but none of them ever came out." This near-miss closely mirrored the Grace Budd abduction, with a train journey and a secluded house.
McDonnell and Gaffney. Fish was also linked to the Francis McDonnell and Billy Gaffney cases. Hans Kiel identified Fish as the "gray man" who tried to lure his daughter into the woods just days before Francis's murder in 1924. Trolley driver Joseph Meehan identified Fish as the man seen with Billy Gaffney on the night of his disappearance in 1927. These connections solidified Fish's identity as a serial child predator.
10. The Insanity Defense and Cannibalism: A Legal Battle for Sanity
“Fish’s life was one of unparalleled perversity,” he wrote. “There was no known perversion that he did not practice, and practice frequently.”
The insanity plea. Fish's trial for Grace Budd's murder began in March 1935, with his defense attorney, James Dempsey, immediately pursuing an insanity defense. Dempsey brought in renowned alienists (psychiatrists) Dr. Smith Ely Jelliffe and Dr. Frederic Wertheim to counter the state's experts, who had declared Fish legally sane despite his "abnormal" tendencies.
Wertheim's revelations. Dr. Wertheim, who spent extensive time with Fish, found him to be a sadist of "incredible cruelty" with a primary interest in boys aged four to sixteen. Fish confessed to Wertheim that he had raped at least 100 children, not primarily for sexual relations, but to inflict pain. Wertheim's testimony painted a picture of a man consumed by every known perversion.
The cannibalism confession. Crucially, Fish finally admitted to Wertheim that he had cannibalized Grace Budd. He described drinking her blood, slicing four pounds of flesh from her buttocks and abdomen, and cooking it in a stew with vegetables and bacon. He consumed her body over nine days, experiencing "absolute sexual excitement." This shocking admission was Dempsey's strongest argument for Fish's insanity, believing no sane man could commit such an act.
11. The Verdict and Final Confessions: Justice and Unveiled Horrors
“We find the defendant guilty as charged,” Partelow intoned somberly.
Dempsey's plea. In his closing argument, James Dempsey described Grace Budd's murder as "fiendish, brutal and inexcusable," arguing that only an insane man could commit such an atrocity, especially one who would then dine on his victim's flesh. He questioned how a sane man could plan such a crime so openly and then clean his bloody hands in the front yard, appealing to the jury for mercy.
Gallagher's counter. Assistant District Attorney Elbert F. Gallagher countered by focusing on the facts of the cold-blooded murder and reminding the jury of Grace's screams. He emphasized that the prosecution's alienists had declared Fish legally sane, arguing that Fish's perversions, while revolting, did not equate to legal insanity. He urged the jury to deliver justice for the people of the state.
Guilty verdict and execution. After two hours of deliberation, the jury returned a verdict of "guilty as charged." Fish visibly slumped, having hoped for Matteawan, the hospital for the criminally insane. The verdict carried a mandatory death sentence. Before his execution on January 16, 1936, Fish confessed to the murders of Francis McDonnell and Billy Gaffney, detailing the horrific cannibalism of Billy, including roasting his "sweet fat little behind" and making a stew of his ears, nose, and face.
Last updated:
